One corrections officer spread a false rumor that a new female officer at the state prison in South Windham was a stripper.
Another one called her “Genitalia,” instead of her real name, which also began with a “G.”
She was asked by a colleague if he could measure her buttocks. When she said no, he did it anyway.
When her complaints were not taken seriously, she quit and filed sexual harassment and retaliation complaints against the Department of Corrections with the Maine Human Rights Commission.
The state settled. Cost to taxpayers: $20,000.
A beginning state trooper — a male — placed under the supervision of a male sergeant, was taken on assignments to secluded locations, had his inner thigh rubbed and listened to talk about skinny-dipping, according to the trooper’s sworn statement.
The trooper got a transfer, but the sergeant called him regularly, making sexual comments and suggested they take a sauna together in the nude.
The trooper filed a harassment complaint. The state settled out of court. Cost to taxpayers: $50,000.
A park manager says she was threatened with losing her job after she refused to move out of her state housing so her boss, the commissioner of conservation, could use it to entertain guests.
He denied the whistleblower and sex discrimination complaint. The state settled out of court for $30,000.
A corrections officer was threatened in a website run by anonymous corrections staff after she complained of sexual harassment. Cost to taxpayers: $137,500.
A Maine Center for Public Interest Reporting investigation found the state has settled 45 cases — including some alleging retaliation in the human services department, disability discrimination in Public Safety and sex discrimination in Corrections — in the past 10 years.
The cost to taxpayers for a range of alleged bad behavior by state employees toward their fellow workers in that time: $1,846,118.
The state spent another half-million dollars to defend itself in the cases.
Nearly half of the cases — 44 percent — came from two law enforcement departments: Corrections and Public Safety, home of the state police. Those 20 settlements alone cost taxpayers more than $1 million.
In all of the settlements, the state admitted no liability.
No tracking by department
State law requires that all new employees receive sexual harassment training their first year in the job, according to Assistant Attorney General Susan Herman.
Herman said her office does not track claims to find out where there might be a chronic problem.
“We have not analyzed the data by department,” she said.
When it comes to punishment for employees found to have harassed a co-worker, Herman said any action is up to the commissioner of the department involved.
Public records do not include any disciplinary action that may have been taken in the 45 cases studied.
David Webbert, an Augusta lawyer who specializes in employment cases — including representing state employees — doubts training alone solves the problem.
“No amount of civil rights training can overcome discriminatory attitudes at the top of an organization,” he said. But, he added, “The state could greatly reduce lawsuits and money settlements — and improve workplace productivity — by basing the evaluation and promotion of managers in a significant part on their record of promoting civil rights.”
Some details kept secret
The settlement agreements — legally binding documents signed by the state and the employee — are often written in a way that prevents full public disclosure.
In 34 of the 45 cases, in return for the settlement, employees and the state agreed not to disclose terms.
The secrecy goes even further in the 21 cases that have nondisparagement clauses. Typically, they state, “Both parties agree that they will not disparage the other.”
That means, for example, the park manager who received the $30,000 was barred, then and forever, from speaking badly of her boss, Patrick McGowan, commissioner of conservation who ran unsuccessfully for governor in 2010.
In 82 percent of the cases, the process began with the employee filing a complaint with the Maine Human Rights Commission, a state agency established in 1971 to investigate complaints of discrimination from public and private employees.
“This discrimination costs the state a lot in employee morale, time and efficiency, and in money towards lawyers’ fees and recovery for the successful employee-litigants,” wrote Amy Sneirson, the commission’s executive director.
“What the public could take away from this data is that bad behavior at work has a tremendous impact,” she said, including on “taxpayers who ultimately subsidize settlements by state agencies.”
Webbert, the employment attorney, said, “Based on representing many state employees … I have observed that the worst problems … are in the law enforcement areas.”
Paid from state budget
Settlement payments don’t come from traditional insurance; the state is self-insured for these cases. The cash comes directly from the state budget.
Each state agency is assessed an annual amount that goes into the state’s selfinsurance budget, which is about $1 million.
The departmental assessment is based on the number of employees and the claims history.
The Department of Corrections, which runs the state’s prisons, is currently assessed $101,000, 10 percent of the total self-insurance budget, while it only has 6.8 percent of the total number of 18,500 state employees. The reason is the disproportionate number of settlements in Corrections.
The department’s discrimination settlements were one reason the Legislature asked its investigative agency to evaluate Corrections in 2009.
An Office of Program Evaluation and Accountability report said intimidation, retaliation and distrust within Corrections kept a lid on exposing internal problems.
Combined, the practices “appear unethical” and “expose the state to unnecessary risks and liabilities,” the OPEGA report said.
Corrections was told to develop a “strategic action plan” addressing the problems. But OPEGA Executive Director Beth Ashcroft said “it was difficult to tell how much progress was being made.”
When the LePage administration took over in 2011, “We learned that wasn’t a whole lot of progress that had been made,” Ashcroft said. “The new administration took it on, and they’ve updated the action plan and reported to the Government Oversight Committee two or three times.”
Laurel Shippee, coordinator of the Equal Employment Opportunity office, said the attorney general’s office added a trainer and ensured a legal expert conducts training in harassment issues.
She said the change was at least partially a reaction to costly settlements.
She also praises a new attitude in Public Safety, which she traced to a new head of the state police, Col. Robert Williams.
Joyce Oreskovich, human resources director for the state, said, “Bob is much more interested in fairness and equity” than previous management.
Oreskovich and Shippee said LePage, early in his tenure, told him their priority was fixing problems that discouraged women from applying for state police jobs.
Oreskovich said LePage “just looked at me and said, ‘Do It.’ ”
The two women said there’s been a shift in Corrections, too, under Commissioner Joseph Ponte.
“I am definitely seeing an interest in swift and firm discipline that they’re not wavering on,” said Shippee.
One of the incidents that let to the OPEGA study was the 2008 case of Pamela Sampson, a corrections officer at the prison in Warren.
In her suit, she said she was sexually harassed by a sergeant who was later fired for sexually harassing another officer.
When she complained, she said they retaliated by investigating her on charges of sexually molesting inmates.
She was later cleared, but ultimately left the job because of concern for her safety.
The state denied she was sexually harassed and that the sergeant was dismissed for harassment, but admits the charges against her “were not substantiated.”
The state settled her claim in 2007 for $66,000. Only six of the 45 claims were settled for a higher amount.
Sampson’s settlement has a nondisclosure and nondisparagement clause.
“If you speak about anything against these guys (in Corrections), it’s not good,” she said. “They use retaliation. That’s why everything was thrown out in my case: They tried to create a false investigation against me.”
Sampson lives in Bangor and is looking for a job in security. “I wanted to continue working at my job, and I miss it very much,” she said.
THE MAINE CENTER FOR PUBLIC INTEREST REPORTING is a nonpartisan, nonprofit news service based in Hallowell.
Comments are not available on this story. Read more about why we allow commenting on some stories and not on others.
We believe it's important to offer commenting on certain stories as a benefit to our readers. At its best, our comments sections can be a productive platform for readers to engage with our journalism, offer thoughts on coverage and issues, and drive conversation in a respectful, solutions-based way. It's a form of open discourse that can be useful to our community, public officials, journalists and others.
We do not enable comments on everything — exceptions include most crime stories, and coverage involving personal tragedy or sensitive issues that invite personal attacks instead of thoughtful discussion.
You can read more here about our commenting policy and terms of use. More information is also found on our FAQs.
Show less