
Like most people, I had my opinions and assumptions, but I didn’t really know for sure.
I also didn’t like that the state of Maine had forced school consolidation on towns under the threat of losing state funding for education. However, that alone doesn’t necessarily make the end result a bad thing.
The issue deserved another look. An honest, well-informed conclusion required an objective review of the facts, an open mind, and a willingness to accept the possibility that what I thought was true might not be.
There are many issues to look at when considering whether withdrawal from RSU 5 would be in the best interest of Durham, but the primary issue I heard about when speaking to people around town involved property taxes.
There is a perception among many that the school budget has grown dramatically since joining RSU 5, and that this has caused a large increase in our property taxes.
The data shows this perception is not accurate. The school budget average annual growth rate has actually been much lower as part of RSU 5 — 2.9 percent — than in the 10 years prior to joining — 5 percent.
This isn’t to say that many residents haven’t seen significant property tax increases since we joined RSU 5 in 2009. Many have. However, just because two events happened at the same time, doesn’t mean one caused the other.
The two primary events that resulted in property tax increases for many residents occurred around the time we joined RSU 5, but they were not caused by joining RSU 5 and won’t be changed or eliminated if we leave RSU 5.
First, in 2009 we made our first interest payment of $89,000 on the bond for the gym, roof and heating system options at the new school that were not funded by the state but were approved by Durham voters prior to joining RSU 5. In 2010, when the school opened, this payment jumped to $178,000 because we started paying on the principal of the bond as well.
Second, in 2010 the town conducted a revaluation of all property in Durham. Since property taxes are based on property valuation, it’s important that the recorded values be accurate so that the tax burden can be distributed fairly. As a result, many saw their tax bills go down, while many others saw their tax bills go up because of large increases in their valuations.
This was the primary reason for the large tax increases some have seen since 2009. Compare your tax bills from 2009 and 2010 to see how revaluation affected you. The town office has this information if you no longer have your tax bills.
The withdrawal decision isn’t just about money. Educational issues must also be considered.
Some have advocated a return to being a K-8 school district with some form of high school choice. This is understandable. Prior to joining RSU 5, it was all we knew. Many are simply more comfortable with this arrangement because it worked for them or their children.
Things have changed, however. For the first time in our history, kids and parents have had the opportunity to experience what it’s like for Durham to be a fully participating member of a complete K-12 school district. They have seen the benefits this brings to our kids’ education, and the community as a whole. In all of the emails, phone calls and personal conversations I’ve had about this issue over the last several months, I do not recall even one parent with a child currently in the school system that wanted to go back to the way things were before joining RSU 5.
Many are concerned with the fact that Freeport has the majority of RSU 5 board seats and a voting population larger than that of Durham and Pownal combined. The fear is that this power could be used to Freeport’s advantage without concern for the interests of Durham or Pownal.
If the roles were reversed and Durham was the town with the majority of the voting power, I don’t think we would ever use that power to our advantage at the expense of the other towns. I don’t think Freeport will, either.
I’ve reviewed the minutes from every RSU 5 board meeting and there has never been a vote split along town lines, or where all the board members from Freeport voted one way and those from Durham and Pownal voted another. It just doesn’t happen.
It is true that last June was the first time Durham residents voted in favor of the RSU 5 school budget. In previous years, enough Freeport residents voted in favor of the budget to offset the number of residents in Durham and Pownal voting against it. However, I believe that prior to this year, Durham voters likely rejected the budget because we mistakenly blamed RSU 5 for property tax increases as described earlier.
It is not a coincidence that an organized effort to provide voters with factual information about the school budget prior to the vote last June resulted in Durham’s approval of the budget. When provided with accurate information, sensible people make sensible choices.
The financial study completed by the committee appointed by the selectmen clearly shows that withdrawing from RSU 5 would cost the town somewhere between $900,000 and $1.14 million per year, even when compared to the cost of staying in RSU 5 and paying our share of a renovation and expansion to the high school.
Some may vote in favor of withdrawal because of how they personally feel about high school choice or because of their desire for more local control of the K-8 school budget. It is their right to do so.
However, they should not be under any illusion that either of these would save the town money, or be in the educational interest of Durham’s students. They should know that there is a very high price tag attached.
KEVIN NADEAU is chairman of the Durham Educational Exploration Committee.
Comments are not available on this story. Read more about why we allow commenting on some stories and not on others.
We believe it's important to offer commenting on certain stories as a benefit to our readers. At its best, our comments sections can be a productive platform for readers to engage with our journalism, offer thoughts on coverage and issues, and drive conversation in a respectful, solutions-based way. It's a form of open discourse that can be useful to our community, public officials, journalists and others.
We do not enable comments on everything — exceptions include most crime stories, and coverage involving personal tragedy or sensitive issues that invite personal attacks instead of thoughtful discussion.
You can read more here about our commenting policy and terms of use. More information is also found on our FAQs.
Show less