BRUNSWICK
The Region 10 Technical High School cooperative board affirmed a budget Wednesday and discussed the need to move its budget process forward in the future.
Region 10 provides technical and career education classes for students from Brunswick, Regional School Unit 5 and School Administrative District 75. During the past year, almost 300 students attended the school, which offers 13 different programs.
The $1,956,479 budget the Region 10 cooperative board approved for the local 2012-13 incorporates a $50,000 — or 2.83 percent — increase. This differs from the earlier budget renditions that reflected no increase.
At the cooperative board’s May 16 meeting, however, several members of the public, including Region 10 instructors, argued that the budget should be increased to prevent cutting programs and teachers.
According to minutes from the May 16 meeting, Region 10 director Barry Lohnes said the school has experienced financial stress for four years in a row, being asked to function at a high level with a flat budget. When cooperative member Jane Blais asked what led to the proposed cut to the building trades program, Lohnes explained it was due to a lack of money and multiple years of declining enrollment.
A motion to add $50,000 to the budget — enough to reinstate cuts to the building trades program — passed unanimously, with the expectation that the money will be placed in contingency and only used for the 2012-13 school year if enrollment in the program increases.
Cooperative board member Jane Scease from SAD 75 (Bowdoin, Bowdoinham, Harpswell and Topsham), stated at the May 16 meeting that the Region 10 budget had been brought before the SAD 75 school board, which recommended a 0 percent increase. A flat Region 10 budget was what the SAD 75 board took to a district budget meeting May 24 and what voters in the district’s four towns approved by referendum June 12.
Brunswick voters also approved a budget June 12 that contained flat funding for Region 10. Yet voters in the third sending unit, RSU 5 (Pownal, Durham, Freeport), voted to increase the school budget and added $12,465, which reflects RSU 5’s share of the additional $50,000 for Region 10. The RSU 5 budget also passed in the June 12 referendum.
Brunswick’s share of the increase is $19,145 and SAD 75’s share of the increase is $18,390 —money these districts must now find within their 2012-13 budgets.
Attorney Nicholas Nadzo of Jensen, Baird, Gardner and Henry told a confused cooperative board at the start of Wednesday’s meeting that members needed to vote on their ballot how their respective sending unit voted on their school budget — either approved or disapproved — at the June 12 referendum.
“If there is a majority vote on the approved, then that’s the end of this process, and if by chance the majority does not approve, then there would be the requirement of this group to come up with a new budget,” Nadzo said.
“Can you explain that a little more?” asked Janet Connors, chairwoman of the cooperative board and a Brunswick School Board member. “It just seems to defy logic to me. … It seems like a contradiction and it seems like it’s taking power away from the school boards.”
“It’s actually a somewhat complicated process,” said Nadzo.
The school budget validation referendum statute has “added one more ingredient, if you will, which means the whole time frame needs to be moved up to cover that.”
Nadzo suggested that this year the budget process did not properly align, so some of the sending schools didn’t have updated numbers for Region 10.
The only question for each cooperative member Wednesday was, “Did the budget referendum pass your budget? So that’s all you’re voting on, literally, right now,” Nadzo said.
Phil Dionne, a cooperative board member from Brunswick, asked for the statutory reference giving sending school boards “any authority whatsoever to vote on and establish a number for Cooperative Board Region 10. They very well have the authority if they so choose to recommend to the legislative unit, which in Brunswick’s case is the council, that the council not pass it. But nobody has the authority beyond this board to lower or raise the number we present. They can approve or not approve; they cannot change it until it’s turned down and then we take the next step.”
Just because the council didn’t include money in its budget for the 2.83 percent increase Dionne said, “doesn’t make it right.”
Nadzo acknowledged that the budget the cooperative board proposed wasn’t actually voted on and that “it should have been voted on, one way or the other. So there we have a little bit of complication and the question is how to resolve that.”
Nadzo said, “I think the reason why we’re in this predicament here is because of the time period,” a scenario in which the cooperative board did not recommend an increase in the Region 10 budget until after the sending districts had already settled on their 2012-13 budgets. He advised the cooperative board to resolve future budget question in February or March so that school boards have final draft budget numbers to put in their budget.
“Again, they could vote it up or down, but at least it is the number that you folks are recommending,” Nadzo said.
Connors asked Nadzo if the sending school boards have the right to send a budget back or if the school units have to accept the cooperative board’s recommended budget and include it in their budgets.
“They have to accept it,” said Shannon Welsh, the designated Region 10 superintendent and superintendent of schools for RSU 5. “The influence of the sending boards, like RSU 5’s board is really through the members on this cooperative board. And so we’re creating a timeline to ensure that the budget is done by March.”
Connors requested an agenda item to outline and clarify the role and responsibility of the superintendents of the sending schools, and a workshop on the matter is tentatively set for Aug. 15.
Scease added that she thinks the sending school boards also should receive information about their roles and responsibilities relative to the Region 10 Technical High School and its cooperative board.
Comments are not available on this story. Read more about why we allow commenting on some stories and not on others.
We believe it's important to offer commenting on certain stories as a benefit to our readers. At its best, our comments sections can be a productive platform for readers to engage with our journalism, offer thoughts on coverage and issues, and drive conversation in a respectful, solutions-based way. It's a form of open discourse that can be useful to our community, public officials, journalists and others.
We do not enable comments on everything — exceptions include most crime stories, and coverage involving personal tragedy or sensitive issues that invite personal attacks instead of thoughtful discussion.
You can read more here about our commenting policy and terms of use. More information is also found on our FAQs.
Show less