3 min read

BATH — An April 23 letter signed by all nine Bath city councilors and sent to Central Maine Power violated Maine’s Freedom of Access Act, the coauthor of the handbook on the so-called “Right to Know” law said Tuesday.

The council letter, which criticized the utility company for misrepresenting a city ordinance regarding installation of so-called “Smart Meters,” was only discussed by councilors during an April 17 executive session and was never discussed — nor voted on — during any public council session.

The council properly advertised and then met in special session on April 17 for the sole purpose of entering into executive session to discuss a legal matter, according to an agenda. State law does not require a municipality to be more specific about the reason for a session.

Councilors emerged from chambers following the executive session without formally returning to public session to adjourn the meeting.

On Tuesday, The Times Record received via U.S. Postal Service delivery a copy of a letter from the Bath City Council to CMP, dated April 23 and signed by all nine councilors.

Advertisement

The letter requests that CMP rescind a notice it sent some Bath customers because councilors alleged the notice included “serious and fundamental misrepresentations” of a municipal ordinance related to the installation of the new meters.

But Maine’s Freedom of Access Act prohibits city councils and other such bodies from performing “official actions” or giving final approval to “ordinances, orders, rules, resolutions, regulations, contracts, appointments or other official actions” in executive session (Me. Rev. Stat. Ann. Tit. 1, § 405(1)-(5)).

Attorney Sigmund D. Schutz, who co-authored “Maine’s ‘Right to Know’ Law: An Introduction and Guide,” wrote in an email late Tuesday to The Times Record that “the decision to sign and issue the letter was official action. I also question why all discussion (unless there was some public discussion) took place in executive session. Any deliberation on the letter, aside from (perhaps) legal discussion of rights and duties, should have been public.”

Bath City Manager Bill Giroux referred questions about the letter and the council’s process to city attorney Roger Therriault.

Asked Tuesday about the letter, Therriault told The Times Record that the council’s letter to CMP was “a legal matter that was discussed in executive session. I’m not sure they needed a formal action — they all signed the letter.”

“Roger Therriault’s statement is contradictory,” said Robert Long, managing editor of The Times Record, who contacted Schutz about the matter. “Discussing, drafting and signing the letter clearly constitutes the type of official actions that the law requires to be done in public. Regardless of whether they acted with any ill intent, Bath’s city councilors violated the public trust by conducting constituent service in a forum to which their constituents had no access. They and their attorney should know how to apply the law.” David Sinclair, chairman of the City Council, said councilors were advised by Therriault that no official action was necessary.

Advertisement

“Our counsel was well aware of what we were doing and did not advise us there was a need for (a vote in regular session) to happen,” he said.

Sinclair said Wednesday that he could not discuss what took place during council executive sessions. He stated again, “We had the city solicitor and parliamentarian there at every step of the process. He composed the letter that eventually went out and we followed his guidance.”

bbrogan@timesrecord.com

 



Comments are not available on this story. Read more about why we allow commenting on some stories and not on others.