Police are investigating a Gorham legislator’s management and use of town money while he was director of the Buxton Recreation Department after an audit by the town accountant uncovered what he characterized as “mismanagement” of town money.
According to the accountant, Rep. Chris Barstow was improperly using a town credit card, postage machine and cell phone for personal use.
The accountant also found a number of deficiencies in the way Barstow, who had been director of the department for four years, was handling the department’s finances, including inconsistent practices for depositing money collected for recreation programs.
“It appears money was collected by the town and not deposited in a timely fashion or deposited at all,” the accountant, Ron Smith, wrote in a letter to the town. “We approximate the amount to be less than $1,000.”
Buxton Police Chief Jody Thomas confirmed Friday that police were investigating the matter, but declined to comment further.
The accountant’s letter paints a more serious picture of Barstow’s involvement in the Recreation Department’s financial problems, which led to his resignation May 21. It was reported last week, prior to the letter being made public, that Barstow had neglected collecting program fees, which he admitted, and that some department accounts were overdrawn as a result.
In interviews Friday and Monday, both in person and on the phone, Barstow, 30, acknowledged he had made some “poor choices as an administrator,” but said he didn’t believe he had done anything illegal. He said he met with Thomas Saturday and is cooperating fully with the police investigation.
“I am regretful of mistakes that were made,” Barstow said.
Barstow met privately with Smith and Jean Harmon, who chairs the Board of Selectmen, on May 19 to discuss some of the findings of the audit. After the meeting, held in Smith’s Buxton office, Smith and Harmon contacted police, according to Smith.
The Buxton Board of Selectmen accepted Barstow’s resignation at its May 21 meeting. On May 28, Smith reviewed his findings publicly, which were contained in a letter he had submitted to the town, at a selectmen’s meeting. In the letter, Smith recommended changes for improving internal controls over town finances in the Recreation Department.
Among those recommendations were that the town begin receiving recreation money through town office clerks, who would include that money with the town’s daily deposits. According to the letter, Barstow had been taking deposits home occasionally or traveling with them before they were taken to the bank.
Smith also recommended adopting a policy on the use of town credit cards by town employees who hold them, with acknowledgment from those who hold them.
According to the letter, Barstow was using a town credit card to charge $30 to $40 in gas approximately twice a month for his personal vehicle, without permission from the town.
In an interview, Barstow acknowledged traveling with department money on a couple of occasions when he said he didn’t have time to deposit it. He also admitted that he had used the town credit card to pay for gas.
“I used it in lieu of mileage reimbursement. It was a matter of efficiency. I saw it as a way of reimbursement,” Barstow said. “In retrospect, it was a mistake, not illegal but a poor choice.”
Barstow also said he had used the town postage machine for personal mail. He estimated that he had used it to send a total of $30 to $40 postage.
“I did have several personal letters that I sent out. I regret using that service of the town,” Barstow said. “It was a bad decision on my part.”
Barstow said that, aside from credit card charges for gas, he had not used any other town money he was not authorized to use. He said he expected that the investigation would find he had not done anything illegal.
“I’m looking forward to seeing the results and I’m looking forward to closure,” Barstow said.
The investigation comes just before the state primary election. Barstow, a Democrat, is unopposed for his party’s nomination in District 129. “At this time, it’s my intention to continue my re-election bid,” Barstow said.
Buxton Selectman Cliff Emery said he was “very disappointed” by the information provided in Smith’s report to the board.
“I knew we had some accounting issues,” Emery said. “It was going to be my suggestion that (Barstow) not go to Augusta, or be done with us… The job wasn’t getting done.”
Emery said he had been supportive of Barstow as they tried to work through the accounting problems in the department, but is “mad as hell” now that the matter is under investigation by the police.
In an interview, Smith, an accountant for RHR Smith & Co., said he had been working for more than a year with the board to help fix accounting problems in the Recreation Department. But it wasn’t until May that more problems, such as the improper use of the town credit card and postage machine, began to surface.
“Rockets weren’t really glaring a year ago,” Smith said.
Smith said accounting issues in the Recreation Department first surfaced in the fall of 2006, while Smith was conducting a routine audit of the town’s 2005-2006 fiscal year. Smith worked with the town to right the department’s practices, but in February 2007, the selectmen asked Smith to look at the Recreation Department’s practices a bit closer as the accounting problems did not seem to be resolved.
In May 2007, Smith said he first met Barstow at Smith’s Buxton office on Old Orchard Road. Smith said he pointed out accounting problems to Barstow, and told him he needed to pay attention to them. Smith told Barstow they would be talking again in the fall, when Smith returned to audit the town’s 2006-2007 financial records.
Smith said he and the selectmen involved Barstow in the process as they tried to resolve problems in the department, but when Smith returned for the fall 2007 audit, “Things were just as bad,” he said.
In December 2007, the board requested that Barstow catch up on sending out the bills to recreation service users for the first six months of the 2007-2008 fiscal year. According to Smith, selectmen again asked Barstow to catch up on the bills in March 2008.
In April, Smith said, Barstow sent out totaling some $68,000. Based on his audit, however, Smith said he was not confident of the accuracy of all the bills that were sent out.
Emery encouraged residents who have questions about their recreation bills to call Town Hall.
By the end of the first week of May, Smith said, he had found the issues with the credit card, the postage machine and the deposit practices.
Barstow was hired as a part-time director but became full time about two years ago. The position pays $32,000 annually.
Barstow, in an interview on Monday, said poor recordkeeping and other financial issues in the department had reached a point where he, with a limited background in financial management, was unable to square them away. Barstow acknowledged that he had previously worked as an auditor at the Inn by the Sea and Holiday Inn West before becoming the recreation director in 2004, but said he believes he was hired by Buxton based on a strong recreation background, not on a strong financial management background.
Barstow was “given ample opportunity and ample resources to get this thing right,” Smith said Friday.
Barstow has been active in the Gorham community and previously served as a trustee of Baxter Memorial Library. He said he left the board in April.
A biography posted by the Maine Democrats said Barstow is the moderator at Little Falls Baptist Church. He’s a volunteer with youth baseball and softball in Gorham and he’s a member of the town’s Recreation Advisory Board.
Barstow graduated from Gorham High School in 1995 and attended the University of Maine, studying elementary education.
Amid probe, legislator steps down
Finances probed – After audit, Buxton police investigating legislator
Comments are no longer available on this story