Next time you’re in downtown Brunswick, take a good look at the statue of Joshua Chamberlain. Better yet, if you have time, visit the Chamberlain Museum.
While you’re there, think not only of the former general and governor, but also of the men he lead into battle and who never returned home to Maine. Think of what they fought and died for more than 150 years ago — the preservation of the Union and an end to slavery.
American society has come a long way since then, but not nearly far enough, as seen by the resurgence of white nationalism. So while you’re also thinking of those who died under Chamberlain’s command, spare a thought for Heather Heyer. killed in Charlottesville, Virginia, following a counter protest against white supremacists who demanded to preserve a statue of Robert E. Lee.
Times Record columnist Jonathan Crimmins recently wrote that “knocking down a monument, or breaking apart a statue will make us feel good today. However, choosing to set aside that reminder of what we can and have overcome will serve no one’s long term interest.… Removing or hiding parts of our history will only distort the parts of our history that remain.”
We agree with that, but to a point.
The likenesses of Lee and his compatriots belong in a museum, not a public square. So too do symbols of the rebellion that sought to cleave the United States in two and keep a race of people literally in chains.
Symbols that represent enslavement and division do not deserve the same veneration as those who oppose tyranny and oppression. Rather, Confederate monuments only salt the wounds of America’s racial divide. That’s a point that President Trump didn’t get when he blamed “many sides” for the violence there.
In tandem with Trump, Maine Gov. Paul LePage told a Portland radio station removing Confederate monuments is “just like going to New York City right now and taking down the monument of those who perished in 9/11.” And in a handwritten note to a constituent critical of his response, an increasingly unhinged LePage wrote: “Both parties to the events of Charlottesville are guilty of racism.”
That’s a matter of false equivalency, but LePage has never been constrained by facts — case in point, his recent, baseless claim that “7,600 Mainers fought for the Confederacy.”
In his weekly radio address, LePage somehow managed to sink even lower, blaming Heyer’s death not on the driver who allegedly intentionally rammed his car into a crowd of counter-protesters, but on “so-called ‘anti-fascists’” who “went to Charlottesville looking for a confrontation.”
And while LePage stated he agrees that “there is no excuse for hatred,” his comments and outright disdain for the counter protesters — along with liberals and the media — only fuels animosity.
Let’s come back to Chamberlain, or rather, Chamberlain’s alma mater, Bowdoin College. Before the Civil War, that college bestowed upon future Confederate president Jefferson Davis an honorary degree. Recently, the college moved a plaque containing Davis’s name that was put on display in 1965 to commemorate the 100th anniversary of the Confederate Army’s surrender. (That surrender, incidentally, was overseen by Chamberlain.)
The plaque had hung in a space “that honors the service of alumni who fought to preserve the Union and to end slavery,” according to Bowdoin College President Clayton Rose. It has now been moved to a display case the Hawthorne-Longfellow library’s Archive and Special Collections.
“What occurred in Charlottesville and the subsequent national conversation have led us to conclude that historical artifacts like this that are directly tied to the leadership of a horrible ideology are not meant for a place designed to honor courage, principle, and freedom,” Rose said. “Rather, this part of our history belongs in a setting appropriate for study and reflection. Special collections is where we preserve historical objects and records and where we invite members of our community and the public to research, study, and understand Bowdoin history and the lives of those connected to the College. Critically, this move explicitly preserves and acknowledges our history, our unusual relationship with Davis, and the fact that there were those at the College who did not support the preservation of the Union or the causes of freedom and human dignity.”
LePage, Trump and anyone who says they are concerned with history can learn from Bowdoin’s example: Preservation without veneration of the Confederacy, slavery or hatred.
Comments are not available on this story. Read more about why we allow commenting on some stories and not on others.
We believe it's important to offer commenting on certain stories as a benefit to our readers. At its best, our comments sections can be a productive platform for readers to engage with our journalism, offer thoughts on coverage and issues, and drive conversation in a respectful, solutions-based way. It's a form of open discourse that can be useful to our community, public officials, journalists and others.
We do not enable comments on everything — exceptions include most crime stories, and coverage involving personal tragedy or sensitive issues that invite personal attacks instead of thoughtful discussion.
You can read more here about our commenting policy and terms of use. More information is also found on our FAQs.
Show less