The recent Town Council election in District 6 has exposed deep rifts in the town’s governing body as it prepares for 2014.
The election turned nasty when Town Council Chairwoman Suzan Wilson made phone calls endorsing Allison Harris, prompting fellow Councilor Benet Pols to endorse Jane Millett for the seat being vacated by current Council Vice Chairwoman Margo Knight.
Councilor-elect Millett beat Harris by 18 votes in the Nov. 5 contest. Millett will take her seat on the board when she is sworn in on Jan. 7.
Pols authorized the Millett campaign to distribute a message from his Facebook page, which publicly supported Millett as a reformer who would upset “the status quo.” Campaigners for Millett converted Pols’ message into a flier and actively distributed it on windshields throughout the district less than a day before the election.

Pols’s flier, paid for by the Millett campaign, referred to the “collegial aspects of working as part of a group such as the council” but also criticized Councilors Knight, Gerald Favreau and Ben Tucker — all Harris supporters — as “those who want things the way they are: the supporters of the status quo.”
Pols also offered Harris as an example of the “status quo” by tying her to the controversial $247,000 loan extended to Brunswick Taxi this year by the Brunswick Development Corporation in what Pols’s flier called a “backroom deal.” The Brunswick Development Corporation is a quasi-municipal corporation on whose board Wilson served at the time the Brunswick Taxi loan was granted.
Harris “has the support of former Council Chair Joanne King and her husband, Dale King,” Pols’s flier said. Dale King is the owner of Brunswick Taxi. Joanne King is a former town councilor who served on the BDC board in 2012, shortly before the Brunswick Taxi loan was granted on extremely favorable terms to her husband’s business.
Harris said she was dismayed at Pols’s actions, saying they misrepresented her campaign and were orchestrated too late for her to rebut.
“I guess I was disturbed, and very disappointed,” Harris said Tuesday.
“I’m not status quo,” she said. “I, in fact, have taken exception to actions of the Town Council numerous times, and had addressed those concerns with my councilor, Margo Knight.”
Pols — an at-large councilor — said the flier was just typical electioneering meant to improve the makeup of the board.
“It was printed off my website, a message on my web page somebody else copied and leafletted with,” placing the fliers on windshields across the district in the 24-hour runup to Election Day, Pols said Monday. “A number of people were involved.”
Harris said the timing of the leafletting was suspect — and may have affected the outcome.
“I expect it did,” she said, citing other factors such as Millett’s name recognition and low voter turnout — about 17 percent. “People who got up in the morning and saw this on their windshields may have been a lot of the people who wouldn’t have otherwise voted.”
She said she learned of the Pols-Millett electioneering only after polls had closed, and thus had no opportunity to respond.
Asked how Harris would have been a “defender of the status quo” as councilor, Pols again cited Favreau, Wilson and the Kings among her supporters.
Favreau “has voted for every expenditure, but then complains the actual voting day when we actually raise our hands,” Pols said Monday.
“All of those councilors that we listed as supporting (Harris), along with other people that were listed that I didn’t bother to name, have been associated with decisions made in the past couple of years that many people disagreed with,” Pols said. “Taxes are going up, and you have some councilors saying, ‘I don’t really want to do it’ when they vote to approve the spending, yet they vote for every single expenditure.”
No issue falls more squarely into the category of disputed town spending than the imminent move of the town’s municipal offices to the McLellan Building on Union Street — and with what Pols said is “the associated huge escalation in the advertised price” of renovations to the building.
Bowdoin College acquired the Longfellow Elementary School building from the town in December 2011 in exchange for the McLellan Building, which the town will use as its new municipal offices beginning in 2014. The college will also continue to use the building, retaining third-floor office space, until 2025.
Millett, a real estate broker, was the loudest critic of the swap, asking questions at Town Council meetings about the deal and agitating against what she said were undisclosed costs associated with its renovation.
In an OpEd in The Times Record editions of June 10, Millett wrote the town’s assumption of the McLellan Building “is an unprecedented and mostly unneeded expansion of town square footage which promises to expand operating expenses for the town tremendously.”
“It’s her willingness to question,” Pols said of his advocacy of Millett. “This is the affirmative reason, her willingness to question staff or the decisions of the Town Council as a whole. Whether it’s a 9-0 or a 5-4 decision, she’s been willing to question those things. People who have supported past council issues fear her.”
But in tying her to the Brunswick Taxi loan, Harris said Pols and Millett engaged in dirty politics.
“Of course I had nothing to do with the (Brunswick) Taxi deal,” she said, “and I was surprised they took the low road and seized the opportunity of endorsing Jane to take another swipe at the Kings,” whom she said were just two of 90 residents endorsing her campaign. “I guess I’m kind of naive.”
Harris also said it was “ironic” she was being taken to task for the views of her supporters when Millett did not publicly disclose the names of her supporters except Pols and those who wrote letters on her behalf on The Times Record Op-Ed page.
Other councilors expressed muted discomfort at Pols’s rhetoric, if not his tactics.
Favreau declined comment on the content of the flier — specifically, whether he is a “defender of the status quo.”
“Well, (Pols) has got his opinion and I’ve got mine,” Favreau said Tuesday. “And like I said, I represent my district and I vote for what’s good in my district and the town of Brunswick. I’ve been doing that for the last seven years.”
Tucker, who is mentioned on the flier, declined comment about being tagged a “defender of the status quo.”
“I endorsed Allison Harris on the merits because I thought she was a good candidate, someone that I knew,” he said, adding: “Jane is going to be a good councilor.”
Tucker is finishing out his term in District 2 and will not serve on the Town Council in 2014. “I’ll leave it to the next council to work out the issues they’re facing next year,” he said.
Tucker’s seat will be filled by Planning Board member and former state biologist Steve Walker, who ran unopposed.
Wilson, the council chairwoman, didn’t return several messages seeking comment on her advocacy of Harris.
Pols said he doesn’t think his flier was polarizing.
“Going forward, I don’t think there will be negativity cast on those who oppose what the majority thinks,” he said. “I would hope not.
“There is a tendency (on the Town Council) to just want to get along for the sake of getting along,” Pols said. “I don’t mean to ascribe this to any individual councilor, but it’s as if voting against something is a personal insult to the person who proposed it, that you would have the nerve to question it.
“This concept that there’s a social requirement for unanimity; or an idea that the council should take direction from the (town) manager’s office, that’s not what the charter says, that’s not what people who elect people to represent them say.
“(District 4 Councilor) John Perrault, (District 7 Councilor) Sarah Brayman and I have been sometimes painted as not team players, I guess, because we vote against stuff. There’s this idea that there’s some sort of chain of command that were all supposed to follow.
“I just think that the desire to have everyone look like a team player gets in the way of people getting information to and from constitutents,” Pols said.
About his potentially assuming the Town Council chairmanship in 2014, Pols said only: “I’ve heard that, too.”
“There’s no firm committment to anybody from anybody,” he said. “Other people are interested in it, too.”
In assessing the campaign flier, Pols said he didn’t regret it.
However: “What if the other person wins?” he said. “Then you have to feel bad about it.”
bmentzinger@timesrecord.com

Comments are not available on this story. Read more about why we allow commenting on some stories and not on others.
We believe it's important to offer commenting on certain stories as a benefit to our readers. At its best, our comments sections can be a productive platform for readers to engage with our journalism, offer thoughts on coverage and issues, and drive conversation in a respectful, solutions-based way. It's a form of open discourse that can be useful to our community, public officials, journalists and others.
We do not enable comments on everything — exceptions include most crime stories, and coverage involving personal tragedy or sensitive issues that invite personal attacks instead of thoughtful discussion.
You can read more here about our commenting policy and terms of use. More information is also found on our FAQs.
Show less