4 min read

Mark Fish
Mark Fish
Other than tossing red meat to your RedState.com readership, I can’t for the life of me figure out why The Times Record insists on giving so much prominent ink to the rantings of self-described tea partier Edward Tharp.

Although responding to him probably does nothing but increase his sense of self-importance, not responding is akin to surrender, and that is something that those of us in the realitybased community are not willing to accept.

On Nov. 20 in a guest column titled “Tea party suffers the violent rhetoric of the Left” (Page A6), Mr. Tharp remains true to his usual modus operandi. He makes a few unsourced, outrageous claims that he presents as fact, and then throws in the obligatory link to some obscure rightwing website as if that somehow settles it. I know I’m not the only one tiring from this tea partyinspired Kabuki theater.

Mr. Tharp gives us two tea party tidbits in particular that demand a response.

First, in a gross mischaracterization of the truth, he leads the reader to believe that because of the recent government shutdown, U.S. Sen. Angus King called tea party conservatives “murderers.”

Advertisement

It is no secret that Generation Opportunity, a Virginia-based, Koch brothers-backed organization, has been engaged in a national campaign to convince healthy young people to opt out of Obamacare. They travel to college campuses throwing boozy tailgate pizza parties and have produced a disgusting ad with a creepy Uncle Sam posing as a gynecologist. Their aim, quite simply, is to financially destabilize the entire endeavor.

King says he is alive today only because he was insured as a young man. And because many others have died due to lack of insurance, Senator King, in a Sept. 30 interview with Salon Magazine said, “That’s a scandal. Those people are guilty of murder in my opinion. Some of those people they persuade are going to end up dying because they don’t have health insurance. For people who do that to other people in the name of some obscure political ideology is one of the grossest violations of our humanity I can think of.”

In this context, Senator King is absolutely correct. If his “violent rhetoric” gives the tea party the vapors, perhaps they should undertake a bit of self-introspection. Encouraging young people to forgo insurance, or anyone for that matter, will result in people dying. That is a fact, and those involved in such a vile undertaking are, at the very least, complicit in murder.

Second, Mr. Tharp, claiming the tea party believes in the free market, says, “…the Unaffordable [sic] Healthcare Act is tyranny.”

Nothing could be further from the truth. The ACA is based entirely upon the free market. The exchanges where people go to find policies that suit their needs exist to encourage competition between private insurers — i.e., pure, unadulterated capitalism.

Yes, the government provides subsidies to help those who can’t afford their premiums, but those subsidies go directly to private insurers.

Advertisement

Many of us on the left are unhappy with Obamacare precisely because it doesn’t offer a public option and is too mired in the “health care for profit” model which, in my opinion, is immoral.

But it is magnitudes of order better than the status quo. For example, to date, well over 700,000 people who previously didn’t qualify, and don’t make enough to qualify for subsidies, have been enrolled in Medicaid in the states that have participated in Medicaid expansion. That is significant, and a model of what single-payer health care could, and should, be.

Mr. Tharp defines the Tea Party as “Constitutionally-oriented Americans who believe in our country as founded.” I would advise him and his ilk to thumb through their pocket Constitutions they so proudly wave around. It would benefit us all if they could come to understand how a law becomes a law and how democracy depends upon honoring the will of the majority.

The ACA is the law of the land. It was passed by Congress and the Senate, signed by the president and upheld by the Supreme Court. Pretending this constitutes tyranny and is somehow not valid because no Republicans voted for it, or because there is a Democrat in the White House, is un-American.

If Mr. Tharp and his tea party brethren really believe in freedom, as they claim, they should put their money where their mouth is and stop working to sabotage that which, for the first time, is giving millions of Americans the freedom to pursue happiness without fear of bankruptcy. Otherwise, give us a rational alternative — or go the way of the dinosaurs.

MARK FISH is a self-employed upholsterer who lives in Richmond.


Comments are not available on this story. Read more about why we allow commenting on some stories and not on others.