2 min read

To the Editor:

There are errors in tone and fact in the review of Judy Collins’s performance at the Chocolate Church Arts Center (“Review: Judy Collins at Chocolate Church,” Nov. 29, Page C1).

On Ms. Collins “Wildflowers” album, three songs were written by Judy Collins, three by Joni Mitchell, three by Leonard Cohen, one by Jacques Brel and one is “traditional.”

On “Who Knows Where the Times Goes,” two songs were written by Collins, one by Leonard Cohen and none by Joni Mitchell.

It is inaccurate to suggest Mitchell was the “songwriter” who Collins relied on to reach acclaim.

Advertisement

More disturbing is Gina Hamilton’s characterization of Collins’s song, early in the first set, about her son as a 16-year-old, as “shockingly intimate.”

Hamilton found on her fact checker, the Internet, that Collins lost this son to suicide when he was 33. That information isn’t in the song or performance.

Hamilton’s embellishment is shocking. It does not need to be said that the loss of a child to suicide and public acknowledgment of that speaks to the extraordinary tenderness of human courage and loss that warrants gratitude from both the listening public and from those many of us who have great difficulty hearing it.

Many professional entertainers have graced the Chocolate Church, but they won’t continue to if they aren’t treated professionally.

To call Collins’s performance “shockingly intimate” is a shot taken at no expense to the taker and only at the expense of the one it is aimed at.

Whether we’re talking about the introduction of the legendary “Battlefield Band” who the introducer described inaccurately as already having been over at “the pub,” clumsy failures to grasp that these are nationally recognized icons, entertainers who are superb professionals, means they won’t come back.

Ms. Collins’s encore was “Amazing Grace.” I’m closing with a line from another song from this performance, “Like a Bird on a Wire,” which Cohen wrote and Collins sang to all of us, “Why not ask for more?”

Susan Cook
Bath



Comments are not available on this story. Read more about why we allow commenting on some stories and not on others.