
Presidents Day may just be another holiday for some, but with this year’s upcoming presidential elections, it may be a good time to reflect back on the leaders who have influenced our country — both positively and negatively.
While a president has yet to come from Maine, Franklin Pierce, the nation’s 14th president, has a closer connection to the Brunswick area than at first glance.
Born in New Hampshire, Pierce was 16 when he entered Bowdoin College in 1820. Nehemiah Cleaveland, author of “The History of Bowdoin College,” described that the first couple years of Pierce’s college career were “idled or played away” until he “suddenly woke up to a sense of duty to true manhood,” and graduated third in his class. He was also friends with both Henry Wadsworth Longfellow and Nathaniel Hawthorne, who wrote his biography.

Despite a promising future, Pierce’s presidency was fairly undistinguished, though there may have been a good reason why he wasn’t as widely celebrated in history textbooks and at his alma mater.
“It’s an interesting question — why does Franklin Pierce not have a storied memory as other figures do and … one possible reason is that he played a role in a break down of politics in the coming of the Civil War, and has sort of tarnished his memory in some way,” said Patrick Rael, a history professor at Bowdoin College.
According to Rael, Pierce was a “dough face,” which was slang for a Northern politician with Southern sympathies at the time.
At one point in his presidency, Pierce had sent troops to Boston to make sure an escaped slave, Anthony Burns, was returned to slavery, despite the outcry of abolitionists.
“The streets of Boston were lined with mourners as Burns was led out of town, and people covered their windows with black draperies,” Rael said. “It was a bad moment.”
In addition to that incident, Pierce and his administration had also issued the Ostend Manifesto, which called for the annexation of Cuba for slaveholders who wanted to expand their land for plantations. While it failed, this made Pierce even more unpopular, said Rael.
“He was a president in an age of weak presidents,” he added. “There wasn’t a lot of strong presidents, and that was sort of deemed to be OK. It was better to have Congress be active than to have this one powerful central figure that was deemed to be a little bit of a threat to liberty.”
Pierce’s presidency was also doused in tragedy, as he and his wife had lost their son in a carriage accident as they were headed to Washington after his election.
“Pierce and his wife had witnessed the decapitation of their son before their very eyes and this is something that Pierce’s wife never retired from. She never joined him at Washington, and it meant that (he) entered the White House with this incredible grief in his heart,” Rael said. “Some people claim that this is one of the reasons why he wasn’t a stronger president — he was stricken by grief, concerned for his wife, he let things be managed too much by his councilors and Cabinet.
“I’ve never been a Pierce fan myself because of his stand on slavery, but that helps me understand him as a human being who suffered like everybody else,” he added.
Recognition woes
Rael also pointed out the national conversations surrounding the recognition — or revoked recognition — of certain leaders.
He referred to the recent call to rename Calhoun College, a residential college of Yale University named for John C. Calhoun, a South Carolina politician who defended slavery. In the fall, Bowdoin College rescinded an award named after Jefferson Davis, who was the president of the Confederacy.
“I think the question is when we consider these folks, what are we trying to do? Are we trying to honor their memory? Are we trying to dishonor their memory? Or a third way is where we simply try to understand,” Rael said. “Maybe we can remember them without necessarily honoring or dishonoring them to simply understand our past a little more completely.”
Reflection is also key.
“I think that Americans are courageous people and Mainers are courageous people, and we can courageously look at our own past, whether we find it personally to be positive or negative,” he said.
• FRANKLIN PIERCE was 16 when he entered Bowdoin College in 1820. Nehemiah Cleaveland, author of “The History of Bowdoin College,” described that the first couple years of Pierce’s college career were “idled or played away” until he “suddenly woke up to a sense of duty to true manhood,” and graduated third in his class.
Comments are not available on this story. Read more about why we allow commenting on some stories and not on others.
We believe it's important to offer commenting on certain stories as a benefit to our readers. At its best, our comments sections can be a productive platform for readers to engage with our journalism, offer thoughts on coverage and issues, and drive conversation in a respectful, solutions-based way. It's a form of open discourse that can be useful to our community, public officials, journalists and others.
We do not enable comments on everything — exceptions include most crime stories, and coverage involving personal tragedy or sensitive issues that invite personal attacks instead of thoughtful discussion.
You can read more here about our commenting policy and terms of use. More information is also found on our FAQs.
Show less