| GUEST | COLUMN |
Presidential character matters. Honesty, integrity, good judgement is what we try to teach our children, and what we hope for in a spouse and friend. These and other attributes, trustworthiness being the most important, I would argue are the essential ingredients when it comes to voting, especially for a president.
Lately the terms “narcissistic,” “anti-social“ and even “psychopathic” have been bandied about in editorials, talk shows and in the equally loose-lipped social media world. Republican candidates are usually the target.
I am a licensed psychologist in Maine. So when I read or hear such descriptors, I often think from a clinical perspective. There is the dictionary, and then there is a diagnostic manual (DSM 5) used by psychologists, psychiatrists and clinical social workers, hospitals and insurance companies who base treatment plans and payments on these words. So when I think “narcissist” or “anti-social” I think of researchers who back up diagnostic terms with carefully chosen criteria and then compare this criteria to actual behavior.
The more inflammatory descriptor “psychopathic” is particularly damning. While watching the evening news my wife — not a psychologist — declared one of the Republican candidates to be “psychopathic.” With a feigned, imperial psychologist voice, I told her, “I don’t think so.” Then I thought about it.
Again, “psychopathic” is a term loosely used. But what does it mean from a clinically researched perspective? The most respected tool used by social scientists to determine psychopathy is the HARE PCL-R. The measure uses 20 criteria. Each criteria is given a score of 2,1, or 0 (zero meaning the individual does not exhibit the attribute):
• Glibness/Superficial Charm
• Grandiose Sense of Self Worth
• Need for Stimulation/Proneness to
Boredom
• Pathological Lying
• Conning/Manipulative
• Lack of Remorse or Guilt
• Shallow Affect
• Callous/Lack of Empathy
• Parasitic Lifestyle
• Poor Behavioral Controls
• Promiscuous Sexual Behavior
• Early Behavioral Problems
• Lack of Realistic, Long-Term Goals
• Impulsivity
• Irresponsibility
• Failure to Accept Responsibility
for Own Actions
• Many Short-Term Marital Relationships • Juvenile Delinquency
• Revocation of Conditional Release
• Criminal Versatility
Each of these 20 criterion is spelled out in detail, though “considerable judgement and inference” is involved, so advises the instructions. Some items, such as #17, are more clearly quantified. For instance, a score of 2 for those who have had three or more short-term marital relationship under age 30 and four or more if over 30. (Each item is scored with a 2,1 or 0. A score of 32 qualified one as a psychopath.)
Yet, three quarters of the items have a common sense ring. On item #2, a subject receives a score of two if the individual has a “grossly inflated view of his abilities and self worth … He may impress as a braggart … He often appears selfassured, opinionated and cocky … His inflated ego and exaggerated regard for his own abilities are remarkable, given the facts of his life.” An overall score of over 32 qualifies one for the label “psychopath.”
There are a number of provisos. First, the Hare PCL-R should be used only by qualified persons with an advanced degree in “social, medical or behavioral sciences,” and they should be trained. Second, ethical standards specify that psychologists like myself cannot diagnose unless we’ve actually sat down and interviewed the subject, face to face. Third, we must have been given informed consent. Four, we must not “promote psychological techniques to unqualified persons.” Lastly, the term psychopath is not a recognized diagnostic category. Instead the term “psychopath” is used to describe those persons given two diagnoses: narcissistic personality disorder and anti-social personality disorder. The “psychopathic” subject is an individual at the high range for both of these diagnoses.
So why focus on the attributes that make up a psychopath? I would argue that, even though we who are not qualified and trained to use the above check list, and certainly not in a position to make a diagnosis, we can form informed impressions. That really is what most voters depend upon. Besides, the 20 criteria do employ common sense terms.
I have taught abnormal psychology for many years. As students work their way through the text, they inevitably end up diagnosing themselves, family and friends—no matter how often I tell them to contain themselves. It is fraudulent activity, I tell them. But, learning about criteria for various diagnosis does teach one to appreciate the first step in much scientific inquiry, that of identification and categorization. I must add, at the same time I have many misgivings about these categories. I prefer to understand “abnormal” behavior to be on a dimensional scale, not categorical, as is the HARE PCL — and for that matter how all mental health disorder are constructed. Categorizing humans in itself suggest a hubris most “psychopaths” tend to exhibit.
Perhaps the above descriptors will expand one’s understanding of a term that is getting a fair amount of play today. Getting impressions so to vote intelligently, is one thing, but it’s not diagnosing the candidate.
———
R. deVillers Seymour lives in Brunswick.
Comments are not available on this story. Read more about why we allow commenting on some stories and not on others.
We believe it's important to offer commenting on certain stories as a benefit to our readers. At its best, our comments sections can be a productive platform for readers to engage with our journalism, offer thoughts on coverage and issues, and drive conversation in a respectful, solutions-based way. It's a form of open discourse that can be useful to our community, public officials, journalists and others.
We do not enable comments on everything — exceptions include most crime stories, and coverage involving personal tragedy or sensitive issues that invite personal attacks instead of thoughtful discussion.
You can read more here about our commenting policy and terms of use. More information is also found on our FAQs.
Show less