Say you’re up at bat, expecting a fastball from the pitcher but he throws you a curveball instead. Do you throw down your bat and walk off the field?
That’s pretty much the explanation of Rep. Brian Hobart, R-Bowdoinham, for what he did on “Veto Day,” when he skipped out on the last chance to keep a historic solar bill alive.
To be clear, there’s no good reason for abandoning our job duties by not showing up for a vote, or “taking a walk” as it’s called at the State House. Hobart is in a real predicament because of what he did. I know that he wants to find a way out, but blaming someone else as he did in his recent opinion piece is not the answer.
Hobart took cover in the House Republican Office instead of staying in the House chamber to vote on the solar bill veto override a second time. We know House Republicans come under intense pressure from their leadership and Gov. Paul LePage. But what about doing the right thing? What about the duty that he and all of us lawmakers have to do our jobs?
LD 1649 was a chance to create hundreds of needed jobs in our homegrown solar industry, put solar power within the reach of more Maine families, companies, farms and other agricultural businesses, mitigate climate change and reduce electricity costs for all Maine ratepayers.
It took a lot of work to get to the bill that Hobart and his fellow House Republican killed. It was two years of hard work, including lots of give and take among folks who aren’t always on the same page. They represented Maine’s fledgling solar industry, utilities and environmentalists and worked with Maine’s public advocate, who is responsible for representing ratepayers’ interests.
Lawmakers from different parties worked on the measure and the final version was improved by a Republican amendment.
But the governor wanted it dead. And, as is too often the case, House Republican leadership backed him, even though it meant Maine would lose out. (The Republican-controlled Senate passed the bill 35-0.)
Hobart did vote once to override. Republican leadership turned up the heat on members who dared to break ranks. They knew they could kill the bill without all their people casting “No” votes, but they did need enough to take a walk.
Hobart and Reps. MaryAnne Kinney of Knox, John Pichiotti of Fairfield, Michael Timmons of Cumberland and Kathleen Dillingham of Oxford had all supported a veto override that day but purposely did not vote the second time. Rep. Timothy Theriault of China didn’t vote either time. Now, they’re sending out these columns as a smokescreen.
The second override opportunity came after House Majority Leader Jeff McCabe used a well-established parliamentary strategy — one that Hobart concedes is codified in the House rules — to ask whether the House would reconsider the veto. Republicans and independents joined Democrats in agreeing that the House should have another vote.
This procedure was used about a dozen times during the four-month legislative session that wrapped up on Veto Day alone. So, it’s unclear why Hobart claims to be so unfamiliar with it.
Now, Hobart is trying to salvage his reputation by claiming to be pro-solar despite his role in killing the bill. He’s even trying to sell people the story that he took the high moral ground by skipping the vote.
His constituents sent him to Augusta to do a job. It’s a job that requires pushing a button to register your vote and being willing to accept the consequences.
Fastball or curveball, it makes no difference. His job was to represent and, here, he truly failed to keep his eye on that ball.
———
Rep. Sara Gideon, D-Freeport, is the assistant House majority leader. She sponsored the bill that created the stakeholder process that led to LD 1649.
Comments are not available on this story. Read more about why we allow commenting on some stories and not on others.
We believe it's important to offer commenting on certain stories as a benefit to our readers. At its best, our comments sections can be a productive platform for readers to engage with our journalism, offer thoughts on coverage and issues, and drive conversation in a respectful, solutions-based way. It's a form of open discourse that can be useful to our community, public officials, journalists and others.
We do not enable comments on everything — exceptions include most crime stories, and coverage involving personal tragedy or sensitive issues that invite personal attacks instead of thoughtful discussion.
You can read more here about our commenting policy and terms of use. More information is also found on our FAQs.
Show less