Public Utilities Commissioner David Littell recently publicly recused himself from a decision that the PUC is hearing involving Nestle Water and a family-owned utility in Western Maine.
Recusing yourself when you have a real or perceived conflict of interest is a good thing; it should be encouraged and applauded. It’s a way that citizens can be confident that public officials are not influenced by past relationships when facing a decision involving a client from the past.
Littell had been associated with a law firm that is now representing Nestle. Nestle and tiny Fryeburg Water Company want to get approval for a 25-year contract allowing Fryeburg Water to sell groundwater to Nestle, a move opposed by many residents of the town and national advocates who say that Nestle isn’t paying enough and that the deal could put clean drinking water at risk in Fryeburg.
Gov. Paul LePage, however, told Littell that “the appearance of conflict” wasn’t a good enough reason to recuse himself.
Littell was the third commissioner to bow out because of ties to a company or law firm involved in the case. In one case, LePage appointed Justice Paul Rudman to hear the case, but the other commissioner has not been replaced. The governor intended Rudman and Littell to hear the case and decide it together.
But even if Littell has a change of heart — and we wouldn’t expect that from David Littell — that will leave the case without a quorum.
Two of Littell’s fellow commissioners, Mark Vannoy and Chair Thomas Welch, had worked for Nestle. Vannoy recused himself immediately, and Welch recused after press stories outlined his potential conflict of interest in the case in 2013. The case led the Legislature to sponsor legislation giving the governor power to designate alternatives and, in May, LePage appointed Justice Rudman to hear the case.
But the legislation had given Littell the chance to do what he thought he should do, which was to recuse himself as well.
Now the deal is in limbo, because there is only one temporary commissioner working on the issue.
Some legislators worry that the PUC, may never be able to decide this or other high-profile issues, since the commissioners have ties to many energy and water companies, or the specialized legal firms that represent them.
A solution may be to have a large pool of potential temporary commissioners, from outside the ordinary pools from which PUC commissioners are drawn for their expertise. Legal experts, land use planning boards from municipalities, and legal groups that act for the environment, such as the National Resources Defense Council, provided none of the individuals chosen are intervenors in the cases that come before them.
In any case, the governor should not be discouraging anyone from recusal in cases where the commissioner feels he has the appearance of conflict. That is the standard we hope for, and expect from, public officials in Maine.
It may take Nestle and Fryeburg Water Company a little while longer to close their deal without former Nestle employees and their lawyers on the commission. But if a deal is ultimately done, Maine should be confident that the process was clean and transparent.
Comments are not available on this story. Read more about why we allow commenting on some stories and not on others.
We believe it's important to offer commenting on certain stories as a benefit to our readers. At its best, our comments sections can be a productive platform for readers to engage with our journalism, offer thoughts on coverage and issues, and drive conversation in a respectful, solutions-based way. It's a form of open discourse that can be useful to our community, public officials, journalists and others.
We do not enable comments on everything — exceptions include most crime stories, and coverage involving personal tragedy or sensitive issues that invite personal attacks instead of thoughtful discussion.
You can read more here about our commenting policy and terms of use. More information is also found on our FAQs.
Show less