4 min read

Sigaud Arguments on Child Care Come Up Short

You recently re-printed column “Regulations Drive Up Cost of Maine Child Care” by Liam Sigaud of the Maine Heritage Policy Center. The thrust of the article was that excessive child care regulations harm low-income people without contributing to the quality of care. Mr. Sigaud seemed to make a conclusion and then collect arguments to back it up.

He wrote that low-income people pay 73 percent of their income for child care. However, he didn’t cite the level of pay, so readers can’t know what those parents actually pay. No one would pay 73 percent of one’s income for child care. That would not leave enough to live on. Perhaps he meant to say that they might have to pay at that level if they didn’t have support.

There is support, however. There are subsidies for low-income families that reduce the cost of child care and make quality child care placements attainable. Unfortunately, the LePage administration has made the subsidy application process so daunting that people give up and the monies go left unspent in Maine (see the veto message of LD1689).

Mr. Sigaud further maintains that there is an acute shortage of child care in Maine. Inexplicably, however, he only cites two family care providers as references, with no statewide data to back it up; hardly a convincing argument.

Advertisement

That article’s proposition point that regulations don’t produce quality is empty. Regulations, whether in child care, fishing, or farming, aren’t really designed to produce quality, except to bring it to a minimum level. Regulations don’t produce things, they prevent things, like child abuse and neglect.

Mr. Sigaud states that “quality of interaction” is the real measure of quality, but that group size doesn’t affect the quality. I was director of a child care center for eight years and have done assessment observations of about 50 child care and Pre-K programs across Maine. I would say that group size absolutely affects the quality of interaction, along with the education of the teachers, as he rightly notes. Group since affects workload, which affects stress, which affects the quality of interaction. It’s that simple.

I never felt that regulations were an undue burden and those providers that want to provide quality can and do find ways to do just that. However, they could do even better if the LePage administration would raise the amount it pays to providers from the federal funds it doesn’t use and aide low-income families in the process.

Dewey Meteer,
Nobleboro

Early Childhood Education a Smart Investment

A recent op-ed in the Times Record claimed that Maine is over-regulating its commercial child care providers and centers, and that less regulation of early childhood learning would help our state (Regulations Drive Up Cost of Maine Child Care, May 27). As a retired U.S. Navy admiral, I strongly disagree.

Advertisement

We in the military often use the term “readiness.” It is, in fact, part of the name of a national security organization to which I belong, called Mission: Readiness. We are a non-partisan group of retired senior military leaders calling for smart investments in America’s children so they are ready for their future, whether they choose to serve in the military or not.

Research shows that quality early childhood education is one of the smartest investments we can make in our children. These programs, including day care programs for the youngest children, are critical to developing the kind of leaders our country needs. They not only keep our kids safe when they cannot be with their parents or guardians, but they give our kids the right start by helping to develop the critical skills they need to succeed in school, ready to learn and grow at each step, and for some, ready to serve our country.

We need these early childhood programs to be the best they can be, and we believe the quality of these programs should be a priority in Maine. Our state’s children deserve the highest quality education possible at every stage and our nation’s future security depends on it.

Richard Mayo,
Harpswell

The Benefits of Early Learning Experiences

I recently read with great concern a piece in the Times Record by Liam Sigaud of the Maine Heritage Policy Center on the regulation of Maine’s child care centers. In the article, Mr. Siguad argues that we need less regulation of Maine’s child care centers. I believe that this would be inappropriate and potentially jeopardize our investment in our youngest and most important resources for the future of our state.

Advertisement

First, I cannot imagine anyone believing anything is more important than the well-being of our state’s young children. Maine monitors and licenses myriad fields for safety, quality and proper training — including K-12 teachers, police officers, and people working in my field of banking, to name just three.

Why would our youngest children deserve any less?

Furthermore, these child care centers are actually powerful learning centers for our future workers. They play a tremendously important role in the development of our kids. Often, the social and developmental skills kids learn in quality early learning centers are the basis for all of their future education. The foundation they begin to build in these programs can increase their chances of graduating from high school on time and with proficiency in key learning areas. It also helps put them on a path to be prepared for college and to be leaders in the workforce.

I would hope most reasonable people would not believe Mr. Sigaud’s suggestion that regulation of Maine’s child care centers is economically burdensome. A constructive review of the regulations would always be appropriate, but I would oppose simply a reduction in regulations. Instead, we should see the benefits these early learning experiences hold as investments in our state’s economy and the quality of our future workforce.

Bob Davis,
Harpswell



Comments are not available on this story. Read more about why we allow commenting on some stories and not on others.