The burned-out shell of a building at 16-18 Oak St. has been flattened, but one town official sees that property as symbolic of a lingering fissure in the town’s building standards.
On Monday, Codes Enforcement Officer Jeff Hutchinson presented to the Town Council a draft ordinance that would give the council authority to order the demolition of a building that the codes officer deems dangerous.
In the case of the Oak Street building, which stood vacant for approximately nine months before its ultimate demolition, Hutchinson wrote that the timeline “was frustrating for both the neighborhood and the town.”
“This proposed ordinance,” Hutchinson wrote, “will give the town the ability to resolve a similar event in a more reasonable time frame.”
Councilors ended discussion of the item, sponsored by councilors Benet Pols and Margo Knight, with no action Monday, but Hutchinson said Tuesday that the ordinance would likely return to a council agenda later this summer with changes resulting from Monday’s discussion.
Asked by The Times Record to review the proposed ordinance, Jeffrey Matthews, who owns the building at 16-18 Oak St., wrote in an email that he hopes town officials “would give a fair time frame for people to settle with insurance and do all the processes necessary to get everything done.”
Matthews wrote that after the fire at his building, he was told that it could take up to a year to settle the claim with his insurance company.
Those who were lukewarm on the idea expressed concern about the level of discretion such an ordinance would grant to the codes enforcement department.
“I personally am a little queasy about some of it because it’s a strange slippery slope,” Councilor Suzan Wilson said. “Where do you draw the line between a building that’s dilapidated and something unattractive and in disrepair?”
Councilors Joanne King, Sarah Brayman, David Watson, John Perreault and Wilson also expressed concerns about those definitions and how the ordinance would be used.
“I can see this being used as a tool for one neighbor against another neighbor,” King said.
Matthews echoed a concern that the proposed ordinance could allow the town to “pick and choose” which cases to pursue.
As presented to the council Monday, the ordinance would allow the codes enforcement officer to declare a building dangerous to life or property, and then set a timeline for either repair or demolition.
In the case of repair, the codes enforcement officer would specify the work to be done and a timeline for the work to be completed. Per the draft ordinance, if the codes enforcement officer recommended demolition, the owner would have 30 days to appeal that recommendation by “submit(ting) sufficient construction documents to the codes enforcement officer to support the owner’s claim.”
If an owner failed to comply with either recommendation of repair or demolition, the codes enforcement officer would have the ability to refer the case to the Town Council, which could then approve demolition of the building, picking up the cost of demolition from the owner within 30 days of demand or through a special tax assessed against the property.
To issue an order of demolition or other disposal, the proposed ordinance cites an existing state statute (17 MRSA § 2851) on dangerous buildings that gives municipalities the right to hold a hearing on buildings deemed dangerous to “make and record an order prescribing what disposal must be made of that building or structure.” On Tuesday, Lewiston began razing dwellings its codes department deemed to be uninhabitable public safety risks.
Councilors also expressed concern about the timeline granted to landowners to respond to any decisions from the codes office, especially in cases where delays are due to a slow insurance process or other factors outside of the landowner’s control.
This year, some councilors said they’ve received questions from neighbors about a home on McKeen Street, which has remained standing after a fire caused significant damage.
“As a town official, do you want to find yourself pushing a timeline that pushes a victim into a premature settlement with their insurance company or gives the insurance company few incentives for negotiating with the resident?” Wilson said. “It’s those kinds of concerns — who are the people that are most affected by the disrepaired building and who does this help or address?”
For Councilor Watson, the proposed ordinance raised broader concerns.
“I’m interested in constitutionality,” Watson said. “I know that’s an alien word to some people, but it’s not to me.”
dfishell@timesrecord.com
Comments are not available on this story. Read more about why we allow commenting on some stories and not on others.
We believe it's important to offer commenting on certain stories as a benefit to our readers. At its best, our comments sections can be a productive platform for readers to engage with our journalism, offer thoughts on coverage and issues, and drive conversation in a respectful, solutions-based way. It's a form of open discourse that can be useful to our community, public officials, journalists and others.
We do not enable comments on everything — exceptions include most crime stories, and coverage involving personal tragedy or sensitive issues that invite personal attacks instead of thoughtful discussion.
You can read more here about our commenting policy and terms of use. More information is also found on our FAQs.
Show less