
No, says the bank. It maintains that it was investing its own money and that its losses should have no effect on its depositors or borrowers.
But what would happen if its losses were so great that it would go under? Then the government might have to step in.
Why? The bank would be considered “too big to fail.”
In other words, it would be less costly to pump government money into it to keep it alive than to let it collapse.
Failure would have a huge effect on the economy by cutting off vitally needed credit for businesses and homebuyers. There might not even be enough federal deposit insurance to cover depositors’ losses.
Many people, who manage their finances well, resent having their tax dollars go toward bailing out banks that are “too big to fail.”
It used to be simple. Depositors would put money into savings accounts and receive interest. Banks would lend that money at somewhat higher rates to homebuyers and businesses. The bank made money on the difference between the two interest rates.
Federal law adopted after the Depression prevented depository banks from performing this function while also investing in financial markets. That way, depositors would always be protected from market losses.
But that federal law was repealed in 1999 in the belief that competition would keep banks from making risky investments.
That belief turned out to be wrong. Free to play the market, banks took big risks that turned sour.
The banks do not simply invest in company shares or real estate, they also invest in “derivatives.” A derivative has no value of its own and has no assets. Its value is derived from something else that does have value.
Here’s an example. A bank lends money to homebuyers and then sells the loans to investors. That means that investors take the risk that the borrowers won’t make their payments. The bank also sells a derivative to investors who bet that the loans will fail and people won’t make their mortgage payments.
The bank makes money whether the loans are repaid or not. In effect, it bets against itself, but seemingly cannot lose. That takes the bank a long way from the traditional business of accepting deposits and making loans.
The problem arises if the investors buying the loans and betting against them are the same people, and the loans do fail. The bank does not get the payments it expects from loan buyers, but must pay the derivative purchasers.
That’s just what happened about five years ago. Finally, some banks had to turn to Uncle Sam to save them from going under.
Some complex derivative deals are only understood by a few people, who are far removed from the normal banking business.
As the J.P. Morgan Chase fiasco showed, the problem was not only that the banks were “too big to fail,” but that they were becoming “too complicated to fail.” Few people even understood what they were doing and that included the top bank officers and government regulators, who lacked authority to demand information from the banks.
This is mainly a problem with the big banks, but it could affect everybody who pays taxes used for bailouts.
What’s the solution so no more bailouts will be needed?
Congress decided that it ought to go back to preventing banks that accept deposits from playing in the investment world. While it did not go as far as the previous law, it intended that depositors, most of us in the real world who have nothing to do with derivatives, should be protected.
The average bank customer, who also happens to be a taxpayer, would be protected by banning certain bank investment activities and by increased bank disclosure to regulators.
The details were left the Securities and Exchange Commission, the federal regulator, which could determine just how tough enforcement would be.
The SEC came under strong pressure from the banks, led by J.P. Morgan Chase, to water down the new law. Too much regulation, the bankers claimed, would hurt the economy.
The agency has been dragging its feet in adopting the necessary new rules. Last week, a bipartisan group of 58 members of Congress demanded prompt action. Perhaps the J.P. Morgan Chase loss will prompt the SEC to get the law fully into effect.
Those of us who dislike bank bailouts probably hope so. Better regulation is the payoff we deserve for the last bailout.
Comments are not available on this story. Read more about why we allow commenting on some stories and not on others.
We believe it's important to offer commenting on certain stories as a benefit to our readers. At its best, our comments sections can be a productive platform for readers to engage with our journalism, offer thoughts on coverage and issues, and drive conversation in a respectful, solutions-based way. It's a form of open discourse that can be useful to our community, public officials, journalists and others.
We do not enable comments on everything — exceptions include most crime stories, and coverage involving personal tragedy or sensitive issues that invite personal attacks instead of thoughtful discussion.
You can read more here about our commenting policy and terms of use. More information is also found on our FAQs.
Show less