3 min read

In the last few days, in the wake of actor Robin Williams’ suicide, there has been a slew of people weighing in, not a one of whom lived in Williams’ skin, woke up in his brain or dealt with his misery.

Some claimed that Williams’ suicide was “selfish.” Others insisted it was not selfish, and no one should ever, ever suggest that suicide is a selfish act.

Suicide is a tragedy. It’s a means to end what the victim believes is a struggle he or she cannot win, whether it’s a physical, mental or emotional struggle. The disease robs the victim of any hope or joy or peace. The suicide may not feel that he or she has a choice; that life has become intolerable; that only years of pain stretch out endlessly ahead.

But let’s be honest. No one wakes up brightly one morning and says, “You know what, I’m going to take my life on behalf of my loved ones today. It’s just the right thing to do.”

No one says that. No loved one of a suicide victim says that they’d wish their depression-victim husband or wife or brother or mother to commit suicide, either.

Advertisement

People who commit suicide know that’s going to be the reaction, that’s why they don’t ask permission. They may not even leave an explanation.

Suicide may be entirely understandable because of a victim’s deep depression, but no one commits such a final act actively thinking about the destruction to their family’s and friends’ lives that will inevitably follow. The questions, the wondering, the guilt, the anger, the sorrow … visiting these on family and friends and coworkers is quite simply not a selfless act.

With some 30,000 Americans committing suicide every year, and another three quarters of a million people attempting suicide in any given year, the most important thing we can say about suicide is that it is a public health emergency.

If there were 750,000 Americans injured by any other condition that would ultimately kill 30,000 of them annually, we’d be doing a lot more than we’re doing. We’d have a Manhattan Project or a War on Depression or something. We’d be training doctors and psychiatrists on the public dime to get out there and work with these victims as soon as humanly possible. We’d be looking for a cure that didn’t make them feel worse than they felt untreated. We’d be screening for these conditions in schools and workplaces and we’d set up mobile trailers in grocery store parking lots to allow people to come in and be screened and treated, free of charge.

We’d set up treatment facilities where people could be helped with the necessities of life until their cures kicked in. We’d understand that their minds were impaired; we wouldn’t expect them to make selfless decisions under the influence of the blackness of despair. Mental illness would stop making a patient a pariah. The patient would instead be regarded as any other ill person … one who deserves sympathy and compassion … and treatment.

What depression shouldn’t be given is either disdain or romance.

Robin Williams and all those who lose their battle with depression should be considered victims of a deadly disease that takes the lives of 30,000 Americans every year … like prostate cancer. If Williams had died of prostate cancer, we’d be full of sympathy for his surviving family and we’d make a mental note to ask our GP for a test this year. We wouldn’t find ourselves on either side of a yawning divide, on one side, those who believe Williams was a coward for committing suicide, and on the other side, those who idealize the tortured comic genius. Neither is true, and neither is healthy.



Comments are not available on this story. Read more about why we allow commenting on some stories and not on others.