3 min read

There aren’t many times when we are expected to look 20 years down the road into a crystal ball and set public policy in almost immutable stone.

One of the few times is when towns and cities create a mysterious document called the “Comprehensive Plan,” and its little cousin, the “Zoning Ordinances.” A comprehensive plan is more than just the town’s ordinances and codes, it’s an attempt to figure out what the life of the town will be like in the somewhat distant future, and formulate policy based on that assumption. Zoning ordinances make blanket decisions about what people can and cannot do with their own land, in some cases, generations after the land came into their family’s possession.

Both are usually notoriously wrong about what will be going on years down the road. Bath’s previous comprehensive plan assumed … or perhaps hoped … that there would be multiple shipyards and other marine-based businesses in Bath. That didn’t occur. But in the meantime, projects were refused that might have earned the city money, or at least taken land that was not garnering property tax and putting it back to work.

The reason why the Stinson Cannery building was never used for any other purpose, and why, after it burned, nothing was ever done with the land, prime real estate on Bath’s waterfront, was that the comprehensive plan dictated that the land be used only for marine industry. It’s now been eight years since the fire, and the land is still lying empty.

Stinson Cannery was an anachronism in the last 20 years of its own life; an upscale neighborhood had grown up around it that didn’t appreciate fish innards splattering on the street in front of their homes and heavy trucks clattering down a tiny one and a half lane road at all hours.

Advertisement

But the Bath comprehensive plan was insisting that the land be used for marine industry, an industry that, to be blunt, isn’t beating down the door to settle in Bath.

Stinson Cannery wasn’t alone. There were several properties along the waterfront in the north end that were never going to be shipyards again in this world, but any other development was being stymied because the Comprehensive Plan, written years before, really really wanted Bath to be “ the city of ships” and not the “city of small, tasteful, upscale housing with a river view”… which is what it is.

The problem with treating comprehensive plans as something other than a collection of town ordinances and codes is that our planning boards and councils are infusing them with meaning they probably shouldn’t have. Yes, there are things we can say in a comprehensive plan — we can say that we would really like to see more public parks, or bike paths, or even that we’d like to encourage industry or commerce. But we need to keep these things somewhat vague. We shouldn’t be shutting the door on possibilities that don’t mesh with what a previous generation thought it wanted when it wrote a comprehensive plan. That doesn’t mean that we need to accept all comers in a town, or that we can’t exclude industry that might not be a good fit with our towns. But it does mean that each proposal should be considered on its merits, not on the strength of what the previous town planner or the last generation of planning board members thought was a good idea.

Brunswick is now considering writing zone ordinances that will have an effect on residents, farmers, foresters, and property owners, and will affect the Bowdoin College community and the immediate neighborhood. Zoning ordinances may need to change, but Brunswick should avoid making the mistakes that Bath made during its process.



Comments are not available on this story. Read more about why we allow commenting on some stories and not on others.