2 min read

My Sept. 9 guest column noted statistical discrepancies in the Northern New England Passenger Rail Authority’s reporting of Amtrak “Downeaster” passenger traffic. Aside from whether total ridership was up or down for the fiscal year ended in June, the more pertinent subject locally is the effect of the 22-month-old route extension beyond Portland to Brunswick. As the new service becomes recognized throughout the Midcoast region, is there “overwhelmingly positive” evidence of market acceptance to justify additional daily runs, as the Authority contends? The only reported yardstick was a combined 52,000 Freeport and Brunswick patrons for the first full calendar year, 2013.

One revealing measure that does assure comparability is the actual passenger count taken for each arriving and departing train at Brunswick. For the first eight months of 2014, that station alone accounted for 20,744 oneway trips versus 23,255 in the corresponding period a year ago, a decline of 10.8 percent. Only one of the eight months this year (June) was ahead of the corresponding 2013 figure.

Possible explanations for the year-to-year downtrend are that (1) the novelty effect of a new transportation option and heavy introductory fare discounting stimulated ridership in the early months of 2013 and (2) unusual winter weather and extended trip-time delays south of Portland in June and July reduced the 2014 count. In addition, some travelers likely have chosen to drive to the Portland Transportation Center for a wider choice of scheduled rail and bus connections to more Boston-area destinations than is possible via train from Brunswick.

The open question remains the extent of additional market potential for the 28-mile extension. If ridership is the sole standard of success, the Authority’s proposal to run more trains to Brunswick should produce the desired result in absolute numbers, even if some patrons are diverted from the present two daily round trips. Cost-effectiveness is a different matter, however, as nominal extra revenue earned north of Portland inevitably dilutes the “Downeaster’s” present 55 percent farebox coverage of above-the-rail operating expenses, thereby increasing the claim for state subsidy. Either way, this operation needs more riders per train, not more trains for the available number of interested riders.

George Betke
President, Transport
Economics Inc.
Newcastle



Comments are not available on this story. Read more about why we allow commenting on some stories and not on others.