4 min read

 
 
Back-in-the-day, river log drives were a common event in Maine, and with every log drive came logjams. To release logjams, courageous loggers ventured onto a floating and shifting island of timber, armed with poles and sometimes dynamite, so the flotilla could resume its progress toward the mill. Today, we face a massive logjam that prevents the kind of action to reduce climate emissions that any prudent risk analyst would say is required. We need some dynamite.

I see three basic paths to sharp and rapid reductions in climate emissions: a) technological breakthroughs in renewable energy or capturing carbon from fossil fuel use; b) a “moral awakening” in which we all decide to spend more of our budget on renewable energy and less on other things, or we learn to get along with less energy; and c) changes in public policy.

While I continue to support paths “a” and “b,” I don’t think we should bet the farm on them. Unfortunately, the public policy path for climate action is largely a stalemate and can be boiled down to liberals (including me, on most matters) arguing for more government subsidies for renewable energy and more government regulation of fossil fuel emissions, and conservatives essentially arguing that the uncertainties about climate change are still large enough that we should avoid any policy action rather than experience the problems that would accompany any further growth of government.

However, there is a relatively new policy proposal that is gaining acceptance across the political spectrum called a “revenue-neutral carbon tax,” which may just provide us with the dynamite we need. This policy would tax fossil fuel emissions but return all the money collected to the American people. By increasing the cost of fossil fuels through an annually increasing tax but returning all the tax revenue, the price of fossil fuel would be closer its true cost to society, and the market system would be used to incentivize a transition to cleaner energy (instead of using government subsidies or complicated regulations). A fee system would be used at the U.S. border to adjust the cost of imports and exports so U.S. businesses wouldn’t be harmed, and to incentivize other countries to impose a similar carbon tax of their own.

Unfortunately, this policy would require conservatives to vote for the ‘“t” word. But as George Shultz has pointed out, “It’s not a tax if the government doesn’t keep the money.” On the other hand, this policy would require liberals to trade-off their long-standing fight for government subsidies and regulations in favor of a more marketbased approach. A recent report done by the highly credible Regional Economic Models, Inc. (REMI) shows that in 20 years this policy would reduce annual U.S. carbon dioxide emissions to 50 percent of 1990 levels, while increasing GDP and employment, and reducing premature deaths. In short it would be a win for the environment, for the economy, and for public health.

Advertisement

A number of influential conservatives now favor this policy, including former Secretary of State George Shultz, supply-side-economics guru Arthur Laffer, and former South Carolina congressman Bob Inglis, who runs the Energy and Enterprise Initiative at George Mason University in Virginia, and who was featured in a Sept. 22 interview on the topic for National Geographic’s website. The most prominent group in support of this policy, however, is the Citizens’ Climate Lobby (CCL), a non-partisan non-profit with a rapidly growing number of citizen lobbyists based in local chapters (over 200 nationally, including groups in Brunswick, Bangor and Waterville), supported by a small but dedicated national staff.

This policy, in the context of a growing public sense that the risks of climate change have increased, may be the dynamite that enables us to break through the logjam. As additional climate disasters and other pressures cause more conservatives to look around for a climate action policy that is consistent with their commitment to accountability and limited government, I hope they will decide to support this policy. If that happens, I hope my liberal friends will decide to support this policy as well. In the meantime, I hope you’ll join us or another local CCL chapter to help hasten this outcome.

———

John Newlin is co-founder of the Midcoast Maine chapter of CCL, which meets in Brunswick, and is Maine’s CCL “group-start” leader. He blogs at carbontaxadvocates.net.


Comments are not available on this story. Read more about why we allow commenting on some stories and not on others.