Lots of discussion has arisen recently about minimum wage and in Maine there is a referendum question on the ballot which proposes a minimum wage increase to $12 by 2020, from $7.50 now.
Also, if Question 4 passes, the law will also include inflation increases after 2020, and an elimination of the tip credit, which is used primarily in restaurants for servers’ wages. Currently, servers get an hourly wage of half of minimum wage per hour as their tips more than make up for the other half.
If for some reason at the end of the shift a server’s tips don’t cover the $7.50 minimum wage level, the employer makes up the difference — that is the tip credit. To make up the difference, servers need to make $3.75 per hour in tips, which happens nearly every time (think about what your minimum tip at a restaurant is and you see how easily that wage is made up).
There have been lots of stories for the reasons to raise minimum wage, and though the logic for some of these arguments is severely flawed, other arguments in favor of a raise are quite legitimate. I am currently a proponent of an increased minimum wage, but to $10, not to $12. How did I come to that?
Back in February, I worked with other chamber directors around the state and I created an eight-question business survey asking about the effects of a $12 minimum wage by 2020. In that survey, 75.9 percent of respondents said they preferred a $10 option that did not eliminate the tip credit, as opposed to the $12 proposal with elimination of the tip credit.
The final question of the survey was open-ended and just asked, “Do you have anything else you would like to share?”
Below are the responses from businesses, straight from them. Not enough businesses are standing up and telling their side of the story, so this is my effort to start to tell their untold tale. Here are several responses, straight from employers, in their own words.
“It will be the end of hiring high school-aged or just graduated young people in my business. It will eliminate 5-6 jobs for young people” — retailer, Somerset County
“Making the wage too high will force the business to pick between the younger workforce or the more mature (employee) which will most likely lead to the business picking the more experienced, reliable mature person.” — retailer, York County
“The only reason my restaurant can survive is having my employees make money from tips. If I had to pay them more hourly, I wouldn’t be able to pay the bills and I would go out of business.” — restaurateur, York County
“I agree that most long-term employees that have worked hard to be at that $12 would be very disappointed to have new employees starting at that level. Very counterproductive.” — automotive, Piscataquis County
“Education is greatly needed to help people to understand that these increases have to be paid for by someone. Either businesses (which may cause them to go out of business), consumers (which may impact our tourist industry here in Maine), or driving businesses elsewhere. … We want that option (wages) based on performance and experience. Not dictated to us by law.” — lodging, Cumberland County
“With the small margins in the convenience industry, an increase in the minimum wage would necessitate store-wide price increases to cover the increased cost of payroll. Of course this would erode the consumers’ purchasing power, which the wage increase was intended to boost.” — convenience store, York County
“Arbitrarily raising the minimum wage results in higher cost of goods which in effect negates the benefits of a higher wage. Wages should be driven by the market.” — electrician, Somerset County
“Businesses and employees will adjust. Retirees with relatively fixed earnings, will pay. They are the largest growing group of purchasers and will bear a disproportional percentage of the necessary increases.” — retiree, Piscataquis County
“I would need to reduce hours of my full-time employees if the citizen’s initiative passes.” — retailer, Somerset County
“My business has tipped employees, and if forced to pay the new proposed rates I will simply default on my mortgage, and shut down, and 12-15 employees would be out of work. This is so backwards. Please educate the people that this simply does not work.” — bar/hotel, Somerset County
Comments are not available on this story. Read more about why we allow commenting on some stories and not on others.
We believe it's important to offer commenting on certain stories as a benefit to our readers. At its best, our comments sections can be a productive platform for readers to engage with our journalism, offer thoughts on coverage and issues, and drive conversation in a respectful, solutions-based way. It's a form of open discourse that can be useful to our community, public officials, journalists and others.
We do not enable comments on everything — exceptions include most crime stories, and coverage involving personal tragedy or sensitive issues that invite personal attacks instead of thoughtful discussion.
You can read more here about our commenting policy and terms of use. More information is also found on our FAQs.
Show less