
Specifically, Maine needs to work on three major issues in order to be competitive in the future. The first is its roads and bridges and other transportation infrastructure, as well as state-wide internet. The second is upgrading its schools, universities and public buildings to make them more energy efficient and improve educational quality so that the young people who graduate from them are able to take on the jobs of the 21st century. And the third is to invest — heavily — in energy infrastructure and weatherization of our aging buildings so that Maine is not dependent on the vagaries of fossil fuel energy pricing, especially from fuel produced in other regions of the country.
Bonding vs. pay-as-you-go
Maine is like many other places in the country in that we have pulled back from infrastructure, even though we have had historically low interest rates. The truth is that investing, even now, in infrastructure would mean that we would save money, even paying interest, than by saving up and doing the work when the money is in the bank.
It works like this. If we borrow a million dollars to invest in a bridge, say, we have to pay the million back, plus the interest on the bond. Interest rates for municipal bonds and infrastructure bonds are still shockingly low, about 2 percent. Over 20 years, the typical life of such a bond, we would pay about $214,000 in interest. But the truth is that if we saved up to do the bridge even 10 years down the road, when we could afford it, we’d be much worse off.
First, the cost of materials, labor, and fuel would be much more, and probably much more than the cost of the interest we would spend if we did the work today. Secondly, something dreadful could happen in those ten years that we would be liable for, since we know the bridge is deficient. This could cost us millions more in personal injury, death, or property claims. Third, we might easily lose out on matching funds, TIFs, and other inducements that are regularly offered by the federal governement and towns that would halve our investment.
All of these things are real and measurable. But there is another issue, which may be harder to quantify. How many businesses don’t open in the vicinity of the bridge because there is space open at another, safer location? How many tourists and visitors don’t come to the town because they don’t want their car to be destroyed or have heard bad things about the road or bridge? Is there another benefit to doing the work? Would we save money or even make money over the long run? How many jobs would have been created to do the work that aren’t being created now?
Some of these issues won’t ever be known, and some can’t be known until and unless the work is done, comparing one town’s experience to another similar town’s experience.
Maine is already being told that businesses expect up-to-date, quality roads and bridges, and other transportation infrastructure. Tourists and visitors tell the state that it’s beautiful and buccolic, but they don’t feel safe on Maine roads. Some roads to some well-known tourist areas are so clogged with traffic that the towns and whole regions are skipped, even though they have a lot to offer.
We don’t know how much money our businesses are losing every year because visitors are going to the White Mountains instead of the Mid-coast, but it is no doubt a considerable sum.
The same is true of repairing and making more efficient public buildings and even weatherizing the aging housing stock in Maine. The least expensive kilowatt-hour is one that is never used, so increasing the R-factor of homes, schools, and other public buildings, and adding energy generation where possible — flat roofs of high schools make great places for solar arrays and even small wind turbines — means that the cost of energy over the long term drops dramatically. Spending a million dollars to improve Morse High School’s energy efficiency, for instance, would probably pay for itself within a year or two.
Business ‘unfriendliness’ more than taxes
When one asks a business why they don’t choose to set up shop in Maine, our supposed “high” taxes are relatively low on their list of priorities. The perceived lack of a well-prepared workforce, the high cost of energy, and infrastructure issues, including large infrastructure problems such as bridges, roads, railroads, ports, and internet, are the main reasons businesses decline to work in Maine.
What Maine must do and do quickly is improve education from preK through graduate school to attract businesses who need a prepared workforce. If it helps to consider this an “infrastructure” issue, then we must do it. That will mean more money quickly, while school structures are improved or replaced, with a well-considered curriculum that is more than a set of national standards. School should be less about a series of tests than a developmental process in which critical analysis and problem solving are more important than memorization. That may mean that some of the most cherished notions of modern education need to be revisited. We will look at Common Core next week and discuss how the new standards would improve workforce preparedness and thus Maine’s economy — or not. Higher education needs more, not fewer, majors, especially in engineering, technology, mathematics and the sciences, and majors specific to Maine’s unique needs — hospitality and recreation, agriculture, silvaculture and marine sciences, and majors to support health care, emerging Maine economies such as green energy and retrofitting older homes, preschool education, and many other fields.
The cost of energy in Maine is a harder and more complex problem, but also one that can be re-thought if we as a state are willing to think out of the box. Some technologies are in their infancy, but other carbon free energy choices are working well in places that get less sunlight, less wind, and have less in terms of hydropower, than does Maine. With the cost of solar and wind coming down, and the efficiency of other energies — heat pumps for home heating, for instance, and wood and wood pellets, grown in Maine — improving by leaps and bounds, Efficiency Maine is trying to encourage residents to buy these systems. The greater the abandonment of carbon based fuels, the more funding Maine receives through its participation in the Regional Greenhouse Gas Initiative, or RGGI, and the more funding Efficiency Maine has to create rebate programs and lend to homeowners and businesses who are attempting to upgrade their homes’ and businesses’ efficiency.
Maine is considering purchasing hydropower from Quebec. To that end, Maine is attempting to create a new transmission line, called the Green Line, which will also transport Maine’s wind power — and possibly solar and tidal power as well — down the line from Orrington, Maine, to Tewksbury, Massachusetts. This line, if built, will serve to replace energy lost when Vermont Yankee closes by the end of the year, as well as the energy lost when two coal plants in Massachusetts close. Without it, there could well be energy shortages in New England by 2017.
It’s not surprising that businesses are taking a wait-and-see attitude about moving to Maine. But there are things the next Governor and Legislature can do, if they work together, to move them off the fence.
Comments are not available on this story. Read more about why we allow commenting on some stories and not on others.
We believe it's important to offer commenting on certain stories as a benefit to our readers. At its best, our comments sections can be a productive platform for readers to engage with our journalism, offer thoughts on coverage and issues, and drive conversation in a respectful, solutions-based way. It's a form of open discourse that can be useful to our community, public officials, journalists and others.
We do not enable comments on everything — exceptions include most crime stories, and coverage involving personal tragedy or sensitive issues that invite personal attacks instead of thoughtful discussion.
You can read more here about our commenting policy and terms of use. More information is also found on our FAQs.
Show less