4 min read

HARPSWELL

The Harpswell Board of Selectmen unanimously voiced support for a proposal to place an article on the annual Town Meeting warrant to issue $110,000 to a nonprofit group for legal expenses associated with gaining public access to Cedar Beach.

No action was taken at the selectboard’s Wednesday meeting, pending consultation with the town’s attorney regarding the legality of issuing public funds to a private group and discussion with the budget committee.

Cedar Beach/ Cedar Island Supporters President Mike Helfgott addressed the selectboard and several group members in attendance at the meeting, noting that there has been strong public support for their efforts to regain beach access.

At the 2013 Town Meeting, “the people of Harpswell really overwhelmingly voted to put $ 220,00 toward what was then a new effort to see if we could … regain access to Cedar Beach,” said Helfgott.

Advertisement

“We’ve been incredibly successful in raising money to pursue this legal fight,” he said. “ That means that I’m talking primarily about the people of this town who have really dug deep into their pockets to come up with almost $200,000.”

CB/CIS formed in 2012 to pursue access to the historically public beach and filed two lawsuits against property owners abbutting Cedar Beach who blocked public passage to the beach area.

One lawsuit, concerning a parcel with a footpath to the beach area, was settled in mediation and access was reopened to Harpswell residents and their guests.

In September, Superior Court Justice Nancy Mills ruled in favor of CB/CIS in the second lawsuit, against the owners of Cedar Beach Road — Charles and Sally Abrahamson, who in July sold the road to co-defendant Betsy Atkins’ company Gables Real Estate LLC.

Though Mills ruled that there is a prescriptive public easement on Cedar Beach Road, which reopened the road to the public, that ruling is likely to be appealed, according to beach access advocates.

The group has spent roughly $190,000 in legal fees to reach this point, according to Helfgott, and fees are continuing to accrue as the group pushes for a final ruling.

Advertisement

“We really don’t want to take the town up on its offer to fund us at the level of $220,000,” said Helfgott. “ That doesn’t mean that what we’re asking of the town we’re absolutely certain will be enough, but we’re willing to put ourselves at continued risk to fund our future role in this fight.”

The current town authorization for $220,000 will expire Dec. 31, and instead the group requested an article be placed on the 2015 Town Meeting warrant to half that amount — $110,000 — to the group to pay for accrued and future fees.

“There is no doubt … in anybody’s mind that the town wanted to shoulder this along with us,” said Helfgott. “They wanted to participate in this solution and frankly the only way that can happen is if the money is allowed to be conveyed to us sooner than after all is said and done.”

“ I don’t believe we’re ready to make any decision on this this evening,” said Selectboard Chairman Rick Daniel, who noted that the language for a warrant article had to be vetted by the town’s attorney and fund acquisition discussed with the budget committee.

“ Roads were slippery tonight and a lot of people came out,” said CB/ CIS board member Martin Eisenstein. “ It would be nice for us to know what the views are of the selectmen.”

“I see no reason at this time why I wouldn’t support this going to Town Meeting,” said Daniel.

Advertisement

Selectman Kevin Johnson, who was initially a plaintiff in the CB/ CIS lawsuits, and withdrew when he ran for public office, said he was also in favor of placing an article on the Town Meeting warrant.

“ I certainly think I would supports this going to Town Meeting, assuming that our attorney doesn’t find some problem. The concern is the public-private intersection here,” said Selectman Elinor Multer. “ Road associations used to get a little money from the town for their winter plowing and all of a sudden it stopped.”

She noted that a state official had determined that practice granted public money to private organizations, “and it wasn’t legal in Maine.”

“ That question hangs over this and I have no idea whether it will have an impact,” said Multer. “Frankly, I hope it’s not a problem. We’ll never have calm again unless their question goes to the public.”

Approval of an article will be discussed at a future Board of Selectmen’s meeting, the date of which was not determined.

rgargiulo@timesrecord.com



Comments are not available on this story. Read more about why we allow commenting on some stories and not on others.