4 min read

Douglas McIntire
Douglas McIntire
Another Valentine’s Day came and went this week and it reminded me of simpler times.

No, wait.

That’s how it usually goes, isn’t it? I’ll muse about something from my past and before you know it, you’re smack in the middle of a snark-filled Pepperidge Farm commercial.

Valentine’s Day was anything but simple when I was a kid and it’s the Sherry Effect I blame for the whole mess.

You say you’ve never heard of the Sherry Effect? I may have given it a name but I’m sure some of you have been put in a tight spot of frustration and anxiety by this very concept at one point or another in your childhood.

Advertisement

Think back: Do remember all those boxes of generic Valentine’s cards we used to get as kids to hand out at school? Some were themed, like Peanuts or Bugs Bunny. I seem to remember going no frills and getting generic, goofy cards with every sentiment from “Be mine” to the simple “Happy Valentine’s Day.” The latter was useful across the board but since there were only a handful of them, I set those aside for the boys in class. This was the beginning of the Sherry Effect.

You see, in the many cruel twists of learning how to be fair as a child, I was forced to make out a card for every student in my class, every student. This meant kids I didn’t like, kids I didn’t know, girls I hoped would really respond to my card and, naturally, those I wished didn’t respond.

It was a noble rule — my parents didn t want any kids left out like a sad Charlie Brown peering into his mailbox. Now that I think about it, it was more of a lesson in insincere altruism than fairness. Hey Dave, remember when you tripped me and my lunch went all over the cafeteria? Here s your Valentine!

Also set aside were the heavy hitters like “Be mine!” This was targeted mailing at its finest as I walked around passing out tiny envelopes. But then there was Sherry.

To be honest, I didn’t really know anything about Sherry and I’m sure she was a perfectly lovely person but the point was this: If asked what I thought of her, my response would have been, I don’t. In fact, I knew so little of her I didn’t have any idea how she would respond to getting a card from me and therefore lumped her with Dave from above and really didn t want to give her one at all.

I wasn’t being mean as much as I hated this level of disingenuous behavior, even though I had no earthly idea what disingenuous was at the time.

Advertisement

Now Jenn, on the other hand. Jenn was in solid “Be mine”- range and practically had to bring in a shopping bag to cart home all her cards. Donna was worth a “Be mine” and the cutest shape of a puppy in the box.

See that frolicking puppy, Donna? That’s me around you on the playground.

Donna, who always came to school impeccably dressed. Donna, who had short, perfectly feathered hair that never got messed up. Donna was Coffin School perfection and all the boys fell in line behind her even at an age when most girls were gross, in cafeteria vernacular.

But Sherry? Sherry was a stranger, making my few genuine Valentine attempts pedestrian.

Then there was the back-hand of the Sherry Effect. How was I to know if the Valentine I received from Jenn was genuine or whether she was also forced to pencil her name on the envelope? Was I Jenn’s Sherry? Then, of all horrors, those I didn’t get a card from at all! Now, I’m not even good enough for the Sherry Effect to secure me a card! It s enough to make a third grader s head spin.

Luckily, Valentine’s Day has become much simpler now. For one thing, there s only been one girl in the class now for about 16 years. She knows I’m not coming home with a cartoon puppy and a giant “Be mine!” across it and she’s fine with that.

Advertisement

So, here we are, folks. We finally have a story that s the antithesis of the Pepperidge Farm commercials. It’s kind of more like the old man hawking Country Time lemonade. We re now a little grayer, rocking on the porch and enjoying the unencumbered now.

Sherry, I don’t know what became of her, where she is or what her life is like but despite naming an undesirable phenomena after her, I hope she has all the Valentines in life she can carry.

Douglas McIntire is a writer and educator in the Midcoast and can receive Valentines ! The Times Record P.O. Box 10, 3 Business Pkwy., Brunswick, ME 04011-1302 or email him at broughtupbrunswick@gmail.com.


Comments are not available on this story. Read more about why we allow commenting on some stories and not on others.