
Already, the much vaunted and ever-present “circular firing squad” is taking aim within the party, but while there is certainly a reason to ask some honest questions about the direction of the party and our electoral strategies on both a macro and micro scale, it is important not to lose sight that the purpose of these questions should be to learn and adapt, not assign blame.
Like the old saying goes: “Success has many parents, but failure is an orphan.”
Should people wish to play the blame game, there is always plenty to go around, but it seldom accomplishes much. We had countless good candidates across the country, and what happened is not a reflection on them.
But I do not believe all, or indeed most, of the Republican Party’s future is doom and gloom. On the contrary, I believe that this can serve as an opportunity to make some significant and lasting changes.
First, I want to dispel any doubt in the core tenets of conservative philosophy. The problem is not the issues; it’s the way they are sometimes presented.
It is ironic that the very idea of real conservatism — the right of the individual — serves to provide consistent fodder for the perceived divisions that exist in any organization. The irony is compounded by the fact that the Democratic Party, claiming to support the “common man” (or woman), has no such trouble because the very nature of their party leadership brooks no dissent, no compromise, and no quarter.
Second, we must accept that, thus far, our efforts to court various demographics have failed.
We will never “out-Democrat the Democrats,” nor should we try. Rather, the GOP must stress its heritage of not only the party of personal liberty, but also of personal responsibility.
When grappling with the question of how to appeal to demographics that seem to have voted overwhelmingly Democratic on Nov. 6, the argument must be framed in a way that highlights these broad distinctions, while still providing a compelling argument to vote Republican.
Too frequently, elections come down to a contest of facts against personalities. The analysis seems to be that, if you don’t have the facts, you can still win on personality — or enough money — as we have seen here in southern Maine over the last few years.
We can no longer afford to let the other party have a monopoly on personality, and trust that the facts alone will sway an electorate.
To be blunt, the box that something comes in does count: A brown paper bag that contains a bar of gold won’t get the same attention as bright wrapping paper and glitter wrapped around a lump of coal.
Third, and most importantly, we as Republicans must get serious with ourselves.
Much has been made of the divisions within our own party, and the very public feuding and attacks launched by some has been reckless, to say the least.
In my background as a senior officer on a ship, I recognize there are times when you must question the orders being given by those above you — but during a battle or emergency is not the time to do it.
In such times, everyone must pull in the same direction, and to fail to do so betrays that one is more concerned with scoring political points and making headlines than actually accomplishing real victories that will benefit all of America — not the “1 percent” or the “47 percent” or whatever percentage strikes your fancy.
Being a “conservative” and being a “Republican” is not necessarily the same thing, but the two are inexorably linked in modern America.
Therefore, those who identify with one or the other — or both — must recognize that what unites us as a party — indeed, what unites us all as Americans, regardless of political ideology — is far more complicated than a checklist of issues, which only serves to further divide an already fractured American people.
The Republican Party will win — and win big — when we start talking big. No one has to compromise his or her values and principles.
Rather, we will achieve success because we will no longer be putting values and principles into a niche while attempting to win an election based on pettiness, smallness and political smoke and mirrors. Once more, I will reiterate — the GOP will never “out-Democrat the Democrats.”
We can be true to our principles and still tolerate disagreements with others.
We can compromise in government without compromising our beliefs.
We can work for a better tomorrow without sacrificing today.
But there is a difference in being true to our beliefs and being caricatures of them. There is a difference between deep philosophies in government and personal attack. And most importantly, there is a difference in the two major parties.
The year 2012 was not the end of the Republican Party, no more than 2004 was the end of the Democratic Party. Too many prognosticators are already chirping that this election means the end of all we hold dear.
To that, I can only paraphrase John Paul Jones, the father of the United States Navy: “We have not yet begun to fight.”
PATRICK CALDER, a Portland Republican, is a former candidate for U.S. House of Representatives in Maine’s 1st Congressional District.
Comments are not available on this story. Read more about why we allow commenting on some stories and not on others.
We believe it's important to offer commenting on certain stories as a benefit to our readers. At its best, our comments sections can be a productive platform for readers to engage with our journalism, offer thoughts on coverage and issues, and drive conversation in a respectful, solutions-based way. It's a form of open discourse that can be useful to our community, public officials, journalists and others.
We do not enable comments on everything — exceptions include most crime stories, and coverage involving personal tragedy or sensitive issues that invite personal attacks instead of thoughtful discussion.
You can read more here about our commenting policy and terms of use. More information is also found on our FAQs.
Show less