
End some of the red tape, they argued, and the free market will provide competition and bring down costs. Supporters went so far as to say that all uninsured people in Maine would be able to afford coverage.
Although much of the plan remains to be implemented, four of its provisions have already gone into effect, and have already caused higher net premiums for most policyholders.
The law permits insurance companies to increase the difference between what they charge older or rural customers and what they charge younger or urban customers in the individual and small group markets. As a result, Maine’s largest insurance provider — Anthem Blue Cross — raised premiums for the majority of its individual policyholders, especially older ones. Small-business premium rates increased, especially in northern and eastern Maine — rate increases of 70 percent, in some cases.
Relatively few policyholders saw a decrease in premiums, averaging 7 percent to 8 percent.
The law permits an insurance company to “close” its individual or small-group book of business at will and issue new plans. Because the plans are “new,” they do not qualify for regulatory protection. Anthem again led the way: It closed its existing programs and offered a new plan called HealthChoice Plus that drastically reduced benefits, cut maternity coverage altogether, increased deductibles and increased cost-sharing compared to the older, defunct plans.
The law imposes a new tax that requires every privately insured person to pay up to $6 per month to establish coverage for high-risk people by a new private, nonprofit corporation whose meetings — where they decide how public tax money will be spent — will not be open to the public. Maine policyholders together will pay a tax of $22 million — and possibly up to $33.5 million — for this high-risk pool, without knowing what or whom constitutes “high risk.”
The law allows insurance companies to raise rates by up to 10 percent without regulatory review, as long as 80 percent of its premiums are used to pay claims.
Previously, an insurer had to go before Maine’s Bureau of Insurance, a process open to the public, and request a rate increase. Anthem was able to raise rates this year (3 percent was considered “reasonable”), adding $1.8 million in new revenue to the $11 million Anthem received from the “high risk” tax.
Early evidence suggests giving insurance companies free rein to set their own rates without oversight hasn’t been a good deal for Maine policyholders.
The state Bureau of Insurance says that, in the year since the law took effect, 11.4 percent of small groups renewing their policies have seen premium decreases, compared to 3.5 percent that saw decreases in the prior year.
The small groups seeing lower insurance rates are more likely to be in southern Maine, where as there was generally little geographic variation in rate changes before the law.
When small groups were quoted higher rates to renew their policies, the rate increases were slightly more likely to fall in the 40 percent to 80 percent range after the law took effect than they were before. Rate increases between 0 and 20 percent were slightly more common before the law took effect last year.
Small groups quoted rate increases of 40 percent or more were more likely to be in northern and eastern Maine.
And that may be why the new Legislature is already talking about altering the law.
During the campaign, in a closely contested race for Senate District 20, a voter asked then- Rep. Les Fossel, R-Alna, whether he still supported the law for which he had voted.
Kelsy Hartley, president of Hartley Marine Services, told Fossel her rates increased 23 percent under the new law, making things difficult for her business, which runs three tugs out of Boothbay.
He refused to answer because she had called it “the rate hike increase.”
Fossel went on to lose his race. The victor, Democratic incumbent Chris Johnson, has been an outspoken opponent of the law.
He’s not the only Democrat opposed to the deregulation of insurance companies in Maine.
Rep. Sharon Treat, D-Hallowell, submitted legislation even before the election to rescind or revamp the law.
However, the Democratic majority has been promised a veto from Gov. Paul LePage, if they manage to pass a bill. So the only way is to work with Republicans whose own constituents are telling them how the law has hurt them and their small businesses.
Many of these businesses are in Republican strongholds in northern Maine, and there is no shortage of them.
As a result, Republicans, even in reasonably safe seats, are nervously rethinking their support.
Supporters of the bill like Sen. Rodney Whittemore, R-Skowhegan, and Rep. Kenneth Fredette, R-Newport, the newly elected House Republican leader, say they’re open to working with Democrats on improving the bill.
“If things aren’t working, then we need to look at those things,” Fredette said. “We certainly are willing to work across the aisle to see what can be improved.”
Ironically, the law may have provided an unexpected boost for Dirigo Choice, a public-private option that provides health insurance for individuals and small businesses.
Not subject to the new law, Dirigo has kept its rates fairly low and provides state-sponsored premium support for individuals and families making less than 400 percent of the federal poverty limit. Many small businesses are deserting the commercial market for Dirigo Choice, which is swelling its ranks for both individuals and small-business customers.
GINA HAMILTON, of Bath, is editor of the New Maine Times. She welcomes emails at editor@newmainetimes.org.
Comments are not available on this story. Read more about why we allow commenting on some stories and not on others.
We believe it's important to offer commenting on certain stories as a benefit to our readers. At its best, our comments sections can be a productive platform for readers to engage with our journalism, offer thoughts on coverage and issues, and drive conversation in a respectful, solutions-based way. It's a form of open discourse that can be useful to our community, public officials, journalists and others.
We do not enable comments on everything — exceptions include most crime stories, and coverage involving personal tragedy or sensitive issues that invite personal attacks instead of thoughtful discussion.
You can read more here about our commenting policy and terms of use. More information is also found on our FAQs.
Show less