
When considering “unreasonable adverse effects” of the project, we urge the board to take seriously the independent allhazards risk assessment from Good Harbor Techmart, presented in February and commissioned by the nonprofit Islesboro Islands Trust.
The report cites three overarching and compelling issues: the site is too small, the community too close, and the region unprepared to respond adequately if a major problem occurs.
Propane gas is highly flammable, and prevailing winds could direct it toward an ignition source anywhere. As a marine toxicologist who witnessed firsthand the environmental tragedy in the Gulf of Mexico when BP’s Deepwater Horizon oil rig exploded, I can speak to the hazards involved in siting such a large gas liquid propane gas operation in close proximity to communities.
Accidents do happen. The 2010 Gulf catastrophe was certainly never anticipated and, despite DCP’s assurances to the contrary, the likelihood of an accident at the Searsport site cannot be dismissed.
This would be one of the largest LPG facilities in the world, and the largest on the East Coast — a 14-story, 22.7-million gallon megatank with a 75- foot tower and a deepwater pier and unloading facility occupying 43 acres, surrounded by other businesses and residences, some of which are as close as 500 feet, significantly inside the the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency’s half-mile blast zone limit.
The U.S. Coast Guard predicts a two-mile vapor cloud and thermal hazard zone in the event of an explosion.
The Good Harbor analysis points to the unrealistic assumptions that have been made concerning the local capacity to manage an accident. Because there is no cost-sharing plan in place, risk mitigation expenses would shift disproportionately to the municipality, the state and the federal agencies — i.e., the taxpayer.
Worse, the Searsport Volunteer Fire Department, police and EMS are woefully underequipped for an LPG disaster response, and there is no emergency plan in place for regionwide first-responder collaboration or assistance.
As an environmental organization, we also have serious concerns about threats to the marine and terrestrial environment. Searsport Harbor is not deep enough for the deepdraught LPG tankers, and would require expensive and environmentally destructive dredging.
The Army Corps of Engineers did not conduct a full environmental impact review for this, as mandated by the National Environmental Policy Act, even though the proposed LPG terminal is of the same scale as LNG terminals for which this is normally required.
According to the DCP application, the facility would release 108 tons of industrial pollutants annually into air that is often heavy and moist from fog and keeps airborne pollutants close to the ground, thus contaminating humans and wildlife.
Long Cove, adjacent to the site, will likely become contaminated by seeping surface and ground waters containing chemicals, diesel fuel and hydraulic fluids. As recently as 2010, DCP has violated the Clean Air Act by issuing “extremely hazardous substances” at their plants in Texas and New Mexico.
Changing market economics now means that the United States no longer needs to import propane. Terminals throughout the country are converting from import to export facilities. This raises serious questions about the future of the Searsport terminal and the possibility that the owners would want to convert it for exporting gas. This would create security issues, an even greater risk profile, and exponentially more pollution from propane traffic on roads, rails and in Penobscot Bay.
One hundred temporary construction jobs and eight to 10 permanent positions do not justify such overwhelming risks to human health and the environment. We urge the Searsport board to reject the project on the grounds that the hazards far outweigh any potential benefits.
DR. SUSAN SHAW, president and founder of the Marine Environmental Research Institute in Blue Hill, is a professor of public health at the State University of New York.
Comments are not available on this story. Read more about why we allow commenting on some stories and not on others.
We believe it's important to offer commenting on certain stories as a benefit to our readers. At its best, our comments sections can be a productive platform for readers to engage with our journalism, offer thoughts on coverage and issues, and drive conversation in a respectful, solutions-based way. It's a form of open discourse that can be useful to our community, public officials, journalists and others.
We do not enable comments on everything — exceptions include most crime stories, and coverage involving personal tragedy or sensitive issues that invite personal attacks instead of thoughtful discussion.
You can read more here about our commenting policy and terms of use. More information is also found on our FAQs.
Show less