
Natural disasters will occur even when unaided by global warming, but climate change is unquestionably a game changer.
Certainly, our coastline will continue to be threatened by such, and Popham Beach, whatever its future, will not be excluded. Its current plight, however, is arguably a more local issue, though also about interference with nature.
Popham’s erosion continues to rage exponentially. Each visit presents a radically rearranged coastline. On more and more days, there is essentially no beach whatsoever at high tide. Even at low tide, there is no dry sand upon which to recreate.
The park infrastructure remains precarious. Summer residences to the east — some recently provided obscene barriers — are in eminent danger, and the road to Fort Popham may soon be threatened in several places. At the Kennebec’s mouth, barrier surf extends all the way out to Sequin Light, diagonal to the shore. These are catastrophic changes that might well have been avoided by intervening several years ago to address displacement of the Morse River.
Popham Beach’s endangerment presents itself as a “perfect storm” of interrelated phenomena, yet currently the symptoms of dramatic erosion are being addressed ad hoc, while the causal events rapidly distant themselves in memory and attention.
Beaches change, rivers wander.
Agreed, but those changes have causes, some natural and unavoidable, others not. The redirection of the Morse River occurred after a single major storm, but why that particular storm? Were there no other contributing factors?
Bath Iron Works’ Land Level Transfer Facility construction, impinging the natural course of the Kennebec River; and its annual deep dredging, to allow sinking of the drydock and downriver access to the sea for its products, may well be a contributing factor to Popham’s problem. This was the theory of BIW’s own environmental consultant, who took an adversarial position to the project’s implementation after coming to that assessment.
He warned that changed river dynamics and redistribution of silting might eventually have an impact on beaches at the Kennebec’s outlet, that only time would tell.
That projection was made 15 years ago, so I am unsure of the particulars and may be way off the mark in raising this issue. But, perhaps not.
If memory serves, I came upon his challenge to the project in the Department of Environmental Protection’s site permitting documentation while I was pursuing avenues for mitigation of noise and visual impacts. His objections, apparently, were not sufficiently compelling to whomever he petitioned. He might well have been incorrect in his opinion, just plain wrong, but over the years, it has remained a troubling assertion as environmental impacts have slowly gained momentum.
Determining whether his assertion has merit would need investigation by someone more capable than myself, and independent of political or bureaucratic pressures. I will note that the Board of Environmental Protection at the time was overtly pro project.
The definition of “beach” usually describes that shoreline above the high-tide mark. As volatile as the changes to Popham continue to be, a true beach may well return by summer.
Or not. Beaches change, but rarely so violently, quickly and unpredictably, threatening to vanish altogether while remaining in constant flux.
This ongoing chain of events, eradicating 50 to 70 years of dune development, started with the blockage of the Morse River’s direct outlet to the sea, and continued to worsen as state agencies sat by and awaited a natural solution.
Engineering a re-establishment of Morse River’s historical outlet was not done, supposedly because nature was not to be interfered with; that was the state’s position. Since then, they have interfered, performing half measures to correct the situation. Soon, they may need to barricade the entirety of what was perhaps the most beautiful beach in Maine.
The state’s approval of BIW’s expansion into the Kennebec, whatever its impact in this situation, was an environmental crap shoot. It was deemed worth the risk, as is BIW’s ongoing dredging with its impact on fisheries, both commercial and recreational.
The dumping of its dredging spoils nearby, rather than further away off Portland, may explain the Morse River’s diversion. In all of this, money seems to have been the greater consideration.
Why isn’t the state willing to gamble, or invest, to save this irreplaceable beach? They will intervene to save the park’s restrooms, but not to protect the natural aesthetics that invite patronage.
Why is this tragedy not being more scrutinized, especially as an indictment of possible bureaucratic malfeasance or governmental indifference? Certainly, reasonable questions should be asked about what I fear may be the unintended outcome of economic gain sought by a well intended government-business alliance.
If it is, shouldn’t we know that?
Reactions I have gotten in contacting various agencies indicated that these questions, particularly regarding BIW, were definitely anticipated and prepared for as to defuse pursuit. Then again, my sense of stonewalling by the state may well be a misreading of an understandably defensive posture.
I am not an investigative reporter or scientist. I am simply struggling to comprehend a baffling lack of real urgency on the part of those in control.
I hope this commentary will prompt similar outrage as to why this tragedy was allowed to occur. Popham’s stewards have done poorly. BIW, involved or not, was allowed environmental carte blanche. Private landowners are permitted to employ desperate ad hoc interventions that likely exacerbate the problem. For the state to employ “environmentalism” as a scapegoat for inaction, given what has been lost environmentally, is beyond irony.
GARY ANDERSON, of Bath, has visited Popham Beach, in all seasons, since 1976.
Comments are not available on this story. Read more about why we allow commenting on some stories and not on others.
We believe it's important to offer commenting on certain stories as a benefit to our readers. At its best, our comments sections can be a productive platform for readers to engage with our journalism, offer thoughts on coverage and issues, and drive conversation in a respectful, solutions-based way. It's a form of open discourse that can be useful to our community, public officials, journalists and others.
We do not enable comments on everything — exceptions include most crime stories, and coverage involving personal tragedy or sensitive issues that invite personal attacks instead of thoughtful discussion.
You can read more here about our commenting policy and terms of use. More information is also found on our FAQs.
Show less