3 min read

Andrew Ian Dodge
Andrew Ian Dodge
As the dust and the results are contemplated, rejected and examined from last week’s local elections in the United Kingdom, one thing strikes me plainly: With four national parties in today’s British political system, voters there have so much more choice than we do.

Pity the poor libertarianminded American conservative or center-left minded U.S. voter, not to mention small-government social conservatives and their activists. None of these types has anyone to vote for in U.S. elections.

Granted, there are exceptions to this rule, in states such as New York with their Conservative Party; and in Maine and Vermont, with their penchants for independents. Yes, there is a Libertarian Party and Constitution Party, but neither has made much of an impact nationally, nor have they had elected anyone to Congress.

It might require a couple of brand-new parties, with no historical baggage, to make an impact.

In most of the United States, the choice is pretty stark: It is between the socialist/social democratic corporatist Democrats and the theocratic corporatism of Republicans.

Advertisement

Both parties are patronizing and patrician in their outlooks. Neither is for small government in any practical manner, and both limit individual rights when they are in power. No matter who has hold of the ratchet, the bolt that limits our rights is always tighter, never any looser.

In the U.K., you currently have a choice between Labour socialists, the squishy center-left Liberal Democrats, the squishy Conservative center-right and the conservative/libertarian UKIP.

There is actually choice among these parties. There are actual practical differences in policy and political ambition. These parties keep each other on their toes and force each other to avoid taking their core votes for granted.

This doesn’t happen in the United States, and you will hear the Republican and Democrat loyalists every election cycle, saying, “Well, who else are you going to vote for?”

This situation means that neither party needs to reform at all — they just mess around in the middle and ignore any ideas outside their worldview. Look at what happened to those who dared challenge the establishment choice of Mitt Romney prior to and during last year’s Republican National Convention.

Was there really much difference in outlook between Obama and McCain, or Obama and Romney? The rhetoric is varied, but other than that there isn’t much practical difference.

Advertisement

One peddles “Christian morality” dictated by government; the other pushes a “secular consensus” that they use as an excuse to limit choice and freedoms.

The tea party and Occupy movements spoke to those concerns for a few years, only to be infiltrated, corrupted, warped and ruined as independent political entities.

The only groupings that would be able to resist the full onslaught of partisan operatives would be whole new political parties. Some of the Founding Fathers might have been against political parties, but I hardly think they will be a thing of the past anytime soon.

The United States needs parties such as UKIP and the Liberal Democrats that keep the two “major” ones worried that voters and activists might desert them. It needs parties ready to take up the slack if Republicans and Democrats start going wobbly. Parties need the pain and worry of other viable parties threatening their dominance at every turn. In short, the Republicans and Democrats need parties that remind them that no party is immortal and can be replaced, like the Whigs of yore.

The American Republic needs to offer choice to its citizens when it comes to election time. This might help turnout and the perception, somewhat accurate of late, that “both parties are the same.”

Americans, no matter what the mainstream media and our betters try to tell us, are not in the mushy middle. They have strong feelings on matters, and politics needs to reflect that. We need Americans more involved in their governance, not less. Several more national political parties might shake things up just enough to get them interested.

ANDREW IAN DODGE is a libertarian former U.S. Senate candidate and writer who lives in Harpswell.


Comments are not available on this story. Read more about why we allow commenting on some stories and not on others.