BATH
Unhappy with the procedure and sale price of the building housing Midcoast Center for Higher Education, residents unloaded Wednesday night on the City Council, one of them going so far as to say that the buyer had a certain amount of control over the process.
Larry Scott, Michael Wischkaemper, John Armentrout and former Councilor Kyle Rogers all spoke at length regarding the sale, at times receiving applause from likeminded residents in the packed council chambers.
Not everyone was critical of the sale, however, as former Councilor Ed Rogers said he saw “no wrongdoing.”
A closing on the sale of the Park Street building to Robert Smith for $799,000 — approved by the City Council in executive session April 1 — went through last Friday.
Wischkaemper — a private citizen misidentified in an article published last Friday in The Times Record as Scott’s lawyer — said he is finally beginning to receive information that Scott — who was interested in the property — had sought for weeks.
Wischkaemper said the “secret” sale of a building assessed at $6.5 million violates the principal of getting the best possible price.
He went on to say that a building with 85,000 useable square feet was leased at $12 per square foot, yet sold for less than $9.40 per square foot.
“It’s less expensive to buy the property than to lease the property for a year,” Wischkaemper said.
He went on to say that tenants of the property weren’t aware the property was up for sale until it actually was sold.
“The process must be open to listen and hear opinions,” said Wischkaemper, a retired lawyer. “City government doesn’t belong to the city manager or its council. This was a major public decision in which the sale was made in secret.”
He added, to applause, that a “major property tax increase” up for consideration could have been eliminated had the city sold the building for a higher price.
Following remarks by Councilor David Sinclair — who urged the council to delay a decision on the sale — and others, City Manager William Giroux pointed out the Providence Corp., a principal paying tenant, had announced earlier this year it was leaving the building, and the property was offered to another tenant. Midcoast Center for Higher Education is not a paying tenant, he said.
“Keep in mind,” Giroux said, “we lost money for nine of the 11 years that we owned that property. We were concerned that a tenant was leaving. We were afraid that it was going to be on the market for a long time. It wasn’t. In hindsight, I wish it would have been. Then we wouldn’t have this problem.”
Rogers vouched for the council’s decision.
“I think all the letters in the paper came from people who have a personal agenda,” he said.
Scott presented the council with a letter containing a litany of complaints. Among them:
— The city charter required that the sale of city real estate be by solicitation of public bids.
— There were no minutes of the pending sale.
— What was the method of developing the price and valuation?
What was the formula that brought the price to 12.3 percent of its assessed value?
— Did any member of the city manager’s office or City Council have a prior relationship with the buyer?
— Did the Realtor disclose the fact that their office represented both buyer and seller?
Scott told councilors that his many questions to city officials were never answered.
“I don’t understand why you feel I’m not entitled to any answers,” he said. “It’s un-American to do all of this in closed session. Why no answers, and now I’m told, ‘Gee, it’s too late’?”
Councilor Meadow Rue Merrill acknowledged later that things could have been done differently, but she objected to the word “secret.”
Rogers was quick to respond, asking Merrill when she knew of the sale.
“What I’m saying is that nothing was done in secret,” Merrill answered.
Scott responded, “If you don’t know it, it is by definition ‘secret.’”
Armentrout pressed councilors as to how they reached their decision to sell.
“I think everyone has dropped the ball on this,” Armentrout said. “Our taxes are going up 5 percent.”
Assessor Paul Mateosian said that, because the building is tax-exempt property, the assessed value “has no purpose.”
Councilor Mari Eosco noted that the building had made a profit last year, so it was a perfect time to “get rid of it.”
“It’s an aging building that needs work,” Eosco said. “I was shocked to hear that somebody was interested in that building. It’s hurtful for people to accuse us when we thought we were doing the best thing for our constituents.”
lgrard@timesrecord.com
Comments are not available on this story. Read more about why we allow commenting on some stories and not on others.
We believe it's important to offer commenting on certain stories as a benefit to our readers. At its best, our comments sections can be a productive platform for readers to engage with our journalism, offer thoughts on coverage and issues, and drive conversation in a respectful, solutions-based way. It's a form of open discourse that can be useful to our community, public officials, journalists and others.
We do not enable comments on everything — exceptions include most crime stories, and coverage involving personal tragedy or sensitive issues that invite personal attacks instead of thoughtful discussion.
You can read more here about our commenting policy and terms of use. More information is also found on our FAQs.
Show less