
As Greens, we support energy-saving, sustainable and environmentally friendly passenger rail transportation. We appreciate that a layover facility is a necessary component of an efficient and economically viable passenger train system. However, the proposed site, adjacent to Bouchard Drive, is poorly conceived and does not meet any reasonable criteria for protecting the environment, or for considering the health or the quality of life of the people in that neighborhood.
The Green Party adopted 10 Key Values at the time of its founding in 1984-85.
Three of these values speak to the inherent conflict in the building of a layover facility in the Brunswick West neighborhood:
— Grassroots Democracy. “Every human being deserves a say in the decisions that affect their lives and not be subject to the will of another. Therefore we will work to increase public participation at every level of government and to ensure that our public representatives are fully accountable to the people who elect them.”
The Brunswick West Neighborhood Coalition has been denied access to information and the right to participate in a process that should be associated with a facility of this size.
NNEPRA and the town would have Brunswick citizens believe that they have included neighbors in the process by holding “public hearings” and making public presentations of site studies, commissioned by NNEPRA, to demonstrate why the Brunswick West site is preferable to two nearby sites that are more appropriate to industrial use.
The Brunswick West site defies local zoning codes, with NNEPRA claiming federal preemption of state and local laws. Requests by BWNC for critical documents have been denied, their concerns minimized or dismissed.
The fact-finding done by the Brunswick West Neighborhood Coalition is truly remarkable and exemplary. We admire their courage and steadfastness. Their position has been presented in various venues including The Times Record, the Town Council and the Brunswick West Neighborhood Coalition website, www.savebrunswickwest.com.
Why has not the people’s voice been heard? Why has the town of Brunswick supported the fairytale that the facility will be the answer to everyone’s concerns?
— Ecological wisdom. “Human societies must operate with the understanding that we are part of nature, not separate from nature….. We support a sustainable society which utilizes resources in such a way that future generations will benefit and not suffer from the practices of our generation.”
The facility is not the answer to the pollution and noise currently generated by idling diesel engines that emit toxic exhaust in Brunswick. These older diesel engines, used by Amtrak for the Downeaster, spew diesel exhaust, a known carcinogen, five or more hours a day.
The facility will not eliminate the problem. Exhaust from the engines will be ventilated out of the building into the neighborhood. Noise and vibrations from the trains as they move in and out of the facility will disrupt a quiet neighborhood.
Town officials refer to a “rail yard” between Church Road and Stanwood Street, leading one to believe that the West Brunswick neighborhood is the logical place for the facility. In fact, tracks for the former rail yard were removed in 1988. They had not been in use for many years as passenger train service diminished and ended in 1961. The area was zoned “residential” in the early 1970s when plans for the existing Bouchard neighborhood were approved.
Coal ash and other contaminants from train activity and maintenance in the former rail yard pose a significant hazard. An in-depth Environmental Protection Agency assessment addressing soil contamination, ground water, noise, vibration, air pollution and social-economic impacts needs to be completed and the findings shared with the people of Brunswick.
— Future focus and sustainability. “Our actions and policies must be motivated by long term goals……We must counterbalance the drive for short-term profits by assuring that economic development, new technologies, and fiscal policies are responsible to future generations who will inherit the results of our actions.”
The facility will generate no new tax revenue for the town of Brunswick. The impact in the neighborhood will be to decrease property values and reduce property tax revenues. The “quality of place” that currently exists will be lost.
NNEPRA appears to have chosen the West Brunswick site because it is the least expensive, thinking only about their operating costs and not about the environment or the people.
This is a difficult situation. How to encourage rail transportation without sacrificing health and community?
Merrymeeting Greens support a thorough and transparent look by NNEPRA, Town Council and the community, participating together, at all other choices for the site of this layover facility.
We believe in compromise, but not at the expense of environmental health or denying people’s right to participate in how their community is constituted.
MARY HEATH, of Brunswick, is a member of the Maine Green Independent Party.
Comments are not available on this story. Read more about why we allow commenting on some stories and not on others.
We believe it's important to offer commenting on certain stories as a benefit to our readers. At its best, our comments sections can be a productive platform for readers to engage with our journalism, offer thoughts on coverage and issues, and drive conversation in a respectful, solutions-based way. It's a form of open discourse that can be useful to our community, public officials, journalists and others.
We do not enable comments on everything — exceptions include most crime stories, and coverage involving personal tragedy or sensitive issues that invite personal attacks instead of thoughtful discussion.
You can read more here about our commenting policy and terms of use. More information is also found on our FAQs.
Show less