Activists assembled at the State House on Tuesday to kick off an eight-state tour in support of single-payer health care reform.
In Maine, LD 1345, sponsored by Rep. Charles Priest, D-Brunswick, would transition the state slowly toward a state-run insurance system similar to those established in Canada and much of Europe.
Priest has introduced similar bills in previous legislatures. This time, he said he took his cues from Vermont — which in 2011 approved a law to slowly establish a singlepayer system.
He said single-payer — which proponents say would drastically reduce the cost of health care by eliminating the private profit motivation and overhead costs associated with tracking the myriad insurance payments — was established piecemeal in Canada, and should be approached the same way in the United States.
“It’s going to happen state by state by state until there’s enough momentum for Congress to act,” he told a small group of supporters at the State House Welcome Center.
Proponents of Priest’s bill — it has 51 co-sponsors in the House — will surely be watching as Vermont attempts to implement its law by bringing companies that operate their own insurance plans into a single-payer system.
The U.S. Employee Retirement Income Security Act, or ERISA, says companies operating their own plans are exempt from state health care laws. Vermont needs a waiver to make those companies opt in to the single-payer system. No state has ever obtained an ERISA waiver before.
The outcome of that process will provide crucial precedent for Maine’s singlepayer efforts, said Trish Riley, a senior fellow for health policy at the Muskie School.
“The biggest difference between Vermont and Maine is we have far more businesses that are self-insured,” Riley said. There’s also the question of whether a “single” payer could ever be established, she said.
“If you try to do single payer (in Maine), the question is whether Medicare will play along, because we’re the oldest state. And what do you do about self-insurers if you can’t get a waiver?” she said.
It’s feasible that even under a single-payer plan — where private health insurance companies were kicked out of the system — health care providers still could end up dealing with multiple state and federal agencies, plus the large companies that operate under ERISA, such as Bath Iron Works, the University of Maine and the Maine State Employees Union.
Rep. Richard Malaby, RHancock, who sits on the Health and Human Services Committee, said he opposes Priest’s plan.
“Single-payer has a lot of allure in that it could minimize overhead costs, which is good, but it does not address a key component of the health care system, which is that we need more competition,” he said.
Malaby said that even though there are more than 1,000 health insurance companies in the country, only a handful operate in Maine’s small group market. Easing regulations, he said, would make Maine’s market more attractive and drive prices down.
He also said that while it’s true that Europeans operating under a single-payer system pay dramatically less for health care than Americans, that’s not necessarily a function of their payment scheme.
“I think it’s a lot to do with technology and lifestyle choices. They also make rationing choices in those countries that we are not willing to make. We spend a lot of money on end-of-life services, for example,” he said.
Malaby and other Republicans also responded to Tuesday’s event at the State House by touting Public Law 90, a GOP-supported insurance reform package approved during the Republican-controlled 125th Legislature. The law decreased regulation on insurance companies by making it easier for them to offer new plans and by allowing small businesses to band together and negotiate more favorable rates.
The bill also created a highrisk pool — or reinsurance program — to protect insurance companies from the high costs of covering patients who require the most medical care. In addition, the law allowed insurers to charge different rates based on patients’ age, place of residence and health status. Proponents have said that part of the bill is an attempt to woo more young, healthy patients into the marketplace by allowing insurers to charge them less.
Democrats and lawmakers from northern Maine have criticized PL 90 for allowing rate hikes on older and rural customers. Republicans have countered by pointing out that more Mainers have seen rate decreases since PL 90 was enacted.
Malaby said that the geographic fluctuations were rough in the first year since PL 90 but that they are leveling off and that the Republican reform bill has been a success.
“You’re getting more and more young people who can stay in Maine and afford insurance,” he said. “It used to be we never saw rate decreases at all, and now we are.”
Regardless of the political battles over PL 90 or a singlepayer bill — which Gov. Paul LePage opposes — Priest said there’s always a Plan B.
“If we can’t get it through the Legislature, which is a possibility, Maine has a wonderful citizen referendum system,” he said.
FOR MORE, see the Bangor Daily News at bangordailynews.com.

Comments are not available on this story. Read more about why we allow commenting on some stories and not on others.
We believe it's important to offer commenting on certain stories as a benefit to our readers. At its best, our comments sections can be a productive platform for readers to engage with our journalism, offer thoughts on coverage and issues, and drive conversation in a respectful, solutions-based way. It's a form of open discourse that can be useful to our community, public officials, journalists and others.
We do not enable comments on everything — exceptions include most crime stories, and coverage involving personal tragedy or sensitive issues that invite personal attacks instead of thoughtful discussion.
You can read more here about our commenting policy and terms of use. More information is also found on our FAQs.
Show less