3 min read

WILLIAM PLUMMER pauses after taking a call Monday afternoon from someone seeking more details on the shooting of Leon Kelley. Plummer, a selectman, was at his favorite spot alongside the lunch counter in the Georgetown Country Store. “We don’t really know,” Plummer had answered the caller. “He was shot dead in the yard yesterday afternoon. He was shot three times.”
WILLIAM PLUMMER pauses after taking a call Monday afternoon from someone seeking more details on the shooting of Leon Kelley. Plummer, a selectman, was at his favorite spot alongside the lunch counter in the Georgetown Country Store. “We don’t really know,” Plummer had answered the caller. “He was shot dead in the yard yesterday afternoon. He was shot three times.”
GEORGETOWN

Just about everyone in this fishing community knew Leon Kelley. He was one of their own — a lobsterman.

That’s what made it much harder for everyone to figure out Monday as they gathered at the Georgetown Country Store lunch counter. Normally, Kelley would have been there, too.

But that will never happen again.

Kelley, 63, was fatally shot three times in the torso by Merrill Kimball a day earlier in Yarmouth, where he was minding the Brown’s Bee Farm store for his father-in-law, 93-year-old Stan Brown.

Advertisement

“He’d probably be ordering a pizza right now,” William Plummer said. “We’re a close-knit community. This is a terrible thing.”

Police did not arrest Kimball, saying he has been cooperative and they are still trying to determine what prompted the shooting and the extent of the confrontation that preceded it.

“There is no threat to the public, number one, and, number two, we need to understand the circumstances under which this shooting occurred,” state police spokesman Steve McCausland said Monday. “Kimball has been cooperative with investigators,” he said. “We have talked to him and we probably will talk to him again.”

Plummer, a selectman, said he has known Kelley since both were children growing up in the Five Islands neighborhood.

After graduation from Morse High School, Plummer said, Kelley served in Vietnam. He owned and drove his own trucking rig, then settled back in town about 20 years ago as a lobsterman, Plummer said.

“He was big and jovial,” Plummer said. “He liked to laugh — he was funny. This will be tough on his kids, and his grandchildren.”

Advertisement

Plummer and store owner Dolores Pinette, both members of the Board of Selectmen, later gathered with others on the front porch of the store.

“It’s a tragedy, a travesty — all of that,” Plummer said. “You had no reason to believe something like this would happen.”

Rosemary Hentz, the Georgetown ambulance chief, said from her home that she knew the Kelley family well.

“He was a good father,” Hentz said, “and he was a good grandfather. They’re really nice, nice people, and they’re hard-working kids.”

Renee Rogers of Bath cut Kelley’s hair for more than a decade. She heard many a story regarding his grandfather — father and son going out on their lobster boats.

“There wasn’t a more good-hearted human being who walked this earth,” Rogers said. “I am so shocked. It’s going to leave a huge hole.”

Advertisement

Kelley also was a regular at Five Islands Lobster Co., near where he grew up. The Five Islands Lobster website had a simple, sincere message on Monday: “You will be sorely missed Leon. A sad, sad day.”

lgrard@timesrecord.com


Comments are not available on this story. Read more about why we allow commenting on some stories and not on others.