2 min read

Imagine if the income of a mom-and-pop store in Maine was taxed at a much higher rate than the profits made by a global giant like Walmart. That wouldn’t seem fair or even make sense.

Question 1, a November state ballot proposal to offer free “homecare for all” to people 65 or older, would send taxes soaring — an extra 3.8-percent on family gross income over the Social Security tax threshold ($128,400 in 2018).

Even a married couple, each person making only $70,000 a year, would be impacted by higher taxes if Question 1 passes because their gross income on the joint return is above the $128,400 income level. Savings meant for their family needs would instead go to provide free homecare for other people.

Self-employed people could also face the whopping 3.8-percent extra income tax.

Not a single New England state imposes an income tax nearly as high as 11 percent, which is the combined rate Question 1 would bring to Maine. Connecticut’s top rate is 7 percent; Massachusetts, 5.1 percent; Rhode Island, 6 percent; Vermont, 9 percent; and, there is no income tax in New Hampshire.

Question 1 also imposes a 1.9- percent payroll tax on good-paying jobs provided by many small employers and others. No other state in the nation imposes such a penalty on companies for creating good jobs.

Advertisement

A survey of NFIB members in Maine found about 90 percent of the small-business owners oppose Question 1.

A recent analysis by the state economist finds that if Question 1 passes, over the next five years, the labor force would decline by about 1,500 compared to current projections; personal income would drop by $2 billion; Maine’s economic growth would decline up to $916 million; and, the state population would decline by as much as 2,300.

What Maine desperately needs instead of new or higher taxes is more good jobs, more entrepreneurs, and more young families willing to settle here. Taxing small business, discouraging job creation, and penalizing working families is not the way to create prosperous communities.

Whatever the benefits of increasing home care services, the massive price tag and economic penalties of Question 1 warrant a “No” vote in November.

David Clough is the state director for National Federation of Independent Business in Maine.

Comments are not available on this story. Read more about why we allow commenting on some stories and not on others.