4 min read

“Gone: The Mystery of The Don Disaster,” as seen on public broadcasting in 2011, explores the strange disappearance in 1941 of the pleasure craft The Don with 34 people on board. The boat was never found and only 14 bodies were ever recovered. For more than 78 years, the sea off the rocky coast of Maine has held its secrets about this terrible loss of life.

Thirty-four doomed people boarded The Don on that beautiful June morning with only lobster and fun on their minds. Little did these passengers know that their notorious rum-runner captain was about to transport them on a fatal journey.

A group of friends from the small towns of Rumford and Mexico had chartered The Don for a picnic on Monhegan Island, a three-hour boat ride from the Harpswell departure site. The Don had a reputation as an unstable craft, but unfortunately the people who booked the trip lived 60 miles inland and had never heard the rumors. They put their misplaced trust in Capt. Paul Johnson, who was ultimately responsible for ending all their lives that day.

The day became overcast as the picnickers were rowed out to The Don. The boat was too large to pull up to the dock in low tide that morning, so the time-consuming process of transporting almost three dozen passengers in small skiffs delayed the departure. By the time the shuttling was complete, 34 people were closely packed on the 44-foot, not terribly sea-worthy Don.

The boat set off down Quahog Bay through choppy waters. A quick stop was made at a store in West Point where Johnson purchased potatoes and other supplies for a chowder he planned on making to accompany the two lobsters that had been assigned each party-goer. Passengers bought postcards and the store keeper later testified to the playful and polite nature of the group.

As the vessel headed out into the waters of Casco Bay, it was sighted by lobsterman Paul Eastman, who later testified to seeing 10-12 passengers sitting on the upper deck of the boat, which looked overloaded and top-heavy. The Don was next sighted by Second Assistant Lighthouse Keeper Maxwell Deshon on Seguin Island. From his high vantage point, he logged the sighting, which would be the last official look anyone had of The Don.

Advertisement

By late that night, friends and relatives of the passengers on The Don began to worry when there was no word from anyone who had been on board. By early the next morning, authorities were poised to begin searching for the boat, but a thick fog had set in, hampering the search efforts.

Two days later when the fog lifted, bodies had already begun to be found floating in the Bay and were washing up on Harpswell shores. More than 100 boats and hundreds of people were enlisted in the gruesome search for the drowned passengers. The last of the 14 recovered bodies was found 15 days after The Don left Harpswell for its Monhegan trip.

Twelve of the bodies found were women and only two were men. This imbalance helped give rise to many theories about what might have happened to the ill-fated boat. Johnson’s body was one of those found; he was inexplicably tied to a small wooden keg by 20 feet of rope, dressed only in his undershorts. Did he tie himself to the keg and dive in to save the passengers? No one will ever know.

Since The Don was never found, there was no evidence to help determine the cause of the accident. Theories ranged from fire and explosions to hitting a ledge and breaking up. The official investigations conducted eventually declared The Don had capsized due to its instability. The coroner declared accidental drowning as the cause of death for all victims found.

Despite the passage of time, many parts of the boat could possibly still exist, including the galvanized iron engine, anchor and stove, and the bronze skeg, rudder and steering station. But none of these were found despite extensive searches and dredging of both Casco and Sheepscot bays, where the boat had been sighted. No one lived to tell their tale, nor have any relatives or descendants of the passengers been able to help with information in the subsequent years.

An adventurous team of filmmakers explored the mystery and, in the process, was able to add a new chapter to this maritime disaster’s story. “Gone: The Mystery of The Don Disaster” is a one-hour documentary shot in high definition at the original Maine locations.

Advertisement

Re-enactments bring to life that fatal day and provide a personal look at the 34 people lost five months before the attack on Pearl Harbor. The forgotten story is a compelling reminder of life’s unpredictability.

Emotional interviews with relatives show how poignantly the tragedy was felt and how deep the feeling of loss still remains. An eyewitness describes the grisly recovery of bodies; a Rumford/Mexico native sadly recalls the horror of the staggering number of drownings, including several close friends.

The film reconstructs the sequence of events based on sworn testimony. Various theories are investigated and possible sites of the tragedy are explored. This new analysis hopes to uncover the long-sought answer to why the remains of The Don were never found.

The Don disaster was perhaps responsible for eventual maritime laws being changed to improve both passenger and boating safety. The film puts a personal face on the price that paid for these changes.

As a result of this documentary film, interest in The Don disaster was renewed and a memorial was finally created to honor the 34 people who died in this boating mystery. In 2006, Stacy L. Welner wrote a book about this tragedy called “Tragedy in Casco Bay.” The event remains one of the worst boating disasters in New England history.

LC Van Savage is a Coastal Journal contributor. She can be reached at lcvs@comcast.net. 

Comments are not available on this story. Read more about why we allow commenting on some stories and not on others.