4 min read

A crane on a barge removes pilings from the water in Popham. (Nathan Strout / The Times Record)

PHIPPSBURG – The Popham pilings are no more.

On Tuesday, Phippsburg residents spotted a crane on a barge methodically plucking out the dilapidated pilings, the only remains of a long-abandoned pier used by the Eastern Steamship Lines company decades ago.

The pilings’ fate was sealed over a year ago, when Maine’s Board of Environmental Protection denied a December 2017 appeal by Phippsburg residents to stop the pilings from being removed. While no one knew the date they’d be removed, it wasn’t a total shock to residents when the moment finally came.

“I just saw all the Reed & Reed vehicles and went down to the beach, and that’s what was happening,” said Barbara Keltonic, one of the residents who fought to stop the pilings from being removed. “We’re all pretty down today.”

Jack and Susan Parker filed applications with the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers and the Maine Department of Environmental Protection to remove the pilings in September 2016. The Parkers, who own a summer home overlooking the beach and the pilings, claimed in their application that the pilings were causing erosion on the beach and that removing the pilings would allow the beach to return to a more natural state. Key to those applications was an engineering study commissioned by the Parkers that found the pilings were causing some erosion.

Advertisement

Jack Parker, president and CEO of Reed & Reed general contractors in Woolwich, said he would be paying for the removal of the pilings out of his own pocket.

The Army Corps of Engineers application was approved quickly, but it would be almost a year before the Parkers got approval from the Department of Environmental Protection.

During that time, some Phippsburg residents pushed to save the pilings, arguing that they liked the aesthetic appeal of the haggard wooden posts, which harkened back to a more active time in Popham when the Eastern Steamship Lines company was still in operation. Concerned residents asked MDEP to stop the project, and worked to undermine the Parkers’ claims about erosion.

When the department gave the Parkers the final approval they needed to remove the pilings, Phippsburg selectmen filed an appeal, listing the town, Ethan Deberry and Rafael and Victoria Villamil, who are next-door neighbors to the Parkers, as the appellants. The appellants argued that the department had overlooked the scenic and historical value of the pilings. They also made a number of procedural arguments based on the lack of a public hearing and who had the property rights to the pilings, among other things.

A crane on a barge removes pilings from the water in Popham. (Nathan Strout / The Times Record)

Ultimately, those arguments fell flat before the Maine Board of Environmental Protection, and the battle between the Parkers and the small but dedicated group of Phippsburg residents and vacationers came to an end in December of 2017, when the board voted 6-1 to deny the appeal. The Parkers were allowed to move forward with their plans to remove the pilings.

However, they didn’t do so right away, leaving some to speculate that the Parkers had abandoned their intentions.

Advertisement

“I personally thought that Mr. Parker would have looked at what I feel is the truth about his arguments that it was gonna cause erosion and be a real safety problem for him that were debunked, and realize that the sentiment of the community was to let them fade away,” said Dot Kelly, one of the outspoken opponents of the piling removal. “I’m disappointed.”

Any hopes from opponents that the pilings would be allowed to stay were dashed Tuesday, when a video on social media showed a Reed & Reed barge and crane removing the pilings from the water.

“An awful lot of people were more optimistic than I, saying ‘I think he’s going to let it pass.’ I didn’t,” said Keltonic.

According to Jack Parker, their permit for removing the pilings only extends from October to mid-April. With most of his company’s equipment committed to other projects in the fall, Parker said that now was the time to get the equipment in place and pull out the pilings.

In a statement provided Wednesday, Parker remained adamant that removing the pilings was the right thing to do.

“By removing the piling, we are protecting the beach,” said Parker. “With a choice between protecting the view or protecting the beach, we believe we made the correct decision.”

On social media, some people went further in expressing frustration over the removal of the pilings, posting personal attacks on the Parkers, profanity or hopes that their Phippsburg property is damaged.

“We understand (that) some people are upset to see the piling go and we respect their views. We do not believe the invective, threats, boorish comments and insults by some on social media platforms are warranted or excusable,” said Parker.

nstrout@timesrecord.com

Comments are not available on this story. Read more about why we allow commenting on some stories and not on others.