1 min read

Rabbi Herzfeld’s Oct. 2 Press Herald op-ed on the Portland City Council’s Israel divestment resolution (“Searching for connection at Rosh Hashanah“) is a perfect example of why the Jewish-Israel equation must end. From its origins, modern Zionism has never been a universally held belief among Jews. Plenty of Jews, myself included, think that we were formed by our 2,000-year diaspora and that a “return” to an Israeli state is not a goal.

Israel has always been based on the settlement of Palestinian land, but in the past year, it has made the extermination or dispossession of Palestinians an overt goal. The creation of an ever-expanding Jewish ethno-state is openly discussed by government ministers. One has to wonder who used to live in the “new town in Israel” that the rabbi now calls home.

If Judaism continues to be the court religion of Israel, it will become a servant to nationalism like Russian Orthodoxy or Wahhabism, subordinating any claims of theology, morality, or spirituality to the political or economic interests of the state.

Zionism has proven to be a dead end for Jews and Gentiles alike. It has been an existential nightmare for Palestinians and hasn’t even lived up to its promise to make Jews safer. The only way forward is a secular state where all can live with equal claims to safety and civil rights. I applaud the council’s actions.

Dan Kolbert
Portland

Comments are not available on this story. Read more about why we allow commenting on some stories and not on others.