3 min read

Criticism of higher education seems to be in vogue these days, and our colleges and universities are not without blame for the current crescendo of negative and legitimate observations about their conduct.

This conclusion, however, should not be conflated with the politically opportunistic rhetoric of some whose agenda is to subvert the mission of higher education and replace its freedom to discover, examine and question with a government-mandated agenda. A brief reflection on some self-inflicted damage and the available, if unwanted, solutions is important in acknowledging the legitimacy of some of the criticism.

Legacy admissions and the outsized influence of money in college admissions has no place in a democracy. They characterize the underpinnings of plutocracies and oligarchies from which our founding citizens fled. Such practices can be ended at once by our colleges without inviting external intervention – but only if the elites and their followers choose to become less elite.

Standardized testing has done nothing to expand greater access to a broader spectrum of students. The elite schools, which again are extolling the virtue of this practice, need look no further than to admit to the pathetically small percentage of incoming students who come from low-income cohorts. These tests, once “sold” as a measurement of aptitude for which preparation was futile, have instead spawned a multibillion-dollar test prep industry supported by wealthy parents. So much for aptitude. Colleges can end this inequality with the strokes of their collective pens.

The inexorable and unaffordable rise in tuition must cease and be replaced with a new operating model. With sticker prices approaching $90,000 a year, elite schools are setting a grotesque precedent with which financial aid can not compete. Debt service to support unnecessarily lavish residence halls, locker rooms, fitness and student centers, food service, all to beat the competition, is driving unsustainable appetites for luxurious amenities. College was never intended to be a health and beauty spa, but a place for serious intellectual inquiry and learning. These institutions have engineered this extravagance, and they can end it.

The chase for ratings at U.S. News and World Report and other publications, and the very notion that complex institutions can be reduced to a number, is absurd – a premise on which to sell magazines. But so intimidating is the pressure to be successfully branded that colleges have bought into the system, even to the point that some have been criminally convicted of submitting false data to burnish brands. Integrity demands that colleges end their collaboration in this travesty.

Advertisement

The restoration of academic integrity must also extend to the reintroduction of an honest grading system. As a consumer-driven economy has invaded the classroom, encouraging instructors to lavish easy A grades on the customers, we are losing any sense of real excellence earned by hard work and perseverance. The result for the American economy is the risk of lethargy and entitlement, a reminder of the excesses of societies whose demise was predictable.

In view of these serious challenges to higher education in America, what is one to make of the explosion of professional athletics on our campuses? Once-unimaginable billions now dictate priorities at major conferences. Athletes disguised as students are enrolled for a year or two, are open to lucrative offers to transfer, and then, if sufficiently proficient, enter the meat grinder of the draft. Is this what higher education was intended to promote, or are we better off creating an honest farm system for aspiring professional athletes? Are we not forfeiting classroom seats for students in the name of ESPN and the Power Five?

The ineffectiveness of leadership is no more in evidence than in the pitiable response of college and university administrators’ to student activism and provocation on campus. House hearings have confirmed that campus CEOs are ill-equipped to explain and convincingly convey the complexities of their institutions. Myriad constituencies – including a diverse faculty, students (equally diverse), parents, alumni, local state and federal government agencies, the media, rating platforms, financial institutions – are among the interested groups through which a leader must navigate.

Caught off-guard by the domestication of a conflict abroad, many presidents were unable to articulate the limits of provocative speech that offended members of their communities and activism that, while an important value in a democratic society, can disrupt the lives of others who are as entitled to refrain from engagement. Without sacrificing the autonomy of each college, real leadership would encourage an effort to clarify guidelines that are generally, if not universally, accepted.

Comments are no longer available on this story