3 min read

It seemed to be ladies night at the Tuesday night concert given by the Portland Symphony Orchestra. The featured guest conductor was Ruth Rheinhardt and the piano soloist was Diane Walsh who was performing a concerto by Clara Wieck Schumanm (1819-1896).

This may have made news if it occurred some 20 years ago but should hardly raised an eyebrow today. True, female choral conductors are commonplace today, and even female band conductors are not a novelty any more. However, female orchestral conductors are still more the exception than the rule. So it was with some anticipation that I attended the PSO concert on the March 26 at the Merrill Auditorium.

I will state I was not impressed with her reading of the “Tragic Overture” by Brahms. I started to think of many unfavorable things I might have to say. Her beat where there was one was hard to locate, oft times the point of contact was up rather than down. There were wild arc swings over her head and I think that she was fortunate that the orchestra knew this piece and played it more in spite of rather than because of her. However, I must also add that her interpretation of this work was excellent, she knew what she wanted and the PSO gave her every benefit of the doubt.

The second selection of the evening was a piano concerto composed by the 15-year-old Clara Schumann. Her husband Robert orchestrated the last movement and sometime later she wrote and also scored the first two movements. I might attribute her performance more to nerves because her conducting in this piece was in stark contract to the Brahms. She had a small, concise beat with only a few over the head sweeps this time. She conducted like the professional conductor she really is.

The soloist was Portland resident Diane Walsh who played with surefire control of dynamics and technical command. The best part of the performance occurred during the 2nd movement when the orchestra stopped playing and a beautiful duet ensued with a solo cello ravishingly played by James Kennedy and Ms. Walsh doing the honors.

Ms. Schumann earned a decent living as a concert pianist in the 19th century. She had eight children with her composer husband Robert and had the young Brahms as a resident babysitter. The concerto itself calls for a virtuoso pianist (which Mr. Walsh is) and contains some lovely musical ideas but these are not developed to any extent. One must keep in mind that she was a teenager when she wrote it! Her orchestration never over shadowed the piano part in any of the movement that were played without pause. Prior to the start of the last movement there is an extended roll on the timpani which immediately caused me to think of the same event during the end of the slow movement in the “Fantastic Symphony” by Berlioz. (Who took from whom?) One also noticed that the tempi of the Overture and Concerto were a tad on the brisk side. If they were they were anything but “tad” in the “Third Symphony” (The Rhenish) by Robert Schumann which was played after intermission. The thing is that especially in the last movement, I actually liked the rocket speed of the last movement even though I suspect that the cellos and violas were less than happy with it. If there is any justice in this world, the management would take the entire brass section, especially the four horns (with its unidentified third horn) to a champagne dinner. To paraphrase a remark attributed to Napoleon concerning champagne: “If one wins a battle, one deserves it, and if one loses a battle, one needs it.” In this case, the horns deserved it as well as needed it for their heroics not only in this symphony but in the overture as well.

Ms. Rheinhardt knew this symphony very well indeed, and conducted it (as well as the overture) by heart. She conducted with authority and well as with musicality. One can easily forgive her the few fly swatting gestures she made. She is young and has a long and brilliant future before her and we were fortunate to witness her conducting near the start of a brilliant career. She received a well earned standing ovation after the Schumann.

— Dr. Morton Gold is a composer/conductor, retired educator and an arts reviewer for the Journal Tribune.

Comments are not available on this story. Read more about why we allow commenting on some stories and not on others.