5 min read

Biddeford Police Officer Jacob Wolterbeek, a 13-year veteran of the department, is shown here wearing a body camera. Officers with the Biddeford Police Department began wearing the cameras about a year ago. A bill before the Legislature that would have mandated the cameras for all law enforcement agencies in Maine is in the process of being amended to authorize a study of the use of the cameras instead. TAMMY WELLS/Journal Tribune

AUGUSTA – The sponsor of a bill that would have required all law enforcement personnel to be equipped with body cameras by 2021 on Thursday said that questions and concerns raised by a number of individuals and agencies shows that the proposal needs a more thorough examination.

Sen. Susan Deschambault, D-Biddeford, said a work session on L.D. 636 had initially resulted in an “ought not to pass” vote. Another work session two days later produced a reconsideration that is likely to result in the formation of a study committee, if later approved by both houses of the Maine Legislature – a result Deschambault favors.

A bill originally intended to mandate body cameras for all Maine police agencies is being amended to call for a study of the use of body cameras, said its sponsor, Sen. Susan Deschambault of Biddeford. TAMMY WELLS/Journal Tribune

“When I first submitted this (bill), I knew it would generate a lot of discussion,” said Deschambault on Thursday. “We know there’s enough information out there but we have to centralize it and help every law enforcement agency figure out this new tool.”

Currently, the use of body cameras is voluntary. Some agencies have them, some don’t.

Biddeford Police Department officers and detectives have been wearing body cameras for about a year. Police Chief Roger Beaupre said the department used funds from a $37,000 U.S. Department of Justice grant to purchase 23 body cameras that are electronically signed in and out to patrol officers and detectives every day. The information from the body cameras and cruiser cameras is downloaded to the police department’ system automatically.

Advertisement

Beaupre said he researched thoroughly before purchasing the body cameras, because he wanted a system that would be compatible with the cameras mounted in the police officers cruisers, for more ease of use.

Lt. Rick Doyon said preparing the video for a court case can take time, but in general, he spends about an hour a day dealing with the information downloaded from the cameras. The department has had also had success with using a “cloud” type system where a prosecutor with the York County District Attorney, for example, can access a particular video with the use of a specifically generated password, Beaupre said.

Biddeford Police Chief Roger Beaupre powers up a computer which allows officers to log body cameras in and out during their shifts under their name and assigned cruiser. Some police agencies in Maine use body cameras, some don’t. Use of the body cameras could be the subject of a study, if approved by the Legislature. TAMMY WELLS/Journal Tribune

Beaupre said the video from the body cameras allows the police agency to deal more objectively with citizen complaints and recalled the time when a citizen came in, incensed he had been issued a ticket for running a red light, and professed loudly he hadn’t done so. The citizen was shown the video from the incident.

“’I’m guilty, I’m guilty,’ the man said when he saw the video footage,” Beaupre recalled.

The Biddeford chief said in general, police officers activate the cameras when they answer a complaint. There are exceptions – when interviews involving sex assault are conducted, for instance.

He said the video is a valuable evidence tool when officers testify in court.

Advertisement

“Having video backup is convincing,” he said. “The benefits outweigh the negatives.”

Still, Beaupre said, for small law enforcement agencies with limited budgets, a state requirement for the body cameras would be an unfunded mandate.

A March 6 public hearing before the Joint Committee on Criminal Justice and Public Safety, which Deschambault chairs, saw testimony by 17 individuals and agencies on the original bill that would require the use of body cameras by 2021.

Waldo County Commissioner Amy Fowler, speaking on behalf of the Maine County Commissioners Association, said MCCA opposes the original bill largely due to budget concerns.

“The fiscal and budgetary impact alone to counties at a time when our budgets are so strongly criticized would be unimaginable, ” said Fowler. She noted associated costs, the cost of additional staff necessary to maintain and monitor the equipment, along with storage, would be expensive.

Also opposing the original bill were Maine State Police, The Maine Sheriff’s Association, and the Maine Chapter of the National Alliance on Mental Illness, among others.

Advertisement

“Our first concern is that law enforcement officers are constantly responding to calls for service for those in mental health crisis and providing emotional support,” testified NAMI Maine executive director Jenna Mehnert. “We believe it violates the privacy rights of people with mental illness or in a mental health crisis to have a video recording of them made in the middle of a struggle.”

A Biddeford woman, Brenda Dionne, whose son Chad died in 2017 during an armed confrontation in Arundel with York County Sheriffs Office deputies, testified in favor of mandating body cameras.

“Nothing will bring my son back, but going forward, these cameras can provide other families with information and substantiate accounts of what happened and provide closure,” said Dionne, in part.“These cameras can provide insight into events to help families understand the experience of their loved ones and can also provide invaluable training material.”

Kimberly Hammill, a community organizer with Bangor Racial and Economic Justice Coalition, testified that she supports the requirement and asked the committee to “make a strong case for how it can be funded.”

Tina Nadeau of the Maine Association of Criminal Defense Lawyers said the organization supports the mandate.

York County Commissioners on Wednesday voted 4-1, with Commissioner Richard Clark dissenting, to voice opposition to passage of the original bill, citing a number of issues.

Advertisement

“It’s not just the price of the equipment,” said Commissioner Michael Cote, who added other costs would be incurred as well. He suggested that a department might have to hire an individual solely to look after the video and chain of custody requirements, among other tasks.

“I don’t think it should be forced on any agency,” Cote said.

Clark, who voted against opposing the bill, said he believes body cameras will be mandatory at some point.

Deschambault said a the 13-15 member study committee, if approved by the Legislature, will research the use of body cameras, their costs and potential revenue sources to buy them, along with reviewing  practices associated with their use in and outside of Maine, whether there are collective bargaining issues associated with their use, privacy, chain of custody concerns, and more.

— Senior Staff Writer Tammy Wells can be contacted at 780-9016 or twells@journaltribune.com.

Comments are not available on this story. Read more about why we allow commenting on some stories and not on others.