4 min read

In 1940, there were eight teams in the American League. The Detroit Tigers won the pennant that year, but lost the World Series to the Cincinnati Reds, four games to three. The other American League teams, in order of finish were the Cleveland Indians, New York Yankees, Chicago White Sox, Boston Red Sox, St. Louis Browns, Washington Senators and Philadelphia Athletics.
The Tigers were led by outfielder Hammering Hank Greenberg, who batted .340 and led the American League in homers with 41 and runs batted in with 150. First baseman Rudy York also had a .316 average, 33 homers and 134 RBI.
The St. Louis Browns — sharing the City of St. Louis and Sportsman’s Park, which the Browns owned, with the St. Louis Cardinals — finished a dismal sixth, with a record of 67 wins and 87 losses. The Browns had originally played as the Milwaukee Brewers, in 1901, before being moved to St. Louis for the 1902 season.
They drew a total of 239,951 fans in 1940, the lowest total in the league, while the Cardinals were drawing only 324,078 while finishing third in the National League. That same year, the league champion Tigers were drawing 1,112,693 and the third place Yankees were attracting 988,975 in a city with three Major League teams. The population of St. Louis in 1940 was 816,048 compared with New York’s 7,454,995.
The poor attendance figures become much worse when one realizes that this was in the days before there was any revenue from television contracts or revenue sharing, and attendance and money spent at the ball park was the bulk of any team’s income.
The Browns’ owner Donald Barnes decided that St. Louis would not support two teams and had begin to explore alternatives to relocate the team. He finally decided that he would request permission to move the team to Los Angeles and become the first team on the west coast. From 1927 until 1940, the Browns had only had two winning seasons, the last one occurring in 1929. John McGuire once wrote in The Post-Dispatch, the Browns were the “nearest thing major-league baseball had to a vaudeville act.”
Meantime, the Cardinals had won the National League pennant five times from 1926 to 1940, winning three World Series and had finished in second place in the National League four times.
In 1940, baseball teams traveled by train from city to city and, partly because of the travel time between cities, St. Louis was the farthest west of any big league city. The nation’s passenger air industry was still in its infancy and had limited routes.
Although the first commercial airline route, from St. Petersburg to Tampa in Florida, had begun in 1914, air travel in 1940, prior to the jet planes of the fifties, was still limited. That air line route in Florida, operated by the St. Petersburg Tampa Airboat Line, flew the 21-mile route in 23 minutes.
Traveling by train was much more time consuming than air travel would become. Barnes had explored the travel time involved, by rail, and had worked out a baseball schedule that would make it possible for a team to play from the west coast while traveling by train. He sent his general manager, Bill Dewitt, Sr. (father of the future Cardinals Chairman) to New York to the winter meetings to pitch the idea to the owners.
According to an article in the Bay area Mercury News of January 14, 2016, after Dewitt’s presentation, “Browns’ officials believed they had the support from the league and fellow owners to gain unanimous approval when the vote would be held at the winter meetings in the second week of December, 1941.”
The team planned to move into a two-decked minor league ball park that was a landmark in Los Angeles with the familiar name Wrigley Field. The field, built in 1925, was the home to the Los Angeles Angels of the Pacific Coast League.  Los Angeles was the third largest city in the United States at the time, behind Chicago and New York — and was the only one of the three that didn’t have a Major League team.
The vote on the move was scheduled for exactly 77 years ago today, the morning of December 8. On the previous day, the Japanese bombed Pearl Harbor putting the United States in World War II. Instead of the expected unanimous vote allowing the move, the vote was unanimous not to allow the move. The St. Louis Post Dispatch reported that “The belief was that transportation would be limited in the coming season. Trains would be needed for the war effort, not for baseball’s westward expansion. The league couldn’t, with the country going to war, support the move of the St. Louis Browns, and so they stayed put.”
As it turned out, the Cardinals and the Browns both won their respective pennants in 1944 — with the talent diluted due to many ball players having joined the military — and had the last World Series played all in one ball park, with the Cardinals winning in six games. Even with a winning team, the Browns only drew 508,644 fans fifth best in the league.
Finally, after drawing just 297,238 fans in St. Louis in 1953, the Browns moved to Baltimore as the Orioles and, while still losing 100 games and finishing seventh in the league, drew 1,060,910.
If the team had moved to Los Angeles in 1941 it might have radically changed the current landscape for baseball. In 1958, the Brooklyn Dodgers and New York Giants moved to the west coast as the first teams to do so.
If the Browns were already in Los Angeles it’s possible that one of the other two would have moved to Baltimore and we would have had the Los Angeles Browns and the Baltimore Giants or the Baltimore Dodgers today.

Comments are not available on this story. Read more about why we allow commenting on some stories and not on others.