The Red Sox are facing some really tough decisions in the coming weeks and months, decisions that will be critical to their ability to repeat as World Champions next year — which this team, as constituted today, has the ability to do.
Several key players have opted for free agency, among them World Series MVP Steven Pearce, second baseman Ian Kinsler, relief pitcher Joe Kelly, closer Craig Kimbrel and starter/relievers Nate Eovaldi and Drew Pomeranz. Opting for free agency does not mean that a player cannot return to his team, it merely gives the player the ability to negotiate with any team, including the team he played for this season.

Three players — Chris Sale, David Price and Eduardo Nunez — also had options allowing they or the team to decide whether or not to return. The Sox already exercised their option on Sale and will have him back at $17.9 million next year.
Price indicated on Wednesday morning at the Sox victory parade, that he will not opt out of his contract and will return to Fenway. Under his contract he will be paid $31 million this year and $32 million a year from 2020-2022. It was a smart decision on Price’s part. The chances of a 34-year-old pitcher, no matter how well he did this season and post season, getting that kind of money on the free agent market are negligible.
Nunez had a player option to return for $5 million and is reported to be going to exercise that option. Nunez, despite the fact that he has a recurring problem with his leg, is a warrior, who gives the Sox length at second or third and a big bat. Even though it appears Pedroia will be back, he is getting older and Nunez could be key to the infield.
On top of that, the Sox, who had one of the highest payrolls in baseball this past year, approximately $228. million, depending upon which source you read, are facing salary arbitration with Betts, Bogaerts and Bradley this year which will undoubtedly raise the payroll even higher.
The easiest decision to be made is whether or not to try to resign Drew Pomeranz. Assuming Sale, Price, Porcello and Rodriguez will be back, and that Boston will go all out to retain the hard throwing Eovaldi — with Sale, Price and Rodriguez all left handers — the Red Sox have no need for another left-handed starter, particularly one who was 2-6 last year with an ERA of 6.08 and who is injury prone.
At age 37, Kinsler is another easy decision in this group. Brought over in trade from the Los Angeles Angels at the trading deadline when it had become obvious that Dustin Pedroia was probably not going to be available for the entire year, he’s the obvious odd man out at second base. Pedroia is expected to be back to start the 2019 season and, if there is a problem there, both Brock Holt and Eduardo Nunez have shown that they can handle the position.
Pearce, the 36-year-old first baseman/outfielder would not be the first World Series MVP not to return to their spot. Hideki Matsui of the Yankees signed with the Angels at the end of 2009 after winning that year’s World Series MVP. Pearce elected free agency on October 29, but could be resigned if the Sox are willing to spend the money to get him back. Pearce and Mitch Moreland provided a good platoon situation at first this year but, depending on how things fall into place with other players, Pearce could find that the Sox cannot afford him. He hit .284 between Toronto and Boston this year but, at 36, the Sox may decide to let him go.
The more difficult decisions involve the three free agent pitchers Craig Kimbrel, Nathan Eovaldi and Joe Kelly. Kimbrel can be expected to draw more money as a free agent than the Red Sox want to spend. If they could get Kelly back at a reasonable price, based on what he showed in the postseason, he might be able to fill the closer’s role and there is also Matt Barnes and Ryan Brasier who could compete with Kelly for the spot if Kimbrel goes. There are also several other free agent closers available including former Red Sox players Andrew Miller and Mark Melanson.
Eovaldi is the key player in the group of Red Sox free agents. At 29, the fireballing right hander with the 100-plus mile per hour fast ball would give the Sox their fifth starter and balance the rotation somewhat giving them three lefties and two righties.
For those among you who subscribe to the WEEI School of Nonsense, I have this to say about David Price who many of you were hoping would opt out of Boston. He had a 16-7 record, with a 3.58 ERA, with his team winning 22 and losing just 8 of the 30 games he started in 2018. He had two impressive wins in the World Series and one in the ALCS, starting and winning the clincher in both the ALCS and the World Series. He may not be worth $23 million dollars a year, but just suppose he had opted out of his contract as he could have.
If he had and entered the free agent market this year, what Major League team would you expect would be able to afford him and want him more than any other? With CC Sabathia just about at the end of his career and JA Happ the Yankees’ only other left-handed starter, and both of them on the free agent market, Price would definitely look good to the Yankees, who could afford him. In his career against the Red Sox with the Rays, Jays and Tigers, Price was 11-6, with a 3.08 ERA and in 23 starts against the Sox had averaged 6.6 innings per start. Tell me again how it would have been better for the Red Sox if he had opted out only to return to Fenway as a Yankee with those bats behind him.
Dave Dombrowski has his work cut out for him trying to keep as much of this team intact as possible. The big key to him will be trying to keep the cost in future years as low as possible to make it possible to be able to afford Betts, Bradley, Bogaerts, Benintendi and the rest of the young players as they become eligible for free agency in the next few years.
Unfortunately, the reality of the baseball business today is that building a winner is easier than retaining a winner. The 1998, 1999 and 2000 Yankees were the last team to win back-to-back World Series Championships. The 2019 Red Sox team could be the next to do it.
Comments are not available on this story. Read more about why we allow commenting on some stories and not on others.
We believe it's important to offer commenting on certain stories as a benefit to our readers. At its best, our comments sections can be a productive platform for readers to engage with our journalism, offer thoughts on coverage and issues, and drive conversation in a respectful, solutions-based way. It's a form of open discourse that can be useful to our community, public officials, journalists and others.
We do not enable comments on everything — exceptions include most crime stories, and coverage involving personal tragedy or sensitive issues that invite personal attacks instead of thoughtful discussion.
You can read more here about our commenting policy and terms of use. More information is also found on our FAQs.
Show less