5 min read

I recently did a very unscientific survey to try to determine how much action actually occurs during a baseball game. I, very arbitrarily, picked the three-game Red Sox series against the Kansas City Royals last weekend and the Red Sox four-game series with the Texas Rangers from May 3 to May 6 of this season for my survey.
Figuring that the action in a ball game, for the average fan, occurs when a ball is put in play, I simply divided the number of minutes from start to finish in a ball game by the number of times during that game that the ball was put in play.

Carl Johnson

In the Royals series when, if you remember there was plenty of action with the Sox scoring 42 runs on 50 hits, the average time between balls put in play was 3.56 minutes. In the Texas series, which the Sox won three games to one and outscored the Rangers 22-18, the average time between balls in play was 3.53 minutes. The average time between balls in play in an individual game ranged from a low of 2.89 minutes to a high of 4.41 minutes.
Of course, for the dedicated fan of baseball, this methodology does not give an accurate picture of the action in a game. The average fan, who attends or watches a ball game occasionally, does not appreciate all the action and drama that goes on between balls put in play. The average fan does not see the signing that takes place between the dugout and the players, from player to player, from the third base coach to the batter and base runners or things like the subtle movement of players as a pitch is being delivered in response to the signs of the catcher, the tendencies of the batter, etc., etc.
Dan Shaughnessy, writing in the Boston Globe, recently noted “For the first time in history, baseball features more strikeouts than hits. This will be the 11th consecutive season in which MLB sets a record for strikeouts.”
This will also be a record breaking year for home runs which is one of the main reasons for strikeout totals being so high.
It doesn’t take a genius to realize that a large part of the excessive reliance on home runs has led to the overabundance of strikeouts. Why are players so focused on hitting home runs that they strike out at the alarming rate that they do? Power hitters, most of whom are natural pull hitters, face a defense that saturates their natural hitting area and, as a result, try to beat the shifts by hitting over them.
The result is that they now are more concerned with increasing their “launch angle” instead of concentrating on hitting line drives and letting the home runs take care of themselves. Anybody who had played baseball, or even back yard wiffle ball, knows that the flatter your swing is the greater chance that you will make solid contact with the ball, or “barrel it up’” as they say today. Unfortunately, the shifts have lowered the percentages of success for line drive hitters.
The increasing use of analytics and the reliance on past performance to anticipate where a ball will be hit, have resulted in the shifts that drive the home run craze. Hitters with long ball capability realize the futility of trying to hit through the shifts and increasingly go for the long ball, trying to hit over the shift, which increases the number of pitches, strike outs and the time between balls put in play.
Even someone as clueless as Major League Baseball Commissioner Rob Manfred is aware that part of the problem stems from the extensive use of analytics to change the character of the game. In the same article as above Dan Shaughnessy quotes the commissioner as saying “there is a growing recognition that analytics have produced certain trends in the game that we may need to be more proactive about reversing. There are owners that feel that way. There are fans that feel that way.”
Baseball has focused on the pace of the game as the problem creating the loss of interest in the game among the “Plugged in Generation.” So far, they have been unable to make a significant difference in the length of time taken to play a game. Things like starting extra innings with a runner in scoring position and similar ideas make no sense and would have little effect upon the time between balls put in play which is the real problem with this demographic that can’t leave their devices for a three or four hour game.
The one change that has been proposed and would make a significant difference is the pitch clock. This change is being tested in the minor leagues and may be implemented at the major league level next year. Reducing the time between pitches by just five seconds a pitch could reduce the average game by 20-30 minutes.
The elimination of the radical shifts by requiring that the infielders remain in their positions prior to the pitch would reduce the incentive to hit the long ball by making the line drive or bloop base hit a better percentage play and would reduce the number of strikeouts and home runs and the time between balls put in play. This could be accomplished by requiring that the shortstop and third baseman have one foot on the third base side of the diamond and the second baseman and first baseman do the same on their side of the infield prior to the pitch being delivered.
The real action in baseball, for the casual or dedicated fan, is not in the home run. It is in the series of plays such as the single followed by a hit and run which sends the runner to third and he then scores on another hit or a sacrifice fly. That is what baseball is all about and what the geeks have taken away from us. Restoring the real action in a baseball game is the solution, not gimmicks that do little but make work for the geeks that created the problem.
This change would be hard to implement as most teams today have come to rely on analytics or Sabremetrics and have staffs of geeks on their payroll and, as a result, the owners have a commitment.
If they want to continue to realize the financial benefits of the game, they had better realize that the fans want action in a game and begin to implement change, like this, that increases the action in a game, while shortening the game. Making the games shorter is a partial solution, making them shorter and more exciting is the real answer to dwindling attendance.

Comments are not available on this story. Read more about why we allow commenting on some stories and not on others.