Just how good are the Yankees and Red Sox, really?
All we heard before the season, after the Yankees picked up Giancarlo Stanton and Boston finally signed what they called the last piece of their puzzle, J. D. Martinez, was that the Yankees and Red Sox would run away from the rest of the field and battle it out for the American League East title. Red Sox and Yankees fans were sure that their team was the best and would win the World Series.
In New England, since long before the season started, the rest of the teams in both the American and National Leagues had been written off before a pitch was thrown.

On Thursday morning of this past week, with exactly 100 games left on the Red Sox schedule, the Sox were in first place in the American League East and the Yankees were just one game behind. Boston had the best record in baseball, 43-19, and the Yankees the second best at 40-18.
As expected, the rest of the American League East had all but dropped out of the race by that day, with Tampa Bay in third, 14 games back, Toronto in fourth, 16 1/2 games behind and Baltimore last, already 23 games behind and ready to begin rebuilding by unloading players and salaries.
In the rest of the American League, the surprising Seattle Mariners, with a 38-23 record, were the closest to the Red Sox, leading the West and trailing the Sox by just 4? games. The closest National League team to the Red Sox was another surprise, Milwaukee, just six back.
It looks like the answer to the original question, “Just how good are the Yankees and Red Sox” is VERY GOOD!
Before you make hotel reservations for New York or Boston for the World Series, which, by the way, will be played the last week in October, remember that there were 100 games left to play before the playoffs start on October 3 and 4. The reality is, anything can happen between now and then and the possibility of predicting what teams will be there at the end is next to zero even as good as the Yankees and Red Sox look now.
The Red Sox, as of the close of play on June 5, led all of baseball as a team in batting average, .267, runs scored 327, hits 570, total bases 998. The Yankees led all of baseball in home runs with 96, with the Sox second at 90, in slugging percentage .470, while the Sox were a close second at .467. The Yankees were fifth in average at .257, second in runs 326 and second in hits 512.
The Red Sox pitching staff had the eighth best ERA in baseball at 3.56 with the Yankees 12th at 3.73 and the Sox pitchers had the second best strikeout total at 593 with the Yankees fifth best at 579.
Individually, on offense, Betts and Martinez have been running away with the races. Betts led in average at .359, on base percentage .437, slugging percentage .750, and runs scored 52, tied with Mike Trout. Martinez, the nicest surprise, to date, that Red Sox fans have had in a long time, led baseball in homers with 20 and RBI with 50.
On the other hand, the Yankees’ big hitters Stanton and Judge are not living up, so far, to earlier expectations. Stanton had 14 homers and 33 RBI to go with his .251 batting average and 78 strikeouts in 58 games. Judge had 17 homers and 43 RBI, a .274 batting average and had struck out 84 times in 58 games.
These numbers are all based on what has happened to date and there is no way to predict whether a hitter, pitcher or team will continue to perform as he has, go into a slump, get into a hot streak, get injured or traded or what of the dozens of other things that can happen and affect individual or team performance the rest of the way.
As the man says in the money management advertisements “past performance is no guarantee of future success” this is as true in sports as anywhere else and perhaps more true in baseball than other sports. Remember the Miracle Mets, the Red Sox comeback in 2004 or their collapse in 2011.
The only thing any of the experts can tell you now is that the Yankees and Red Sox have been the real thing for more than a third of the season and therein lies the rub, there is still almost two thirds of a season to play.
I can tell you that for my money, a pitching staff with starters Chris Sale, Rick Porcello, Eduardo Rodriguez, David Price, Steven Wright — with, hopefully, Drew Pomeranz returning to have a second half as he did last year — backed up by Joe Kelly, Rick Barnes, Heath Hembree, Hector Velazquez, Brian Johnson, with Brandon Workman back, and the best closer in baseball Craig Kimbrel is better than the Yankees have to offer for the rest of the season. In addition, Johnson and Velazquez have proven their ability to be spot starters.
I’ll take them over the Yankees’ starters Luis Severino, Masahiro Tanaka, and his questionable elbow, CC Sabathia, who is never far away from his next injury, Sonny Gray and, now that Jordan Montgomery is gone for the season heading for Tommy John surgery, Domingo Germain. Their lack of starting depth will hurt them as the season goes on and their bullpen with Chad Green, Chason Shreve, David Robertson, Adam Warren, Dellin Betances and closer Aroldis Chapman does not match up with the Sox relievers.
The Sox also have Carson Smith and Tyler Thornburg on the disabled list and it is expected that they will both return to their bull pen duty in the next several weeks.
The Yankees, of course, always have the ability to spend the money to come up with help on their roster when they need it. Given the composition of the two teams as they stood on Thursday, I think we can expect the anticipated battle to the finish between these two powerhouses, but look for the Red Sox depth in the starting and relief pitching to be the key to this race.
Comments are not available on this story. Read more about why we allow commenting on some stories and not on others.
We believe it's important to offer commenting on certain stories as a benefit to our readers. At its best, our comments sections can be a productive platform for readers to engage with our journalism, offer thoughts on coverage and issues, and drive conversation in a respectful, solutions-based way. It's a form of open discourse that can be useful to our community, public officials, journalists and others.
We do not enable comments on everything — exceptions include most crime stories, and coverage involving personal tragedy or sensitive issues that invite personal attacks instead of thoughtful discussion.
You can read more here about our commenting policy and terms of use. More information is also found on our FAQs.
Show less