4 min read

Jesse Harvey, founder of the Journey House LLC sober living program, is shown here in this October 2017 file photo. Harvey and Journey House LLC have filed a complaint with the federal Department of Housing and Urban Development alleging the City of Biddeford discriminated against the sober house, violating federal law. TAMMY WELLS/Journal Tribune file photo
Jesse Harvey, founder of the Journey House LLC sober living program, is shown here in this October 2017 file photo. Harvey and Journey House LLC have filed a complaint with the federal Department of Housing and Urban Development alleging the City of Biddeford discriminated against the sober house, violating federal law. TAMMY WELLS/Journal Tribune file photo
BIDDEFORD — The founder of a sober living program has filed a complaint with the federal Department of Housing and Urban Development, alleging housing discrimination by the city of Biddeford and its codes officer.

The city, through its attorney, Keith Jacques, denies the allegations.

Jesse Harvey, the registered agent for Journey House LLC filed the complaint March 27 on behalf of Journey House and himself. Harvey declined comment when reached by telephone on Saturday. 

Journey House LLC, which offers sober living to those in substance recovery, began renting an apartment at 45 Hill St. in Biddeford in December 2016. Journey House subsequently opened two sober residences in apartment buildings in Sanford, one for men, and one for women. According to its social media page, Journey House plans to open a sober living residence in Lewiston on May 1.

In the complaint, Harvey alleges discrimination by Biddeford occurred on Oct. 19, 2017.

Advertisement

Harvey alleges the city used zoning and land use ordinances to discriminate against residents of the sober residence, citing sections of  the Rehabilitation Act of 1973, The Civil Rights Act of 1968 as amended by the Fair Housing Act of 1988, and the Americans with Disabilities Act of 1990.

The brief narrative in the complaint states six adult men were living in the sober house when the city and its code officer Roby Fecteau allegedly told the landlord that “this was an illegal operation since the building did not have a sprinkler system.”  

In the complaint signed by Harvey, when told there was case law on the subject Fecteau allegedly said he was not concerned with case law. 

The complaint goes on to say the sober house subsequently shut down.

The city, in its answer to Journey House LLC and filed with HUD, says the city’s representatives never told the complainant’s landlord that the sober house operating in one of the apartments was of his building was an  illegal operation.

“Moreover, at no time did the city tell complainants that the operation was an illegal use or that the complainants needed to vacate the apartment,” Jacques wrote in the city’s response.  He went on to write that while city representatives initially expressed concern that the operation might need to be classified as a rooming house within a multi-unit apartment building, thereby potentially requiring a sprinkler system within the unit, the complainants continued to operate the sober house within the apartment building while the city sought clarification from the State Fire Marshal’s Office.

Advertisement

Jacques wrote that the city believes Journey House operated the sober house in the unit from December 2016 to December 2017, when, he said, they voluntarily vacated the apartment and moved operations to Sanford. He said that at the time Journey House left the Biddeford premises, the city was still awaiting a determination from the State Fire Marshal.

Jacques wrote that when the city became aware of the sober house operation, the primary focus was to assure the multi-use apartment building was safe for occupants. He said when two people living in the sober house unit applied for General Assistance, the landlord completed a Landlord Verification of Rental Unit which spelled out that a building inspection might be required if one had not been conducted in a year.

Since there had not been one for some time, according to Jacques’ response, the General Assistance office requested an inspection. Jacques said when the Codes Enforcement Office attempted to schedule an inspection, the complainant refused to provide access to the unit.

Jacques said zoning issues were not the focus of the Code Enforcement Officer’s request for in inspection, but that it was to determine if the unit complied with life safety standards.

According to information provided to the parties by HUD’s Region 1 Office of Fair Housing and Equal Opportunity, until a determination of  ‘reasonable cause’ or ‘no reasonable cause’ is reached, HUD must offer the parties any reasonable opportunity to settle the matter through voluntary conciliation. 

Region 1 director Susan M. Forward in a letter to the city said the law requires HUD’s investigation to be completed within 100 days. Among the points she raised, Forward wrote that if there is not evidence establishing jurisdiction, or no cause is found, the case would be dismissed. She wrote that if cause is found, HUD must issue a charge. At that point, the matter may be heard by an Administrative Law Judge or referred for trial at the U.S. District Court.

Advertisement

A fire erupted at the multi-unit building at 45 Hill St., on the morning of April 2. An elderly resident, 88-year-old Arnold Goldman, perished in the blaze and several families were displaced.

— Senior Staff Writer Tammy Wells can be contacted at 324-4444 (local call in Sanford) or 282-1535, ext. 327 or twells@journaltribune.com.


Comments are not available on this story. Read more about why we allow commenting on some stories and not on others.