Ken-David Masur, a music director finalist was the conductor at a Portland Symphony Orchestra concert at Merrill Auditorium on March 20. In my lifetime I have observed many exceptional orchestral conductors and I wish to state at the outset that on the basis of this appearance that he is ready to take his place in that august company.
The program began with a spirited as well as expressive reading of Mozart’s Overture (to his opera) The Clemency of Tito which he wrote in 1791 the same year of his death. The orchestra responded to Mr. Masur’s every gesture and one must recognize the lovely playing of principal clarinet and bassoon, respectively Thomas Parchman and Janet Polk.
What followed was an electric rendition of Beethoven’s 5th (and final) piano concerto No. 5 with Natasha Paremski as soloist. With her initial entrance I was more interested and pleased with her playing. The fingers of her left hand should be registered as possible lethal weapons. Where Beethoven wrote a melodic phrase for the right hand he gave the left hand a faster moving counter melody. She blazed right through this as if it really wasn’t difficult at all! Her attacks were powerful where called for and delicate where indicated.
Masur, with baton this time alternately followed and led. The slow movement was a joy to hear and every section of the reduced orchestra (winds and brass in twos and no trombones or tuba) were worthy accompanists. Paremski’s biographical sketch indicated that she has been soloist with many orchestras and while I can’t say if her approach to other composers would be as idiomatic as her essaying of this Beethoven concerto but I would not at all be surprised if it would be. She earned a standing ovation and gave an affectionate hug to Mr. Masur who modestly shared her triumph in which he had a significant role.
After intermission the sole work to be performed was the Symphony No. 6 by Antonin Dvorak. He composed this work in 1860 and it was first performed the following year. When I was a student Mr. Dvoarak was credited with but five symphonies. However the list was expanded to nine in the mid-1950’s. Most folks are familiar with No. 8 (the old No. 4) and No. 9 (the Symphony from the New World, the old No. 5.) While this is probably true, it is also probably true that Mr. D is best remembered for his magnificent Cello Concerto. Therefore I will not disgrace myself if I confess that I had not listened to this symphony before. I must confess that I find this symphony to be an excellent work both from the standpoint of musical architecture as well as orchestration. Mr. Masur, minus baton again, led what I believe to be a personal as well as dynamic reading of this work. Yes, this was a live performance and there were a few (very few) glitches along the way. The celli were not always unanimous in some of their entrances for example. However, the playing of the orchestra, especially the violas in the second movement, the principal flute, Lisa Hennessy are worthy of praise and as well as the entire brass section. Again, I was impressed with the sonority of the violins. Mr. Masur’s interpretation as well as his knowledge of the music, the way he communicated his wishes (musically and not show boating) were most impressive.
At the conclusion of the symphony, the orchestra took the unusual procedure of applauding their conductor and were reluctant to share the ovation by taking a bow. He could have chosen familiar works which would have presented the orchestra with fewer frequent and potential problems but instead chose works which would challenge them. In both concerts they rewarded him with excellent performances. It is not for me to suggest who the powers that be should select as the new music director. I would suggest, however, that they give Mr. Masur very careful consideration. Mr. Moody’s last concert as music director will take place on April 29 and May . The sole work to be performed will be Mahler’s 2nd Symphony.
There will be a radio broadcast of Mr. Masur’s concert on Maine Public Radio on April 4.
— Dr. Morton Gold is a conductor/composer, retired educator and an arts reviewer for the Journal Tribune.
Comments are not available on this story. Read more about why we allow commenting on some stories and not on others.
We believe it's important to offer commenting on certain stories as a benefit to our readers. At its best, our comments sections can be a productive platform for readers to engage with our journalism, offer thoughts on coverage and issues, and drive conversation in a respectful, solutions-based way. It's a form of open discourse that can be useful to our community, public officials, journalists and others.
We do not enable comments on everything — exceptions include most crime stories, and coverage involving personal tragedy or sensitive issues that invite personal attacks instead of thoughtful discussion.
You can read more here about our commenting policy and terms of use. More information is also found on our FAQs.
Show less