4 min read

 

Former York County Probate Judge Robert M.A. Nadeau, who was suspended from the practice of law in Maine for two years by the state’s highest court last fall has been issued a reprimand in connection with a child support case he heard during his last term as probate judge. FILE PHOTO
Former York County Probate Judge Robert M.A. Nadeau, who was suspended from the practice of law in Maine for two years by the state’s highest court last fall has been issued a reprimand in connection with a child support case he heard during his last term as probate judge. FILE PHOTO

PORTLAND — Robert M.A. Nadeau, who was suspended from the practice of law in Maine for two years by the state’s highest court last fall, has been issued a reprimand in connection with a child support case he heard during his last term as York County Judge of Probate.

The Maine Supreme Judicial Court, in a decision issued Thursday, wrote that Nadeau should have recused himself from a 2016 hearing involving an individual who had made negative social media postings against him, to which his wife responded. Nadeau had, in his brief to the court, noted he was aware of the posting.

In May 2016, Nadeau signed a scheduling order for the case involving the individual in which he noted that the probate court would consider the judge’s disqualification at the hearing.

According to the opinion handed up Thursday by the state’s highest court, Nadeau described what followed as him serving “in the capacity of a settlement judge only,” as he negotiated the retroactive starting date for a child support obligation, the ongoing income verification the payer would be required to provide, and the terms under which she would provide it.

There was discussion among the parties about whether Nadeau would recuse himself, with Nadeau saying he would do so if an evidentiary hearing were to be scheduled. After discussion, the parties involved agreed to the terms of the child support agreement that had been worked out, court documents show.

Advertisement

At the conclusion of the hearing, Nadeau denied, without prejudice, a motion made by the individual for him to recuse himself and to transfer the case to another court.

Nine days later, the woman who had made the social media posting and who was a principal in the child support hearing filed a complaint against Nadeau with the Committee on Judicial Responsibility and Disability. She asserted, in part, that Nadeau “intentionally refused to recuse himself, with full knowledge and awareness of his clear bias, in an effort to retaliate against, humiliate and bully me for speaking out against him in the upcoming election,” court documents say.

The high court wrote that Nadeau was required to recuse himself, because of the woman’s social media posting about him and his wife’s direct contact, also through social media, with her about it; the fact Nadeau was aware of it and, the court wrote, his own acknowledgement that he had a bias against the individual at the outset of the hearing.

“Despite the litigant’s indication that she was ‘uncomfortable’ with the process, Judge Nadeau actively participated in negotiating and ultimately approving the final result, which, as evidenced by the detailed directive to (the individual) concerning her potential future income, required considerable judicial involvement,” the justices wrote.

In a response to an emailed request for comment, Nadeau said the high court’s decision “underscores the problems regarding Maine’s probate courts, each of which only has one elected part-time judge not supported by the state court system.”

“When confronted with a disqualification issue as every judge experiences from time to time, a probate judge and the parties appearing before him have very limited options,” Nadeau wrote. “In the case of the York County Probate Court, the judge must try to transfer the case to a probate judge in an adjacent county.”

Advertisement

“The only counties adjacent to York County are Cumberland County in Portland and Oxford County in distant South Paris,” he wrote. “During my tenure as judge, neither of those county’s then sitting probate judges accepted transfers of any cases from York County, due to their own workloads. This created a stalemate unfair to York County parties.”

He noted that none of the parties involved appealed his approval of the child support agreement.

“My willingness to approve the bare bones child support agreement spared both sides substantial delays, while enabling them to stop paying legal fees sooner rather than later and ensuring that the child would receive some modest level of support without unnecessary, further delays,” Nadeau wrote.

Nadeau’s license to practice law in Maine was suspended for two years on Oct. 1 after his bid for a reconsideration was rejected by the Maine Supreme Judicial Court.

Following complaints filed by the Committee on Judicial  Responsibility and Disability, the justices in June found Nadeau violated judicial canons when he directed probate court staff not to make court appointments to seven attorneys; regarding his removal of a previously appointed attorney from pending cases; his issuance of orders urging litigants appearing before him to lobby for increased court time, and his personal solicitation of campaign contributions for his 2016 election campaign.

Nadeau served several terms as York County Judge of Probate. He was first elected in 1996 and again in 2002 and 2004. He lost the 2008 election, but was returned to the bench in 2012. He lost in a three-way race to Sanford Attorney Bryan Chabot in November 2016.

— Senior Staff Writer Tammy Wells can be contacted at 324-4444 (local call in Sanford) or 282-1535, ext. 327 or twells@journaltribune.com.

 

 

Comments are not available on this story. Read more about why we allow commenting on some stories and not on others.