5 min read

Carl Johnson
Carl Johnson
Baseball has, over the past 25 years, taken steps to reduce the financial advantage that large market teams have over the smaller market teams in order to give the smaller market teams the ability to compete more effectively. Revenue sharing, which gave a bigger piece of the revenue pie to the smaller market teams, was instituted to help redress the imbalance.

Under the original conditions of revenue sharing, each team, small market and big market alike, contributed 31 percent of its net local revenue to a pot which was then divided equally among the 30 teams. Obviously, the bigger market teams contributed more and got back less while the reverse was true for the smaller market teams.

In addition, what Fangraphs calls “a large chunk of MLB’s central fund is set aside to be allocated to teams based on their revenues.” The Central Fund is money that MLB acquires through such things as national television broadcasts.

As of last year, revisions were made to the distribution of the “local revenue” pot and the top fifteen teams no longer receive a share in return, although they still contribute to the pot. Instead, after the pot is divided, they get reimbursed the same amount that the smaller market teams get. 

While the intent of the program was to give the smaller market teams the ability to pay higher salaries and thereby acquire a better quality of player and, thereby, make them more competitive on the field, some of the teams put the money into other areas thus defeating the purpose of the program.  

Advertisement

Never the less, as Fangraphs and most experts acknowledge “Although the plan is far from perfect, it has managed to give small market teams a much needed boost in order to keep them on somewhat-competitive footing with large market teams.” 

In addition the smaller market teams receive competitive balance draft picks allowing them an advantage in the annual draft of players. For example, the Minnesota Twins, who finished with the worst record in baseball last year got first pick in this year’s Amateur Draft.

A look at the American League standings at the start of play on June 20, may give you an idea of whether or not revenue sharing is working or at least contributing to leveling the playing field. 

In the American League Central Division, on that date, those Minnesota Twins, who finished in last place in the division last year, with the worst record in baseball, including 103 losses, were in second place, 2½ games behind the Cleveland Indians, with a record of 34-33, two games ahead of second place Cleveland. Cleveland, another small market team, as everyone know, took the Cubs to seven games before losing the 2016 World Series.

In the American League West, the Houston Astros were running away with the division, leading the second place Los Angeles Angels by 12 games. The Astros, who finished in third place last year, 9½ games behind the Texas Rangers, had the best record in baseball with 47 wins and 24 losses despite dropping their last four in a row.  

The Astros are not one of those small market teams, but they are ranked 15th in revenue, just one spot from being in the small market. Although they have a huge population base in the Houston area, their revenues are low, probably because of the competition with football which has always been king in Texas.

Advertisement

On the other hand, the Yankees, perhaps the largest market or revenue generator, with the exception of the Los Angeles Dodgers with their huge television contract, were leading the American League East by one half game over the second place Red Sox.  

The Yankees, who unloaded many of their astronomical salaries at the end of last year, still had, according to Spotrac, the third highest team salary in baseball, $201 million, down from the second highest $213 million in 2016.  Only the Dodgers, at $245 million and the Boston Red Sox, at $202 million have a higher payroll this year than the Yankees.

The Yankees were expected to be in a rebuilding year this year with many relatively low paid young players in their starting lineup but those youngsters have contributed much earlier than  expected leading to the Yankees quick start.

In the National League, small market teams led in both the Central and Western Divisions on June 20. Colorado, who finished in third in the Western division last year, 16 games out with a 75-87 record, was 46-26 in first place and led the second place Los Angeles Dodgers by ½ game. In the Central Division, another small market team, the Milwaukee Brewers, who finished in fourth last year, with a record of 73-89, 30½ games back, were in first, with a record of 38-34, 1½ games ahead of the world champion Chicago Cubs. 

Since the year 2000, in seventeen seasons, in each league, nine teams of the fifteen, or 18 of the total of 30, have appeared in the World Series. In that period, all fifteen current American League teams have advanced to the League Championship Series at least once before being eliminated.   (That number includes the Houston Astros’ appearance in the World Series as the National League representative in 2005 before being moved to the American League.)

In the National League, in that same period 12 different teams have made it to the League Championship Series at least once. (That number includes the Houston Astros who have since moved to the American League. )  

Advertisement

Of the four current National League teams that have not made it to the League Championship Series, the Pittsburgh Pirates have been in the Wild Card game twice and advanced to the League Division Series once in the last five years; the Cincinnati Reds have advanced to the League Division Series twice since 2011 and the San Diego Padres have advanced to the League Division Series twice since 2005. The Washington Nationals, who have been in the league since 2005, advanced the League Division Series three times since 2012.

With 60 percent of all thirty teams having appeared in the World Series in the past sixteen years and almost 90 percent having advanced at least once to their League Championship Series in the same period, it would appear that revenue sharing or the other actions baseball has taken to level the playing field are working. If not, some other factor or factors have made baseball as competitive as it has ever been for the last 16 years.

Whatever the cause, Major League Baseball has come closer to achieving parity among their teams than any of the other major professional sports. 


Comments are not available on this story. Read more about why we allow commenting on some stories and not on others.