The 2016 New York Yankees held a fire sale around the trading deadline last year and still managed to finish six games above 500 with an 84-78 record. A lot of familiar faces, including Alex Rodriguez, Mark Teixeira, Andrew Miller, Brian McCann and Nathan Eovaldi will not be back in the Bronx this year when the Yankees open their new season.
With a starting pitching staff that is headed up by 28 year old Masahiro Tanaka, who won 14 and lost 4 last year and 39-16 in his three years with the Yankees and not much more in the way of starting pitching, the Yankees could be in for a long season. After Tanaka, they will rely on Michael Pineda, 28, who won only six while losing 12 with a 4.82 ERA, and the aging C. C. Sabathia, who won nine and lost 12 last year, and whose health and ability is questionable at best. Nathan Eovaldi, who was 14-3 in 2015 and 9-8 last year, had Tommy John surgery in August and will miss the season.
Luis Severino, the Phenom who ended up 3-8 with a huge 5.83 ERA in 22 starts, despite his ability to throw in the high nineties, may get the fourth slot. Adam Warren, 29, who has been a reliever except for one year, 2015, when he had 17 starts and has never pitched more than 131 innings in a year, or Bryan Mitchell, who had five starts last year may fight for the number four or five starter position. Justus Sheffield, a 20 year old right hander, who was 10-6 between A and AA ball with a 3.09 ERA, and is highly rated, could also compete for one of the starting slots.
There are almost as many questions in the position players as there are in the starting pitching. They are planning on Gary Sanchez to be their number one catcher after trading Brian McCann to Houston. Sanchez had a great debut last year, with 20 home runs in 53 games and a .299 batting average, all at the end of the season. In six years in the Minor Leagues, he never hit more than 18 homers in a year, so the Yankees have to hope that he will continue last year’s production as their regular catcher. If not, Austin Romine, who hit .242 in 62 games last year and has a total of 139 Major League games behind him is the backup.
They face a similar situation at first base. Greg Bird is expected to be the regular first baseman. In 2015, in his debut, in 46 games, he hit .261 with 11 homers and 31 RBI’s before having surgery on his right labrum and missing all of 2016. It would be nice if he and Sanchez could continue their hitting and be regulars. If Bird doesn’t, 25 year old, Tyler Austin, who hit .241 in 31 games last year could get the nod at first.
Up the middle, the Yankees look strong, with second baseman Starlin Castro, at 26 already a veteran of seven years in the Big Leagues and hitting .270 with 21 homers and 70 RBI’s last year, teamed up with Didi Gregorius, 26, who hit .276 with 20 homers and 71 RBI’s at short.
The aging Chase Headley, 32, will be back at third. He hit .253 with 14 homers and 51 RBI’s last year while making 25 errors at third for the second year in a row. The Yankees could use a better defensive third baseman who could produce more at the plate and could turn to 24 year old Ronald Torreyes, who got into 72 games, 34 at third last year and hit .258. They also have Rob Refsnyder, 26, who hit .250 in 58 games, mostly as an outfielder but he can fill in in the infield as well.
Brett Gardner, 33, will be back in left after a so so year in his ninth year with the Yankees. He hit just
.261 with only seven homers and 41 RBI’s after being an All Star in 2015 with 16 homers and 66 RBI’s. He and Jacoby Ellsbury, 33, the center fielder, who helped power the Yankee offense with their speed before last year, both fell off in stolen bases. Gardner had just 16 and Ellsbury 20. Ellsbury hit .263 with just 9 homers and 56 RBI’s batting leadoff over half the time and played in 148 games an unusually high number for the injury prone outfielder. Gardner still managed to win the Gold Glove.
In right field, it looks like a battle between highly touted youngster Aaron Judge, 24, who got into just
27 games and hit only .179 last year and Aaron Hicks, who the Yankees got from Minnesota last year and who played in 123 games but only hit .217.
On December 7, 2016, the Yankees signed 37 year old Free Agent Matt Holliday and plan to use him as a Designated Hitter. The right handed Holliday has a career .303 average, with 295 homers and 1,153 RBI’s in 16 years but had his worst year at the plate last year, hitting just .246 with 20 homers and 62 RBI’s.
The bullpen, bolstered by the return of Closer Aroldis Chapman who they re-signed on Decemebr 15 as a Free Agent, also has many questions. Chapman, of course, went to the Cubs in the fire sale at the trading deadline and helped them to a World Championship before the Yankees got him back as a Free Agent. He was 4-1 between New York and Chicago with a 1.55 ERA and 36 saves in 39 attempts.
With Chapman back, Dellin Betances will revert to his set up role. Betances, who I believe has the best stuff of any pitcher in baseball, had a 3.06 ERA last year in 73 games. He had 126 strikeouts in 73 innings and has pitched in 70 or more games in each of the last three years.
Veteran Tyler Clippard, acquired from Arizona, appeared in 69 games last year between the two with a 3.57, Chasen Shreve, who was in 37 games but had a 5.18 ERA, Tommy Layne, acquired from Boston, who was in 63 games between the two teams and had a 3.63 ERA, and Richard Bleier, 23 games and a 1.96 ERA will probably get the bulk of the relief work with a group of promising youngsters fighting for spots in the Spring.
The Yankees have a lot of young talent both on the roster and in the high minors but there are too many question marks to expect them to challenge for the Division this year. However, Manager Joe Girardi proved again last year that he is one of the best in the game when he kept his team in the race almost until the end even after the Yankees had unloaded most of his aging talent in late July.
The name of the game is pitching, though, and, without major improvements from their existing rotation or trading for a couple of starters, the Yankees don’t have it. Their back of the bullpen, with Betances and Chapman, is among the best in baseball but you have to give them leads to protect or their talent is wasted.
Don’t look for the Yankees to challenge the Red Sox for the Eastern Division this year.
Comments are not available on this story. Read more about why we allow commenting on some stories and not on others.
We believe it's important to offer commenting on certain stories as a benefit to our readers. At its best, our comments sections can be a productive platform for readers to engage with our journalism, offer thoughts on coverage and issues, and drive conversation in a respectful, solutions-based way. It's a form of open discourse that can be useful to our community, public officials, journalists and others.
We do not enable comments on everything — exceptions include most crime stories, and coverage involving personal tragedy or sensitive issues that invite personal attacks instead of thoughtful discussion.
You can read more here about our commenting policy and terms of use. More information is also found on our FAQs.
Show less