BIDDEFORD — A U.S. First Circuit Court of Appeals has upheld a ruling favoring Amtrak in a wrongful death case stemming from an April 2012 accident that took the life of a Biddeford resident.
In a ruling dated Nov. 18, the court upheld U.S. District Court Judge D. Brock Hornby’s decision to grant summary judgement to Amtrak after its popular Downeaster train struck and killed Biddeford resident Sean Page on Nov. 16, 2012.
Judges Ojetta Rogeriee Thompson and William J. Kayatta of the First Circuit Court of Appeals, and Judge Paul J. Barbadoro of the District Court of New Hampshire, presided over the appeal.
Page, 40, a local tattoo artist, was struck and killed by Downeaster train 686 as it headed from Portland to Boston about 100 yards from Biddeford’s Main Street, nearby to a spot that cuts through from Cutts Street to West Cutts and Western Streets.
The victim’s wife, Valerie Page, filed a lawsuit against the passenger railroad, saying her late husband had a “superior right” to use the area in which the incident occurred, and that his death was caused as a result of Amtrak’s negligence.
The appeals court upheld Hornby’s previous decision on the grounds that Amtrak did not act negligently as it had no duty of care to the deceased, citing existing Maine law that states a person may not, without right, stand or walk on a railroad track unless being transported by a train.
“In our view, this case begins and ends with the first principle of negligence: there must be ‘a duty of care owed to the plaintiff,’” the judges wrote in the ruling. “Here, Amtrak owed no such duty.”
Valerie Page was also unable to prove that Sean Page did, in fact, have a right to stand, cross or walk on the premises, following with her insistence Amtrak prove ownership of the tracks and her assertion that Amtrak operates its trains too fast to stop for pedestrians.
Hornby previously said that Amtrak was not required to prove ownership of the tracks, and Maine case law does not obligate Amtrak to stop for pedestrians.
The Journal Tribune reported following the accident that the area where the accident occurred is owned by Pan Am Railways. The Northern New England Passenger Rail Authority, Maine’s public transportation authority, holds a contract with Amtrak to run the Downeaster.
“Having carefully reviewed the papers and Maine’s old, but still controlling, case law and statutes, we see no reason to disturb the district court judge’s well-reasoned and thorough decision,” the ruling reads. “We therefore affirm the entry of summary judgment substantially on the basis of Judge Hornby’s comprehensive opinion with respect to the lack of a duty owed.”
Sean Page was a resident of 61 West Cutts St., and nearby residents said at the time the spot is a popular shortcut for pedestrians between the streets in the area. The judges also wrote that, while Amtrak already owed no duty to Page, that a collision at a railroad crossing is an act of negligence on part of the traveler.
“This component of the analysis is of no moment because Amtrak owed no duty in the first instance,” the ruling states. “Affirmed, and each party shall bear its own costs.”
Amtrak Spokeswoman Christina Leedshere told the Journal Tribune at the time there were no injuries to the train’s crew or 55 passengers in the accident, which delayed train service in the area for three hours in both directions.
— Staff Writer Alan Bennett can be contacted at 282-1535, ext. 329 or abennett@journaltribune.com.
Comments are not available on this story. Read more about why we allow commenting on some stories and not on others.
We believe it's important to offer commenting on certain stories as a benefit to our readers. At its best, our comments sections can be a productive platform for readers to engage with our journalism, offer thoughts on coverage and issues, and drive conversation in a respectful, solutions-based way. It's a form of open discourse that can be useful to our community, public officials, journalists and others.
We do not enable comments on everything — exceptions include most crime stories, and coverage involving personal tragedy or sensitive issues that invite personal attacks instead of thoughtful discussion.
You can read more here about our commenting policy and terms of use. More information is also found on our FAQs.
Show less